[ENDGAME] Bullets Over Broadway Mafia

#1801

Sloonei wrote:I agree about g-man and am still on the fence about Bass.
I see this post where you give reasons for suspecting Bass and a few others, but a lot has happened since then. Do you have anything to add to your case of Bass? How has your read on Bass changed since you first mentioned it?

A lot hasn't happened in regards to bass though. He hasn't answered that post so it sticks out all the more to me. He said he was trying harder this game but a lot of his early posts felt like he was asking more questions instead of providing suspicions. He then had a spike of energy and has since gone quiet. and I think his self vote was weird. My read on him hasn't changed much. I continue to be suspicious of him.

#1802

Sloonei wrote:
sig wrote:Metal Votes against me to tie it, switch off and say it is to force a retie, and then switch back to me after EPi 2.0 votes for me giving me a 2 lead up. Is this not suspicious to anyone? His and EPis votes both seem tailored to get me lynched.
To be fair, I think everyone voting for you is tailoring their votes to get you lynched
But yes, metalmarhs if you're here you could at least explain why you've voted the way you have.

I was hoping to see how other players reacted to a tie. I can't recall off the top of my head how all the votes went down, but I didn't see anything in real time that looked suspicious.

Hindsight may speak differently, but I have a plane to catch, so I had to vote.

#1803

Okay I will give you the point about Scotty

I read FZ post he is still a null I'm justhaving trouble getting a read from him, but I would say he was more of a slight scum read. after rereading their posts.

I don't see nij support against me in that post?

#1804

fingersplints wrote:
Sloonei wrote:I agree about g-man and am still on the fence about Bass.
I see this post where you give reasons for suspecting Bass and a few others, but a lot has happened since then. Do you have anything to add to your case of Bass? How has your read on Bass changed since you first mentioned it?
A lot hasn't happened in regards to bass though. He hasn't answered that post so it sticks out all the more to me. He said he was trying harder this game but a lot of his early posts felt like he was asking more questions instead of providing suspicions. He then had a spike of energy and has since gone quiet. and I think his self vote was weird. My read on him hasn't changed much. I continue to be suspicious of him.

i agree with this. my early read on bass was that he looked town because his participation seemed to be increased from the Economics game, but since then he's dropped completely off the radar.

#1805

We've got about an hour to go and the thread's not very busy right now. I don't know how I should feel about that. It could be that we're not lynching any scums, so they're all content to sit back and let this happen. Or it could be that one or both of Tiny and Sig is scum and they've given in and don't want to come out too vocally against these lynches at this late stage in the day.
Anyone have any thoughts about anything?

#1806

I think it's really because we are in a bit of a holding pattern. We need a lynch or two to get some info and get us moving again.

#1807

Golden wrote:BR, I agree he must not have been around, this is a pattern of late in recent games for TH.

Could you tell me which games? I just remember him playing like this.

#1808

We could always fire drill LC he is mafia

#1809

Black Rock wrote:
Golden wrote:BR, I agree he must not have been around, this is a pattern of late in recent games for TH.
Could you tell me which games? I just remember him playing like this.

RYM 86 he vanished from after a couple of days and was eventually replaced by Sloonei.

In Biblical he was Jonah who vanished after a few days.

#1810

Golden wrote:I think it's really because we are in a bit of a holding pattern. We need a lynch or two to get some info and get us moving again.

me too. this game still has a bit of Day 1 feel to it and this lynch should finally shake that off, regardless of the outcome.
i still feel very good about sig and will be mildly surprised if he flips town. I'll also feel terrible and apologize and ask him to keep playing in future games. but he's not flipping town.

#1811

sig wrote:We could always fire drill LC he is mafia

Why are you so certain about LC?

#1812

Golden wrote:I think it's really because we are in a bit of a holding pattern. We need a lynch or two to get some info and get us moving again.

This. I will leave my bass suspicion until tomorrow. I'm voting sig.

#1813

so you won't ask me to play anymore if I flip mafia

I gave reasoning before on LC, im convinced he is mafia especially since Epi switched his vote,h didn't answermy questions, and the golden/LC thing

#1814

sig wrote:so you won't ask me to play anymore if I flip mafia

I gave reasoning before on LC, im convinced he is mafia especially since Epi switched his vote,h didn't answermy questions, and the golden/LC thing

I... I... didn't mean...

#1815

But also, sig, I know you've given reasons for your suspicion of LC, but if you're on your way out now, and if you are a townie, don't you want to leave as much clear information behind as you can? I do not fully understand how Epi's vote change factors into any of this, for example.

#1816

Sloonei wrote:Anyone have any thoughts about anything?

#1817

Golden wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
Golden wrote:BR, I agree he must not have been around, this is a pattern of late in recent games for TH.
Could you tell me which games? I just remember him playing like this.
RYM 86 he vanished from after a couple of days and was eventually replaced by Sloonei.

In Biblical he was Jonah who vanished after a few days.

That's why I don't know these patterns. I sure hope this isn't the case and he comes back. I can't trust a quiet TH, it's damn creepy.

#1818

But seriously, did no one notice that I shifted my vote around multiple times during the course of the day? I wanted to see if anyone was paying attention to that and it seems that nobody is. Please be more vigilant as the game progresses! Obviously we're going to be more aware of such shenanigans nearer to the deadlines but it's important to be watchful of vote changes throughout the day.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #1819

Changed my vote to sig. He's really looking bad. (...And practically admitted it in that green text just now... lol)

I don't get why Bass voted himself though. Want to hear more from him tomorrow.

#1820

G-Man wrote:But seriously, did no one notice that I shifted my vote around multiple times during the course of the day? I wanted to see if anyone was paying attention to that and it seems that nobody is. Please be more vigilant as the game progresses! Obviously we're going to be more aware of such shenanigans nearer to the deadlines but it's important to be watchful of vote changes throughout the day.

Well, I noticed when you changed it to me, where it's remained for a while. But no, I'm not so focussed on each individual person as to notice them move their vote around without saying so in the thread.

#1821

nutella wrote:(...And practically admitted it in that green text just now... lol)

That's exactly the sense I got - a gracious exit.

#1822

Golden wrote:
nutella wrote:(...And practically admitted it in that green text just now... lol)
That's exactly the sense I got - a gracious exit.

same. :\
play more games, sig!

#1823

Golden wrote:
G-Man wrote:But seriously, did no one notice that I shifted my vote around multiple times during the course of the day? I wanted to see if anyone was paying attention to that and it seems that nobody is. Please be more vigilant as the game progresses! Obviously we're going to be more aware of such shenanigans nearer to the deadlines but it's important to be watchful of vote changes throughout the day.
Well, I noticed when you changed it to me, where it's remained for a while. But no, I'm not so focussed on each individual person as to notice them move their vote around without saying so in the thread.

Okay, well I guess that's just the accountant in me coming out. I have a thing about always knowing the vote tallies. This game especially with the changing factor. Maybe I need to get help. :P

#1824

Definitely sig, I hope you stick around.

linki @ g-man, llama has a therapists couch ready for you

#1825

nutella wrote:Changed my vote to sig. He's really looking bad. (...And practically admitted it in that green text just now... lol)

I don't get why Bass voted himself though. Want to hear more from him tomorrow.

I missed that, I didn't read the green text. Switching my vote now.

#1826

Won't it be nice to hear epi's perspective on today soon

Cobalt's too, I guess.

Also, I'm opening a book on who will have a feud with LC on day 4, since he gets to have one with a different person each day.

#1827

Golden wrote:Won't it be nice to hear epi's perspective on today soon

Cobalt's too, I guess.

Also, I'm opening a book on who will have a feud with LC on day 4, since he gets to have one with a different person each day.

Frankly I'm disappointed that Cobalt gave up on posting. If I were insanified, I'd spam the hell out of the thread just to see what the insanifier filter comes up with.

Heh, could you imagine what Economics Mafia would have been like if I'd have gotten insanified? THAT would be priceless!

#1828

Golden wrote:Won't it be nice to hear epi's perspective on today soon

Cobalt's too, I guess.

Also, I'm opening a book on who will have a feud with LC on day 4, since he gets to have one with a different person each day.

Don't piss him off too much, I have to live with him.

#1829

BR is odds on at $1.22

#1830

In fact, I'd like to request to be insanified (if at all possible) for Day 4. I will revert to memes just for the lulz factor.

#1831

There's almost certainly at least one scum voting for sig right now. I feel good about the way the lynch came together, but it's become very easy for scum to hop onto. I hope everyone's ready to do some vote analysis after today. it'll be fun, we can make s'mores.

#1832

I mean, with two mafia teams there are highly likely to be scum on board any lynch without it being bussing. But I agree there is a high possibility for sig's own teammates to be in there as well.

#1833

G-Man's insanified vote analysis in memes

#1834

Golden wrote:G-Man's insanified vote analysis in memes

All my mafia dreams would come true.

#1835

G-Man, you should offer to call the insanifier a coward if they don't insanify you. I've heard that approach works well.

#1836

Golden wrote:G-Man's insanified technicolour vote analysis in memes

Fixed.

#1837

Wait no I'm sorry I dont want to go out in a gracious exit, let me try again..............IF YOU LYNCH ME YOUR ALLLLLLLL DEAD IM A BOMB...... so you better run

better? :P

I might be independent you never know....Don't sigh I could be.....

Okay let me be serious, I want the other mafia team gone I suspect some may have voted for me, I would say LC is mafia I was trying to get him to give a good argument about sloonie so I could lynch him after my post saying sloonie was clean but that never happened. After LC never responded he became more and more suspicious to me, you might not believe this, but my suspicion of LC and many others was true maybe not all but some were. I was actively hunting mafia during this game I will leave it up to you to figure out which of my reads were honest which were not. Minus LC string him up and kill Cobalt when your at it (that's a joke CObalt).........maybe

Oh and btw my number has to do with the police they can rolecheck/protect or kill

ironic very ironic.
It has been fun I look forward to our next game together......and Sloonie/Scotty I hate you both lynching an innocent civ like me

(I'm joking you were both good with me I would say good luck but I wouldn't really mean it)

I made this post since I was bored and rarely post in the end game but again it was fun

Good by I will see you all in hell

#1838

Sig, dude, you are awesome. Hang around the syndicate, please

#1839

thanks for playing, sig! and sorry you had to be a bad guy.

#1840

my thumbs are twiddling

#1841

Write up hasn't happened still alive?....am I a ghost? if so their will be some series haunting
thanks golden/sloonie

#1842

Hey guys I don't have any wifi right now so I can't make an elaborate post.

Sig has been lunched. He was Starlight Express.
You have 24 hours to get your pms in

#1843

Good show sig.

#1844

Sig was mafia 1.

First instinct - I was wrong about LC being on mafia 1 (and therefore, I don't really think he is bad any more. I definitely don't think he is on mafia 2). I don't think it is likely that bubbles is either, but I'll need to reread sig on both. It's possible sig was intentionally misdirecting on one or both, I suppose. But first instinct is that neither are mafia 1.

I still think G-Man is, though. A reread of sig is now in order.

#1845

woohoo. Good productive day, everyone. We've got a lot of work to do now, though. I plan on taking a look at how certain individuals interacted with sig, and how he interacted with. I encourage others to do the same. Plus vote analysis and whatnot. I'm gonna go unmafia for a little while. And because I like visuals:

Dom wrote: Lloyd Webber – Baddie Team 1 (4 Roles)
Win Condition: Outnumber the civilians and eliminate Team Wildhorn and any other opposition, if it exists.
Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber
The Phantom of the Opera – The Phantom of the Opera is there, inside my mind.
Starlight Express - Starlight express, answer me yes
Cats - Memory, all alone in the moonlight

Wildhorn – Baddie Team 2 (3 Roles)
Win Condition: Outnumber the civilians and eliminate Team Lloyd Weber and any other opposition, if it exists.
Frank Wildhorn
Jekyll & Hyde - If I could reach you, if I could guide and teach you
Bonnie and Clyde – I’d rather breathe in life than dusty air.

Independents (4 Roles)
Andrew Lippa – And we were having a wild, wild party!
Stephen Schwartz – I’ve gotta be someone who lives all of his life in superlatives.
Oscar Hammerstein II – Some enchanted evening, you may find a stranger.
Richard Rodgers –If I loved you, time and again, I would try to say all I'd want you to know

#1846

Golden wrote:Sig was mafia 1.

First instinct - I was wrong about LC being on mafia 1 (and therefore, I don't really think he is bad any more. I definitely don't think he is on mafia 2). I don't think it is likely that bubbles is either, but I'll need to reread sig on both. It's possible sig was intentionally misdirecting on one or both, I suppose. But first instinct is that neither are mafia 1.

I still think G-Man is, though. A reread of sig is now in order.

Why all this?

#1847

Sloonei wrote:woohoo. Good productive day, everyone.

Thanks.

#1848

Just because I wanted to record my gut reaction, sloonei. Oh, and because of sig's stated suspicions.

#1849

Epignosis wrote:
Sloonei wrote:woohoo. Good productive day, everyone.
Thanks.

couldn't have done it without you!

#1850

Golden wrote:Just because I wanted to record my gut reaction, sloonei. Oh, and because of sig's stated suspicions.

sig's post history could be a potential goldmine, i hope we all turn it inside out.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed MM? (not changeable)