U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[Justplayingitcool]

Oh now I fucked up the size tags

[Justplayingitcool]

@sprityo @Justplayingitcool why are you voting me and who else are you considering voting?

Depending on Long Con's answers, I may vote for them. You're in PoE territory.

[iaafr]

what if i claim i can kill myself at the end of any phase, day or night, and bring back sheep as a confirmed?

[iaafr]

because i am in fact claiming that

[Apogee]

Interesting rabbit

Actually that's kinda a broken role you have there lmao

LIke >>> than a town suicide bomber or desperado

[iaafr]

yeah my roles broken imo

and ive seen a lot of other op town roles flip

part of why im not taking this game too seriously but eh

[iaafr]

i should stop being lazy and relying on mech to clear myself when i could just do work but ughhhhhh so lazy

[iaafr]

i should stop being lazy and relying on mech to clear myself when i could just do work but ughhhhhh so lazy

[Long Con]

Hyena has died.

He was a heart emoji.

Each night you will give someone a heart emoji. This is a bulletproof vest. If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die.

Town.

Hyena targeted Logic last night. Hyena died last night. One interpretation of that would be that Logic was mafia.

Logic is the same alignment as Nanook. If Logic is mafia, then Nanook is mafia.

Do you believe that to be the case? And how is Hyena targeting Logic lead to them being mafia?

"If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die."

Hyena gave Logic a vest.

Hyena died.

[iaafr]

it is kinda baffling every day to see sprit just end up on me with no explanation though

[Apogee]

Hyena has died.

He was a heart emoji.

Each night you will give someone a heart emoji. This is a bulletproof vest. If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die.

Town.

Hyena targeted Logic last night. Hyena died last night. One interpretation of that would be that Logic was mafia.

Logic is the same alignment as Nanook. If Logic is mafia, then Nanook is mafia.

Do you believe that to be the case? And how is Hyena targeting Logic lead to them being mafia?

"If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die."

Hyena gave Logic a vest.

Hyena died.

This is possible

However scum like 95% had to shoot hyena cause he'd just keep clearing players otherwise

Not a bad thought though

[Justplayingitcool]

Hyena has died.

He was a heart emoji.

Each night you will give someone a heart emoji. This is a bulletproof vest. If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die.

Town.

Hyena targeted Logic last night. Hyena died last night. One interpretation of that would be that Logic was mafia.

Logic is the same alignment as Nanook. If Logic is mafia, then Nanook is mafia.

Do you believe that to be the case? And how is Hyena targeting Logic lead to them being mafia?

"If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die."

Hyena gave Logic a vest.

Hyena died.

Lol. Shows how much attention I have been paying to this game

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Do you seriously think that mafia would EVER not shoot hyena? Or that I’d push hyena to give a vest to my partner kek

Like c’mon dude wait to be scummy until we can release DDL from his prison

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Rabbit if you tag out does Eph come back too or just sheep?

[iaafr]

Rabbit if you tag out does Eph come back too or just sheep?

just sheep

in general just one eaten town of my choice (literally cannot use with nontown)

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Noice

Idk if it’s better to get confirmed sheep back

Or gobble someone else tonight and do it tomorrow

[iaafr]

ya idk im just kinda paranoid of dying to this wagon of 2 lmao

but ill do some re-eval sorting tonight

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Eh you might be a NK target too, maybe just better to bring sheep back, idk

[Apogee]

Yeah you're now a better than vig

That's a top NK

[sprityo]

@sprityo @Justplayingitcool why are you voting me and who else are you considering voting?

Poe is iaafr, JPIC, Long Con, drwilgy, Logic, bee boy, apogee.

I’m gonna work on cutting this down when possible.

I need to know why long con is a poisoner but not mafia???

And if rabbit can bring sheep back then I fully endorse it


Side note- I got the least powerful role here,

[Long Con]

Do you seriously think that mafia would EVER not shoot hyena? Or that I’d push hyena to give a vest to my partner kek

Like c’mon dude wait to be scummy until we can release DDL from his prison

You are a guy who claims to be a master of mechanics... until a possibility arises when mechanics could point to you, then talking about it is a scum tell.

I need to know why long con is a poisoner but not mafia???

I don't understand, could you rephrase the question please?

[WerewolfHunter]

we could test iaafrs role here.

since logic and nanook are same alignment chance their both neutral

looks like ephemeral has been removed from the list

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Do you seriously think that mafia would EVER not shoot hyena? Or that I’d push hyena to give a vest to my partner kek

Like c’mon dude wait to be scummy until we can release DDL from his prison

You are a guy who claims to be a master of mechanics... until a possibility arises when mechanics could point to you, then talking about it is a scum tell.

I need to know why long con is a poisoner but not mafia???

I don't understand, could you rephrase the question please?

I mean dude

Hyena was obviously going to die last night

We fucking talked about it during the night phase even kek

[sprityo]

[mention]Long Con[/mention] poisoner is a mafia/anti town role.

So what is your alignment and why are you not being lynched? I missed this whole part of the claim fiesta

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I don’t hate half of sprit’s POE

as for the other half

I don’t hate half of sprit’s POE

[WerewolfHunter]

hmm where do we go now.

I agree that iaafr needs to be careful not to accidentally reach parity. However, if telling the truth i think thats impossible

I think best bet is to go logic as same alignment as nanook and that can tell us something here. however, there can be alignment view modification so thats not set

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It seems obvious to me that we kill DDL/sprit/LC in some order kek

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should be planning for two mafia KP a night obviously, if bob or hyena were shot by town that’s fairly atrocious

[WerewolfHunter]

It seems obvious to me that we kill DDL/sprit/LC in some order kek

I'm fine with that however spirityo seems to feel good and getting info from spec chat could be useful

i also feel that going logic can tell us some stuff

[Long Con]

@Long Con poisoner is a mafia/anti town role.

So what is your alignment and why are you not being lynched? I missed this whole part of the claim fiesta

Like Joseph said:

"In this game the players pre-selected their character, not their alignment or role. 100% of alignments were selected based on randomisation. No single player was specifically selected to a certain alignment. The roles were designed based on three factors: enjoyment of the player, flavour of the character and the alignment they rolled."

Poisoner is no more a mafia role in this game than stump or vigilante.

[Long Con]

Do you seriously think that mafia would EVER not shoot hyena? Or that I’d push hyena to give a vest to my partner kek

Like c’mon dude wait to be scummy until we can release DDL from his prison

You are a guy who claims to be a master of mechanics... until a possibility arises when mechanics could point to you, then talking about it is a scum tell.

I need to know why long con is a poisoner but not mafia???

I don't understand, could you rephrase the question please?

I mean dude

Hyena was obviously going to die last night

We fucking talked about it during the night phase even kek

You know what I find towny? Objectivity. You completely lost yours when I suggested an obvious possibility for Hyena's death.

[sprityo]

Spoiler: show

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

dank i was lowkey scumreading him again recently

hmmm was rabbit the only one that suspected sheep? Besides logic I guess

[iaafr]

it wasnt a serious suspicion and i later correctly realized that the report received by logic was generated by ephemeral (who has a role that can send a message that appears to be from the host to a player every night)

which i thought cleared both logic and sheep which makes the logic push rn ?!??!??!

[Long Con]

it wasnt a serious suspicion and i later correctly realized that the report received by logic was generated by ephemeral (who has a role that can send a message that appears to be from the host to a player every night)

which i thought cleared both logic and sheep which makes the logic push rn ?!??!??!

Yeah, that is a good argument that Logic is town. The idea being that ephemeral would not send a red check on his own partner, nor would he send it to his teammate. Unless that's the point... wait, Logic is town because he received the message?

[iaafr]

yeah because why would they send a fake red to a teammate to out it

[Long Con]

Why wouldn't they?

[DaisyCloud]

Hyena has died.

He was a heart emoji.

Each night you will give someone a heart emoji. This is a bulletproof vest. If you give a mafia a bulletproof vest you will die.

Town.

Hyena targeted Logic last night. Hyena died last night. One interpretation of that would be that Logic was mafia.

Logic is the same alignment as Nanook. If Logic is mafia, then Nanook is mafia.

Hyena was always dying tonight

What I’m more interested in is why none of the vig shots hit

I wish bob had told us who he was checking but ig that’s partly my fault for not telling him to

Nanook's first comment after the night post was to make it known that Hyena was a big target last night. If Nanook is scum, then this is instant Damage Control, to deflect from the idea that Hyena's role found scum.

this is why we should all be voting logic

[DaisyCloud]

it wasnt a serious suspicion and i later correctly realized that the report received by logic was generated by ephemeral (who has a role that can send a message that appears to be from the host to a player every night)

which i thought cleared both logic and sheep which makes the logic push rn ?!??!??!

what? I legit read this 5x and I don't understand any of it.

[iaafr]

Why wouldn't they?

because the role lets them gaslight a nonmafia player and if they wanted to fake red somebody with one of their team, they could do it without using that particular action?

[iaafr]

it wasnt a serious suspicion and i later correctly realized that the report received by logic was generated by ephemeral (who has a role that can send a message that appears to be from the host to a player every night)

which i thought cleared both logic and sheep which makes the logic push rn ?!??!??!

what? I legit read this 5x and I don't understand any of it.

logic received a message indicating sheep was mafia

i deduced that ephemeral's role was the likely culprit behind the message

that made me suspect both logic and sheep were not on the scumteam because why would they use a role that can send a mod message to anybody to one of their own to fake guilty sheep?

[DaisyCloud]

@Long Con poisoner is a mafia/anti town role.

So what is your alignment and why are you not being lynched? I missed this whole part of the claim fiesta

Like Joseph said:

"In this game the players pre-selected their character, not their alignment or role. 100% of alignments were selected based on randomisation. No single player was specifically selected to a certain alignment. The roles were designed based on three factors: enjoyment of the player, flavour of the character and the alignment they rolled."

Poisoner is no more a mafia role in this game than stump or vigilante.

does this mean MacDougall likes me/enjoys me as a player in mafia?

@MacDougall

also I was town poisoner in a game. jsn

not that I think it clears you or anything. you are so hard to read. long con! it's not fair

[Long Con]

They could. A tracker could see the real thing to give more credence to the claim. And it obviously wouldn't do to have a message sent to someone else, AND Logic to claim he got one. Are you SURE the reasoning behind giving Logic towncred for this holds up?

[iaafr]

They could. A tracker could see the real thing to give more credence to the claim. And it obviously wouldn't do to have a message sent to someone else, AND Logic to claim he got one. Are you SURE the reasoning behind giving Logic towncred for this holds up?

im not 100% sure but logic isnt one of my priorities for today

but sure you guys can flip him idc still better than voting me

[Long Con]

I don't know if a Logic yeet is the right way to go, I'm just seeing some big assumptions about his alignment that I don't think are credible at all under some scrutiny.

[iaafr]

gonna ask again

does anybody have any good reasons for townreading sprityo?

only time i ever recall this question asked was daisycloud with some nebulous "liked some stuff he posted"

[iaafr]

answered*

[DaisyCloud]

it wasnt a serious suspicion and i later correctly realized that the report received by logic was generated by ephemeral (who has a role that can send a message that appears to be from the host to a player every night)

which i thought cleared both logic and sheep which makes the logic push rn ?!??!??!

what? I legit read this 5x and I don't understand any of it.

logic received a message indicating sheep was mafia

i deduced that ephemeral's role was the likely culprit behind the message

that made me suspect both logic and sheep were not on the scumteam because why would they use a role that can send a mod message to anybody to one of their own to fake guilty sheep?

I just.. i find it hard to believe that you can communicate to eph and sheep.

1 reasons why i have doubts about this and you.

a player in my community who is sooo good we jking/serious gave him a church, a mafia church. this player in a game fake claimed medium and posted a screen shot of a chatzy that was supposed to show him and the dead players talking. it was all fake. he was mafia. iirc i was town cop. town ultimately won. it was my first time ranking cop. I didn't even know Godfather was a thing. we had a gf in game. guess who I checked? the gf. guess who I hard core defended the gf. lucky for town things hot sorted.

I'm still very naive but I do my best to not be. I have trudt issues when players or player say they can have communications with other players who are dead or cannot speak in some way.

[iaafr]

ok

i honestly dont know how to respond to your continued doubts because i have no way to prove im not lying except by activating the power i said i could activate that kills myself and puts sheep back into the game

which i kinda just want to do because im really not into this game at this point

[DaisyCloud]

gonna ask again

does anybody have any good reasons for townreading sprityo?

only time i ever recall this question asked was daisycloud with some nebulous "liked some stuff he posted"

lol, I did. still kinda do. but i seriously question it. since my strongest town reafs all found him in various places of scum.

it's probably stuff like this that I am still alive. my reads are bad. I can't find the wolves.

bet spirtyo, sabie are mafia.

[Long Con]

gonna ask again

does anybody have any good reasons for townreading sprityo?

only time i ever recall this question asked was daisycloud with some nebulous "liked some stuff he posted"

His roleplaying game is top notch with all those images of his character with the different moods and expressiveness.