Hatch thread

#51

G-Man

Eloh
DFaraday

MovingPictures07

insertnamehere

I'll find time today to elaborate on these individually.

#52

Considering that he's not on the lynch poll, I'm guessing that Soneji wasn't rezzed (if Rico hit the failsafe).

I'll get my list up in a few minutes.

#53

Condensing my list should have been easier but it wasn't. I'm still working through that re-read but I'm trying not to focus too much on just you five. Don't want to get shortsighted.

Elohcin
Quin

Insertnamehere

MovingPictures07
DFaraday

#54

I hit play and danced a jig, G. Thanks for the music.

Quin wrote:Me, because I have a power role.

Why would you say this. Do you WANT to be killed? Or are you mafia?

I was thinking MP as well. I think he is civ and I can imagine the baddies picking to off him early.

------------------------------
woah woah woah.....this is nuts. So we are stuck in the hatch for day 2? And Rico is dead. So one of the Hatchlings are bad for sure.

#55

Can't go long without making a list.

Here's a revised list of who claimed hatch, in order. I'll work on specifying the claim times tomorrow.

Hatch claim / Overall claim

1/1. Elohcin
2/2. Quin
3/3. DFaraday
4/5. Ricochet
5/10. Insertnamehere
6/12. MovingPictures07
7/13. G-Man

#56

Elohcin
G-man
Insertnamehere
DFaraday
MovingPictures07
Quin

After finding out Rico was killed, this is my rainbow list of those here in the Hatch.

linki...what do you mean by hatch claim/overall claim?

#57

Elohcin wrote:I hit play and danced a jig, G. Thanks for the music.

Quin wrote:Me, because I have a power role.
Why would you say this. Do you WANT to be killed? Or are you mafia?

I was thinking MP as well. I think he is civ and I can imagine the baddies picking to off him early.

------------------------------
woah woah woah.....this is nuts. So we are stuck in the hatch for day 2? And Rico is dead. So one of the Hatchlings are bad for sure.

I said it the first time at the very beginning of the game. Why are you picking up on it now?

#58

Can the waiting until tomorrow part. Here are the claim times now. Game thread went up on 12/4/16 @ 7:22pm

G-Man wrote:Hatch claim / Overall claim

1/1. Elohcin- 12/4/16 @ 7:51pm (first post)
2/2. Quin- 12/4/16 @ 9:12pm (fourth post)
3/3. DFaraday- 12/4/16 @ 10:55pm (first post)
4/5. Ricochet- 12/5/16 @ 5:45am (third post)*
5/10. Insertnamehere- 12/6/16 @ 11:25am (eighth post)
6/12. MovingPictures07- 12/6/16 @ 5:49pm (sixth post)
7/13. G-Man- 12/6/16 @ 7:14pm (30th post)

*Rico didn't actually state that he was staying at the Hatch outright. This is the post that I was counting as his claim. Going back for the claim times helped me notice the vague nature of the post. I don't suppose our host can clarify if he counted that as a full-on claim?

Linki: Hatch claim is the order just we Hatchlings claimed the Hatch. Overall claims is the order we claimed any location out of the whole group of 13.

#59

Sorry I'm late, I was in the bathroom doing heroin. I mean...looking for peanut butter. For heroin. I mean Clairoin. I mean Claire.

Anyway, I don't think it's a coincidence that two of Rico's top suspects, G-Man and Elo (who incidentally were both up for lynching before that last second save), were here in the hatch with Rico and he turns up dead. WIFOM and all that, but right now I'd wager it's one of those two.

#60

G-Man looks worse than Elo in this regard since she claimed hatch before Rico did. I mean to get to the other hatch residents as well, but I'm almost likely not voting for any of the beach dwellers this time, since we know for a fact that a baddie is here. Unless someone can present an outstanding case for one of them, I'll be voting someone on our side.

#61

DFaraday wrote:Sorry I'm late, I was in the bathroom doing heroin. I mean...looking for peanut butter. For heroin. I mean Clairoin. I mean Claire.

Anyway, I don't think it's a coincidence that two of Rico's top suspects, G-Man and Elo (who incidentally were both up for lynching before that last second save), were here in the hatch with Rico and he turns up dead. WIFOM and all that, but right now I'd wager it's one of those two.

I could still argue INH could have done it considering he even said he would if he were bad. But then he'd say something about WIFOM and that conversation would be over pretty quickly. \_(:/)_/

#62

I want Eloh to answer my question.

#63

DFaraday wrote:Sorry I'm late, I was in the bathroom doing heroin. I mean...looking for peanut butter. For heroin. I mean Clairoin. I mean Claire.

Anyway, I don't think it's a coincidence that two of Rico's top suspects, G-Man and Elo (who incidentally were both up for lynching before that last second save), were here in the hatch with Rico and he turns up dead. WIFOM and all that, but right now I'd wager it's one of those two.

Charlie! Thank's for the peanut butter.

Quin wrote:I want Eloh to answer my question.

Sorry, what question?

I won't be around today. It's homeschool group day. And after that I will be hanging with friends trying out the drink of choice for our homeschool momma Christmas party this weekend.

#64

Claire, I think Quin is referring to the question at the end of this post:

Quin wrote:
Elohcin wrote:I hit play and danced a jig, G. Thanks for the music.

Quin wrote:Me, because I have a power role.
Why would you say this. Do you WANT to be killed? Or are you mafia?

I was thinking MP as well. I think he is civ and I can imagine the baddies picking to off him early.

------------------------------
woah woah woah.....this is nuts. So we are stuck in the hatch for day 2? And Rico is dead. So one of the Hatchlings are bad for sure.
I said it the first time at the very beginning of the game. Why are you picking up on it now?

That looks to be the only question he's directed at you while we've been in the Hatch.

#65

RAINBOW HATCH LIST:

DFaraday
G-Man
MovingPictures
Elohcin
Quin

To be honest, I'm not really sure of any dude's alignment. I've ranked people based on how likely I think they are bad, but the margins are pretty close.

#66

Completed my re-read. It didn't help my mood. I miss my tiger pit.

#67

Courteously requesting rainbow lists from DF and MP. I'd like to condense all the results and ask a few questions.

#68

G-Man wrote:Completed my re-read. It didn't help my mood. I miss my tiger pit.

hey dude, did you get anything from your re-read?

lemme put it like this: GTH, who's the baddie?

#69

Clamming up on suspicions until I see lists from DF and MP, sorry. I don't want my newest thoughts influencing their lists.

#70

G-Man wrote:Clamming up on suspicions until I see lists from DF and MP, sorry. I don't want my newest thoughts influencing their lists.

You think you're that influential?

Whatever dude.

#71

INH
Quin
MP
Daisy
Dom
Epi
Scotty
Sorsha
Elo
G-Man

#72

I've mostly agreed with INH's thoughts, and Quin reads sincere to me, even though I'm not a fan of his Soneji vote. Still, it doesn't feel as opportunistic as some of the later votes.

G-Man's reluctance to share throughout this game makes me view him more suspiciously as well.

#73

Scotty is as low down as he is for trying to justify his Soneji vote as saving himself, and for otherwise having uncharacteristically very little presence in the game.

#74

insertnamehere wrote:
G-Man wrote:Clamming up on suspicions until I see lists from DF and MP, sorry. I don't want my newest thoughts influencing their lists.
You think you're that influential?

Whatever dude.

Certainly not. I just don't want to add anything new to the pot. Baddies will look at what's out there and calibrate their faux-suspicions ever so slightly to the ebb and flow of everyone else. The lower portion of DFaraday's recent list didn't surprise me much because he had mentioned Eloh and I as his prime suspects earlier.

I'm most curious to see what MP thinks of all us Hatchlings.

Linki: I've shared quite a bit, I think. I verbally poked and prodded a few people, threw out some ideas (some wilder than others), and have been receptive to Q&A. The only things I've held out on have been my location claim for N1 and my revised rainbow list. Calling me reluctant to share is a bit of a stretch.

#75

G-Man wrote: Linki: I've shared quite a bit, I think. I verbally poked and prodded a few people, threw out some ideas (some wilder than others), and have been receptive to Q&A. The only things I've held out on have been my location claim for N1 and my revised rainbow list. Calling me reluctant to share is a bit of a stretch.

I guess that's fair. It just seemed like more because both of those instances drew attention.

#76

G-Man wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:
G-Man wrote:Clamming up on suspicions until I see lists from DF and MP, sorry. I don't want my newest thoughts influencing their lists.
You think you're that influential?

Whatever dude.
Certainly not. I just don't want to add anything new to the pot. Baddies will look at what's out there and calibrate their faux-suspicions ever so slightly to the ebb and flow of everyone else. The lower portion of DFaraday's recent list didn't surprise me much because he had mentioned Eloh and I as his prime suspects earlier.

I'm most curious to see what MP thinks of all us Hatchlings.

Linki: I've shared quite a bit, I think. I verbally poked and prodded a few people, threw out some ideas (some wilder than others), and have been receptive to Q&A. The only things I've held out on have been my location claim for N1 and my revised rainbow list. Calling me reluctant to share is a bit of a stretch.

Refusing to share your reads because bad dudes might, I dunno, "calibrate their faux-suspicions" around this sure-to-be prophetic rainbow list seems pretty silly to me, because all you're really doing is making the civilians less informed.

Also think it's funny that you demand everyone else's rainbow list, but treat your own like some sacred text which only you can see.

#77

Contributing to the thread and asking a bunch of questions, only to clam up when other dudes ask you questions in the interest on not "adding anything new to the pot" just seems kinda contradictory and weird.

I dunno.

Someone put on a record. It's getting kinda stuffy in here.

#78

Claustrophobia must be shorting out your memory, because I already gave you a rainbow list. I'm holding out on my revised list.

Spoiler: show

#79

G-Man wrote:Claustrophobia must be shorting out your memory, because I already gave you a rainbow list. I'm holding out on my revised list.

Spoiler: show
It's really not that different from the first list.

Is MP your biggest suspect?

Because that seems to be the only possible reason why you would be so scared to share your reads with the group, in order to prevent bad dudes from, I dunno, copying them.

MP's the only one who's been AWOL from the thread, everyone else has shared their opinions.

#80

insertnamehere wrote:
G-Man wrote:Claustrophobia must be shorting out your memory, because I already gave you a rainbow list. I'm holding out on my revised list.

Spoiler: show
It's really not that different from the first list.
Is MP your biggest suspect?

Because that seems to be the only possible reason why you would be so scared to share your reads with the group, in order to prevent bad dudes from, I dunno, copying them.

MP's the only one who's been AWOL from the thread, everyone else has shared their opinions.

Close. You've also shifted down into orange. Your posts drive the tin-foil loon in me wild.

Elohcin
Quin

DFaraday
Insertnamehere
MovingPictures07

#81

G-Man wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:
G-Man wrote:Claustrophobia must be shorting out your memory, because I already gave you a rainbow list. I'm holding out on my revised list.

Spoiler: show
It's really not that different from the first list.
Is MP your biggest suspect?

Because that seems to be the only possible reason why you would be so scared to share your reads with the group, in order to prevent bad dudes from, I dunno, copying them.

MP's the only one who's been AWOL from the thread, everyone else has shared their opinions.
Close. You've also shifted down into orange. Your posts drive the tin-foil loon in me wild.

Elohcin
Quin

DFaraday
Insertnamehere
MovingPictures07

Me asking you to give your opinions is driving you wild? Well, this is sure to drive you insane: Can you specifically state in the thread what, if anything, you gleaned from your re-read?

Whatever dude. I'm gonna go see if the shower works.

#82

G-Man wrote:Claire, I think Quin is referring to the question at the end of this post:

Quin wrote:
Elohcin wrote:I hit play and danced a jig, G. Thanks for the music.

Quin wrote:Me, because I have a power role.
Why would you say this. Do you WANT to be killed? Or are you mafia?

I was thinking MP as well. I think he is civ and I can imagine the baddies picking to off him early.

------------------------------
woah woah woah.....this is nuts. So we are stuck in the hatch for day 2? And Rico is dead. So one of the Hatchlings are bad for sure.
I said it the first time at the very beginning of the game. Why are you picking up on it now?
That looks to be the only question he's directed at you while we've been in the Hatch.

I must not have noticed it the first time. And for him to re-state it seems like he is screaming, "Hey baddie! Kill ME!" Or he doesn't have to worry b/c he IS the baddie.

#83

Considering a vote for MP for the shock value. It's been a while since he's peed in my face over something.

#84

Sorry, all. My internet has gone to shit again and it's entirely likely I might not get it back for a few days. I can't really address anything specific because I'm using a really bad hotspot internet, but I will when I get a chance. Here's what I can say right now before I check out again.

Eloh's answer to my question isn't great. She reacted like my earlier post about having a power role was so significant, but if she were a civ-minded player in this game, she wouldn't have missed something that significant.

I don't like anything about INH's day 1. I've covered the majority of my thoughts about him in the main thread, so give that a look.

I'm not opposed to a vote for MP. I think my hypothesis about late declarers has some merit, although admittedly it's not the strongest Day 1 thing.

Just so I have a Day 2 vote out there, I'm voting INH again. I'm not caught up in the slightest.

@Golden - if I don't check in for a few days, feel free to replace me.

#85

Quin wrote:@Golden - if I don't check in for a few days, feel free to replace me.

I'll give you some time. Good luck.

#86

Quin wrote:Sorry, all. My internet has gone to shit again and it's entirely likely I might not get it back for a few days. I can't really address anything specific because I'm using a really bad hotspot internet, but I will when I get a chance. Here's what I can say right now before I check out again.

Eloh's answer to my question isn't great. She reacted like my earlier post about having a power role was so significant, but if she were a civ-minded player in this game, she wouldn't have missed something that significant.

I don't like anything about INH's day 1. I've covered the majority of my thoughts about him in the main thread, so give that a look.

I'm not opposed to a vote for MP. I think my hypothesis about late declarers has some merit, although admittedly it's not the strongest Day 1 thing.

Just so I have a Day 2 vote out there, I'm voting INH again. I'm not caught up in the slightest.

@Golden - if I don't check in for a few days, feel free to replace me.

Considerable amounts of tinfoil went into INh being dragged down to my second-most suspicions Hatchling. I wish you had better access so we could talk about it more.

If the Beach Bodies vote for us Hatchlings, I wouldn't be surprised to see votes for me out of Sorsha and Dom. My obnoxious Ana roleplay didn't seem to be appreciated by either of them. Hard to speculate where the other theee might vote though. Heck, it's hard to say where our votes are going to go. It would be nice if this lockdown would end so we could have some clarity this last part of the day.

Lemme see if I can enter those numbers Rico was so fond of mentioning...

#87

Quin wrote:Sorry, all. My internet has gone to shit again and it's entirely likely I might not get it back for a few days. I can't really address anything specific because I'm using a really bad hotspot internet, but I will when I get a chance. Here's what I can say right now before I check out again.

Eloh's answer to my question isn't great. She reacted like my earlier post about having a power role was so significant, but if she were a civ-minded player in this game, she wouldn't have missed something that significant.

I don't like anything about INH's day 1. I've covered the majority of my thoughts about him in the main thread, so give that a look.

I'm not opposed to a vote for MP. I think my hypothesis about late declarers has some merit, although admittedly it's not the strongest Day 1 thing.

Just so I have a Day 2 vote out there, I'm voting INH again. I'm not caught up in the slightest.

@Golden - if I don't check in for a few days, feel free to replace me.

Yes, I reacted as if your power role claiming was significant b/c I thought it WAS significant. You did it right at the beginning of night 1 as if to day, hey baddie kill ME. That is what made it significant. I don't think a civ would put it out there right at that point. If/when you claimed that in the beginning of the game, it wasn't as significant to me.

I don't want to vote MP today. He's barely here and I think it would be a mistake. I am thinking Sorsha or Quin and here is why. Quin b/c of his power role claim right at the beginning of Night 1 when the killer is thinking about who to kill. And Sorsha b/c of her Day 1 lack of contributions. Searching for Walk is all she did.

#88

Can you tell me your feelings about voting for either INH or DF?

#89

G-Man wrote:Can you tell me your feelings about voting for either INH or DF?

Dude.

Are you gonna explain anything about your reads?

Are you gonna say anything more about why you think I'm bad other than "tin foil"?

Are you honestly expecting us to give you content without you giving any analysis in return- only vague illogical justifications?

I was honestly really liking most of the content you made in D1, but this is just getting ridiculous.

I'm going to put my vote on G-Man until he explains himself. And I also reserve the right to leave it there if I'm not thrilled with the answers.

#90

THE RULES wrote:8) All votes are changeable.

I'm not able to change my vote on this poll, what gives Golden?

#91

Golden wrote:There haven't been any rule changes,

Hmm...

#92

insertnamehere wrote:
THE RULES wrote:8) All votes are changeable.
I'm not able to change my vote on this poll, what gives Golden?

Curiouser and curiouser. I'll touch on any addenda to my prior reads tomorrow at lunch.

Glad I didn't vote yet.

#93

G-Man wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:
THE RULES wrote:8) All votes are changeable.
I'm not able to change my vote on this poll, what gives Golden?
Curiouser and curiouser. I'll touch on any addenda to my prior reads tomorrow at lunch.

Glad I didn't vote yet.

Dude, you aren't Columbo. You don't have to wait until the last second to tell us what you really think.

#94

Come to terms with the fact that my mafia playing schedule is whack or you're in for a loooong game. This is quite normal for me, so please stop playing it up like it's a big honking deal.

#95

insertnamehere wrote:
THE RULES wrote:8) All votes are changeable.
I'm not able to change my vote on this poll, what gives Golden?

the box is checked and I can change mine. Refresh?

#96

I'm so dramatic

But seriously, my internet provider is a piece of shit and it's a miracle that they fixed it before the weekend, otherwise we'd probably be stuck without internet until Monday.

It's dinner time so for now I'm doing other things, but I'll pick up my slack sometime tonight.

#97

I can edit my posts. I don't think this is a permission I am supposed to have.

#98

I can't change my votes either, yeah.

#99

very odd. I've got marmot on it. If it doesn't work we will revert to thread voting.

#100

Elohcin wrote:
Quin wrote:Sorry, all. My internet has gone to shit again and it's entirely likely I might not get it back for a few days. I can't really address anything specific because I'm using a really bad hotspot internet, but I will when I get a chance. Here's what I can say right now before I check out again.

Eloh's answer to my question isn't great. She reacted like my earlier post about having a power role was so significant, but if she were a civ-minded player in this game, she wouldn't have missed something that significant.

I don't like anything about INH's day 1. I've covered the majority of my thoughts about him in the main thread, so give that a look.

I'm not opposed to a vote for MP. I think my hypothesis about late declarers has some merit, although admittedly it's not the strongest Day 1 thing.

Just so I have a Day 2 vote out there, I'm voting INH again. I'm not caught up in the slightest.

@Golden - if I don't check in for a few days, feel free to replace me.
Yes, I reacted as if your power role claiming was significant b/c I thought it WAS significant. You did it right at the beginning of night 1 as if to day, hey baddie kill ME. That is what made it significant. I don't think a civ would put it out there right at that point. If/when you claimed that in the beginning of the game, it wasn't as significant to me.

I don't want to vote MP today. He's barely here and I think it would be a mistake. I am thinking Sorsha or Quin and here is why. Quin b/c of his power role claim right at the beginning of Night 1 when the killer is thinking about who to kill. And Sorsha b/c of her Day 1 lack of contributions. Searching for Walk is all she did.

I get that you think it would be more significant given the timing of either post, but you admitted in your earlier post that you didn't even notice it the first time. In that lies my qualm with you, because any civ-minded player who reacted so strongly to a role-claim should not have missed one in the first place, regardless of its circumstantial significance. You could very well be a baddie who's not giving enough scrutiny to the early-game, making the mistake of thinking it's not particularly relevant content.

Who needs to be hit with the Eko stick?