It's not clear that it's ill-conceived to me tbh. Mac's only premise is that someone is lying in you/tim/ted, which seems likely since the night action claims are inconsistent. I don't believe that you have a reason to lie and that's why I didn't suspect you at all a couple of day phases, but the POE is shrinking and just about everyone else has been checked clean, so... who's mafia if not you/ted? Is it the dyachei slot? Oddmerta? I'm planning to cop dyachei tonight unless Mac says otherwise, and I have mech reasons to believe that Oddmerta is town.Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 2:40 amI'm not saying you are definitely scum. I have no fucking clue, if that's not clear. But I severely dislike you saying "Mac says" when it surrounds something that clearly is very ill conceived, and I think you should know that. Clearly, I don't claim to be tracker, a role that can be verified in terms of the results it necessarily will give. And clearly I don't make up some useless lie about a track that couldn't have found place. You will have better luck trying to argue me mafia tracker or something. Do not claim I could have lied, cause I don't believe you believe that. And you didn't a few days ago. I don't see how that logic has changed for you. And I don't see why you need to see "Mac says".
I also absolutely dislike that you use the language of checking Ted to "get a better idea about Dizzy". You should check Ted in hopes he turns up mafia. Why are you ready to argue that I would be godfather for some reason, but anyone else who comes up town can't be? What I dislike is that this is very bad in the case that Ted is indeed town. I don't know though. Maybe he's scum, then great, forget I said anything. I've been riding rest of town this whole game, I've kind of had to. Sorryboutit. You all clearly have a better grasp on this game than I do. But I still have the right to call things as I see it and question when something doesn't sit right with me. And I still think cop is odd one out and a role that doesn't seem to fit this setup very much. I just do. Again, I might be wrong.
I had my suspicions on you being godfather because you were begging to be checked and that's godfather behavior lol. But I no longer have those suspicions since tutuu has pointed out that samu spewed there being no godfather. My general point is that like, why are you so worried about the possibility of ted being town when from your POV every piece of evidence points to him being scum?
Also "your cop claim is unbelievable because it doesn't fit the setup" is a nonsensical accusation. What about the setup doesn't it fit? I'd say 3 trackers doesn't fit the setup more than a cop, and I'm willing to buy 3 trackers. If you're going to want to get me exed you're going to have to do way better than that.