U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Logic]

Spoiler: show

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

Sounds fake to me

All of it, or just one part?

[Maple]

Spoiler: show

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

Sounds fake to me

All of it, or just one part?

Enough of it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

If me and Nanook end up in DVC, that isn't on me

If you’re town I’ll take the blame!

[sheepsaysmeep]

i hardclaim villa

[sheepsaysmeep]

i really dont know how to react lol idk im not sure this makes logic wolf

[sheepsaysmeep]

brb vanity searching in wolfchat of a game that just ended

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

The initial misunderstanding was mine and I misread a lot of things that day lol

In absence of someone who knows how to read Logic, I am gonna say Logic might just be a villager

@Adam_ got me vibes from this (as a follow-up)

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

[mention]NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME[/mention] my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Spoiler: show

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Spoiler: show

Logic
Sheep

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

[Hyena]

Spoiler: show

why does wolf me go to bat for sloonei like that?

Pocketing, setting him up to get yeeted if you die first, and/or general wickedness ... there’s a lot of reasons

Spoiler: show

colonialbob Can you expand on your thoughts on Sloonei wagon?

Majority of Sloonei voters are from off-site (I know Sloonei is a good player but we're not going to have the same attitude towards Sloonei that Syndicate players are, nor has he represented a strong intention to hardcore solve the game)

So I don't think your take that it's an opportunistic attempt to remove the strongest player around is accurate. Syndicate players (or rather, you and DDL that I recall) have generally been like 'gotta give Sloonei a d1 pass', which is stranger to me and even TMI-y given the dissonance between the respect given and Sloonei's investment

Is it normal for Sloonei to take d1s off?

so Sloonei is a player who's super townleader-y. lots of analysis, pushing and prodding, asking good questions, the lot. so for one thing he's a super strong asset for town if he's town. (even when he tunnels me hardcore )

however, that playstyle is understandably tiring, and I've played in several games with ol' sloondog where he clearly did not want to put forth that effort. he was still helpful, still contributed, and importantly was still town. this game so far reminds me strongly of those games. I can totally see him choosing that style for this giant wacky game.

colonialbob Can you expand on your thoughts on Sloonei wagon?

Majority of Sloonei voters are from off-site (I know Sloonei is a good player but we're not going to have the same attitude towards Sloonei that Syndicate players are, nor has he represented a strong intention to hardcore solve the game)

So I don't think your take that it's an opportunistic attempt to remove the strongest player around is accurate. Syndicate players (or rather, you and DDL that I recall) have generally been like 'gotta give Sloonei a d1 pass', which is stranger to me and even TMI-y given the dissonance between the respect given and Sloonei's investment

Is it normal for Sloonei to take d1s off?

so Sloonei is a player who's super townleader-y. lots of analysis, pushing and prodding, asking good questions, the lot. so for one thing he's a super strong asset for town if he's town. (even when he tunnels me hardcore )

however, that playstyle is understandably tiring, and I've played in several games with ol' sloondog where he clearly did not want to put forth that effort. he was still helpful, still contributed, and importantly was still town. this game so far reminds me strongly of those games. I can totally see him choosing that style for this giant wacky game.

Can you point me to examples of the bolded? (In this game)

I agree with you that he would do this as villager for the reasoning he's supplied (semis coming up) fwiw. I think the style itself is fairly NAI, but I would like your opinion on the thoughts he's given a lot

he's been doing things that allow other people to make reads imo (early voting etc). he's thrown some sus on people for reasons, i like the reasoning. he's kinda been a nice piece of bait. and Epi has been doing his Epi thing and I think it's caught some people out.

also i liked his "they're all village posts" response a lot a lot tbh

These are my "explainy" posts, both in response to questions directly to me from jumpluff. This case is poo.

Maybe

hmm Colin sheeped a sus of me that was different than his logic. sheep called out my original votes as overexplainy, Colin said that also pinged him but went after my explanation of Sloonei.

would appreciate outsider's opinions on that

Here’s what I want an outsider’s opinion on: what the heck kind of name for a person is “Sweeney Todd”? First name Sweeney last name Todd? We all just gonna let that slide?

Here's some more Colin+Cbob stuff.

[Maple]

If sheep is a wolf, just change my UT to quote "dogshit" quote

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

I believe the claim

Don’t think it necessarily makes sheep mafia tho, “from an unknown source” sounds uh

Not super reliable?

[Timsup2nothin]

If me and Nanook end up in DVC, that isn't on me

If you’re town I’ll take the blame!

mumble mumble irresistible force mumble immovable object mumble KABOOM mumble mumble...

[iaafr]

oh wait

i think i know what the source might be and it's not trustable

sheeps still villa

[Maple]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

I believe the claim

Don’t think it necessarily makes sheep mafia tho, “from an unknown source” sounds uh

Not super reliable?

Agreed, sheep is a villagery mfer

[Hyena]

That's all of the CBob+Colin stuff I remember. After it, I interacted with Colin a bit. I can pull that up, too, if you want.

[iaafr]

i think logic receiving that message confirms him villa though

though we already kinda knew that from the same check

[DaisyCloud]

Wait, you think BOTH of Colin and CBob should be shot? There was some interesting hostile interactions between them earlier. I'll pull them up for you.

I remember that

[Timsup2nothin]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

I believe the claim

Don’t think it necessarily makes sheep mafia tho, “from an unknown source” sounds uh

Not super reliable?

Yeah it's all sketchy as shit. Why hold a red check, even if the source is sketch? Put it out there and let everyone work through it...NOT with an ITA session bearing down, but like...when you get it...

I'm pretty sure that shooting window doesn't open so we can work this out after.

[Timsup2nothin]

Give me a better name to put in the last opportunity we have astounded the odds makers by killing six people already window...

Five minutes.

GO

[DaisyCloud]

Spoiler: show

why does wolf me go to bat for sloonei like that?

Pocketing, setting him up to get yeeted if you die first, and/or general wickedness ... there’s a lot of reasons

Spoiler: show

colonialbob Can you expand on your thoughts on Sloonei wagon?

Majority of Sloonei voters are from off-site (I know Sloonei is a good player but we're not going to have the same attitude towards Sloonei that Syndicate players are, nor has he represented a strong intention to hardcore solve the game)

So I don't think your take that it's an opportunistic attempt to remove the strongest player around is accurate. Syndicate players (or rather, you and DDL that I recall) have generally been like 'gotta give Sloonei a d1 pass', which is stranger to me and even TMI-y given the dissonance between the respect given and Sloonei's investment

Is it normal for Sloonei to take d1s off?

so Sloonei is a player who's super townleader-y. lots of analysis, pushing and prodding, asking good questions, the lot. so for one thing he's a super strong asset for town if he's town. (even when he tunnels me hardcore )

however, that playstyle is understandably tiring, and I've played in several games with ol' sloondog where he clearly did not want to put forth that effort. he was still helpful, still contributed, and importantly was still town. this game so far reminds me strongly of those games. I can totally see him choosing that style for this giant wacky game.

colonialbob Can you expand on your thoughts on Sloonei wagon?

Majority of Sloonei voters are from off-site (I know Sloonei is a good player but we're not going to have the same attitude towards Sloonei that Syndicate players are, nor has he represented a strong intention to hardcore solve the game)

So I don't think your take that it's an opportunistic attempt to remove the strongest player around is accurate. Syndicate players (or rather, you and DDL that I recall) have generally been like 'gotta give Sloonei a d1 pass', which is stranger to me and even TMI-y given the dissonance between the respect given and Sloonei's investment

Is it normal for Sloonei to take d1s off?

so Sloonei is a player who's super townleader-y. lots of analysis, pushing and prodding, asking good questions, the lot. so for one thing he's a super strong asset for town if he's town. (even when he tunnels me hardcore )

however, that playstyle is understandably tiring, and I've played in several games with ol' sloondog where he clearly did not want to put forth that effort. he was still helpful, still contributed, and importantly was still town. this game so far reminds me strongly of those games. I can totally see him choosing that style for this giant wacky game.

Can you point me to examples of the bolded? (In this game)

I agree with you that he would do this as villager for the reasoning he's supplied (semis coming up) fwiw. I think the style itself is fairly NAI, but I would like your opinion on the thoughts he's given a lot

he's been doing things that allow other people to make reads imo (early voting etc). he's thrown some sus on people for reasons, i like the reasoning. he's kinda been a nice piece of bait. and Epi has been doing his Epi thing and I think it's caught some people out.

also i liked his "they're all village posts" response a lot a lot tbh

These are my "explainy" posts, both in response to questions directly to me from jumpluff. This case is poo.

Maybe

hmm Colin sheeped a sus of me that was different than his logic. sheep called out my original votes as overexplainy, Colin said that also pinged him but went after my explanation of Sloonei.

would appreciate outsider's opinions on that

Here’s what I want an outsider’s opinion on: what the heck kind of name for a person is “Sweeney Todd”? First name Sweeney last name Todd? We all just gonna let that slide?

Here's some more Colin+Cbob stuff.

I tried to multi quote so I had the other one you shared too.
preview never gives me the other post.

[Timsup2nothin]

That's all of the CBob+Colin stuff I remember. After it, I interacted with Colin a bit. I can pull that up, too, if you want.

We're good for now...if we kill both to get one wolf it's actually good returns.

[DaisyCloud]

Give me a better name to put in the last opportunity we have astounded the odds makers by killing six people already window...

Five minutes.

GO

not saying they should be shot at or anything but has anyone said anything about long con?

I'm on mobilr. have they posted? or are they like Shizune and we hope MacDougall subs/modkills or something?

I got them as null in my notes and lots of ????

[Hyena]

whoever bothered killing Liberal did well tbh
Third parties should be dealt with kills, lynching them is wasting town best weapon

I feel like this is the third or fourth time I've seen someone make this exact post.

Thats likely because it is almost a truism tbh
I should be doing better but I gotta be honest I'm still trying to understood how the tools on this site work.

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

^ This is who I'm probably shooting at.

[Timsup2nothin]

I will tell you for free that my next tier is people who are pretty fucking townie and everyone is gonna have a cow if I start talking about shooting them.

[Hyena]

That's all of the CBob+Colin stuff I remember. After it, I interacted with Colin a bit. I can pull that up, too, if you want.

We're good for now...if we kill both to get one wolf it's actually good returns.

Yeah, that's fair actually. I'm cool with that.

[Maple]

I will tell you for free that my next tier is people who are pretty fucking townie and everyone is gonna have a cow if I start talking about shooting them.

We're all thinking about it already, ideally it doesn't come to that.

[Timsup2nothin]

Give me a better name to put in the last opportunity we have astounded the odds makers by killing six people already window...

Five minutes.

GO

not saying they should be shot at or anything but has anyone said anything about long con?

I'm on mobilr. have they posted? or are they like Shizune and we hope MacDougall subs/modkills or something?

I got them as null in my notes and lots of ????

Long Con has some pretty good stuff going for him. Not clear forever but for today is my position.

[Timsup2nothin]

whoever bothered killing Liberal did well tbh
Third parties should be dealt with kills, lynching them is wasting town best weapon

I feel like this is the third or fourth time I've seen someone make this exact post.

Thats likely because it is almost a truism tbh
I should be doing better but I gotta be honest I'm still trying to understood how the tools on this site work.

I commend whoever removed the “trustworthy” liberal from our ranks. Neutrality like that is best dealt with separately, and not with the power of the vote.

It is rather interesting that you posted this literally after fox talked me off for doing so
I don't think there is any pattern but it could actually be a way to people feign contribution (yeah I'm not one to talk but still)

^ This is who I'm probably shooting at.

This shot is approved.

[Maple]

I liked Iwan today

[WerewolfHunter]

Currently enjoying some other things but will def try and be on during ita once I figure out how to format it

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Give me a better name to put in the last opportunity we have astounded the odds makers by killing six people already window...

Five minutes.

GO

not saying they should be shot at or anything but has anyone said anything about long con?

I'm on mobilr. have they posted? or are they like Shizune and we hope MacDougall subs/modkills or something?

I got them as null in my notes and lots of ????

LC probably town if maple is mafia, meaningful vote on xalt D1

[Timsup2nothin]

I will tell you for free that my next tier is people who are pretty fucking townie and everyone is gonna have a cow if I start talking about shooting them.

We're all thinking about it already, ideally it doesn't come to that.

Too many townie town towns round here. Makes me uncomfortable.

[DaisyCloud]

Give me a better name to put in the last opportunity we have astounded the odds makers by killing six people already window...

Five minutes.

GO

not saying they should be shot at or anything but has anyone said anything about long con?

I'm on mobilr. have they posted? or are they like Shizune and we hope MacDougall subs/modkills or something?

I got them as null in my notes and lots of ????

Long Con has some pretty good stuff going for him. Not clear forever but for today is my position.

oh okay. cool cool

[DaisyCloud]

do we get 1 shot or 2?

[iaafr]

do we get 1 shot or 2?

1, i assume

15% hitrate

good luck

[DaisyCloud]

I will tell you for free that my next tier is people who are pretty fucking townie and everyone is gonna have a cow if I start talking about shooting them.

We're all thinking about it already, ideally it doesn't come to that.

Too many townie town towns round here. Makes me uncomfortable.

iirc there is only a small handful of scum left? or am I misreading what you are saying?

[Timsup2nothin]

I liked Iwan today

I was watching from the cone of silence and was unimpressed. Not like "a wolf a wolf, chop instantly" but nothing like he was someone we can't get along without checking the hard way.

[WerewolfHunter]

I'm prob Shooting 10K here

[DaisyCloud]

do we get 1 shot or 2?

1, i assume

15% hitrate

good luck

ok thank you. and I need the luck too so appreciate that.

[Timsup2nothin]

I will tell you for free that my next tier is people who are pretty fucking townie and everyone is gonna have a cow if I start talking about shooting them.

We're all thinking about it already, ideally it doesn't come to that.

Too many townie town towns round here. Makes me uncomfortable.

iirc there is only a small handful of scum left? or am I misreading what you are saying?

I'm saying there are at least some wolves who right now have us fooled.

[Logic]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

I believe the claim

Don’t think it necessarily makes sheep mafia tho, “from an unknown source” sounds uh

Not super reliable?

Yeah it's all sketchy as shit. Why hold a red check, even if the source is sketch? Put it out there and let everyone work through it...NOT with an ITA session bearing down, but like...when you get it...

I'm pretty sure that shooting window doesn't open so we can work this out after.

I dunno about you, but I sit on a redcheck as long as possible to see if spew happens.

I didn't see a lot to implicate sheep is scum or potential partners.

As for the source of the check: I was up front about it and did not claim to have a cop check myself.

[Iwan]

whoever bothered killing Liberal did well tbh
Third parties should be dealt with kills, lynching them is wasting town best weapon

I feel like this is the third or fourth time I've seen someone make this exact post.

Thats likely because it is almost a truism tbh
I should be doing better but I gotta be honest I'm still trying to understood how the tools on this site work.

If it helps town you may as well tbh
I have a weakass role and never could really get you guys
Maybe im gonna need a couple games to actually start getting it here.

[iaafr]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

This is disturbing. It is also short notice.

@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME my inclination is to add Sheep into that final window, assume Logic and Sheep will both survive, and we can sort this out after. Opinion?

I believe the claim

Don’t think it necessarily makes sheep mafia tho, “from an unknown source” sounds uh

Not super reliable?

Yeah it's all sketchy as shit. Why hold a red check, even if the source is sketch? Put it out there and let everyone work through it...NOT with an ITA session bearing down, but like...when you get it...

I'm pretty sure that shooting window doesn't open so we can work this out after.

I dunno about you, but I sit on a redcheck as long as possible to see if spew happens.

I didn't see a lot to implicate sheep is scum or potential partners.

As for the source of the check: I was up front about it and did not claim to have a cop check myself.

i have mechanical information that points to your message very likely being fake and from mafia

which is a good look for you and sheep

please dont ita sheep

[Iwan]

anyway there should be like 6 mafia left
Is that right ?

[Iwan]

or did more scum die

[iaafr]

anyway there should be like 6 mafia left
Is that right ?

something like that yeah

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Probably five

[Iwan]

I liked Iwan today

Im not sure i like this buddying
I have been doing a pretty poor game tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

or did more scum die

Too many janitored kills to be really sure but I think there's three to five.

[Iwan]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Spoiler: show

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Spoiler: show

Logic
Sheep

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

why are you and mapples alive tho m