Battlestar Galactica Mafia - GAME OVER

[Long Con]

Is Lorab going to claim Cylon?

By the way, I am a Cylon. Who wants to claim with me?

Lorab claimed Cylon, and now so have you. Metalmarsh is immune to lynch today?

[Marmot]

Is Lorab going to claim Cylon?

By the way, I am a Cylon. Who wants to claim with me?

Lorab claimed Cylon, and now so have you. Metalmarsh is immune to lynch today?

Yes!

Now if everyone claims Cylon today, we can eliminate the Amnesty from future day phases.

[Epignosis]

Bea, DrWilgy, Nerolunar, Ricochet, S~V~S, sig

A second vote for any of these folks could doom them. Or make them admit to being a Cylon. Come one, folks, let's make something happen NOW, not five minutes before deadline.

ONE person vote someone, and they will be squeezed.

I don't want to help you until you help me.

Don't start that again, I'm not playing that game with you, Cylon.

Even if you don't, I wish you would at least consider the rules.

[Glorfindel]

If Lorab is bad with BTSC, and she knew she could claim "Sanctuary!"

How does that make you feel about these persons?

Polo (10), a2thezebra (11), Vompatti (12), Ricochet (13), S~V~S (14), DFaraday (15), JaggedJimmyJay (16)

I feel fine with Zebs, and Jimmy. I think Polo, Ricochet and S-V-S are alright. Jury is still out on DFaraday and Vompatti.

You just named the easiest two players to lynch.

I just named the two players from the list you gave about whom I have no convictions of their innocence/guilt. I gave you an honest response to the question you asked.

[ObscureAllure]

Marmot 0 No votes

[Marmot]

The statement would have to be true for me to be immune to the lynch, but I hope you see my goal with this proposition.

[Long Con]

Bea, DrWilgy, Nerolunar, Ricochet, S~V~S, sig

A second vote for any of these folks could doom them. Or make them admit to being a Cylon. Come one, folks, let's make something happen NOW, not five minutes before deadline.

ONE person vote someone, and they will be squeezed.

I don't want to help you until you help me.

Don't start that again, I'm not playing that game with you, Cylon.

Even if you don't, I wish you would at least consider the rules.

The rules are that I have to declare that for the rest of the game, I will not wish you dead. In return, you will give me help.

[Marmot]

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

[Epignosis]

I have cast my lot with OA.

I have voted Nerolunar.

[S~V~S]

Bea, DrWilgy, Nerolunar, Ricochet, S~V~S, sig

A second vote for any of these folks could doom them. Or make them admit to being a Cylon. Come one, folks, let's make something happen NOW, not five minutes before deadline.

ONE person vote someone, and they will be squeezed.

You left "Long Con" off your list

Linki @ MM, she already did.

Linki @ OA, why the frownie? I have no reason to believe any of the people voting LoRab are bad, based on their thread up to this point. I got a ping off Rico day one,but then he brought his Rico game to the table.

Polo (10), a2thezebra (11), Vompatti (12), Ricochet (13), S~V~S (14), DFaraday (15), JaggedJimmyJay (16)

[Epignosis]

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

No.

[Polo]

I am a Cylon, but actually I'm not a Cylon at all.

[Marmot]

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

No.

Ok, everyone but Epignosis. :P

[ObscureAllure]

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

Linki @ OA, why the frownie? I have no reason to believe any of the people voting LoRab are bad, based on their thread up to this point. I got a ping off Rico day one,but then he brought his Rico game to the table.

[ObscureAllure]

I am a Cylon, but actually I'm not a Cylon at all.

[G-Man]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

[SokothQultuq]

Keeping with my promise. I rolled a 10. So 3J it is..

I vote JaggedJimmyJay

[Marmot]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

I'll follow you on Glorfindel.

I wouldn't mind lynching Long Con at this point either. He was been active in the thread up until the point where I suggested everyone say "I am a Cylon". I would have expected him to be on board with it if he was human.

[Marmot]

Also,

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

[juliets]

Ok, I feel good about OA and Epi so I'm going to follow their vote on Nerolunar. I have a gut feeling about him anyway, though i wouldn't have voted for him based solely on this gut feel.

Vote: Nerolunar

Also, my travel plans are finally worked out and unfortunately I will be out of the thread both tomorrow May 16th and the next day May 17th. I know this is not ideal but there is nothing I can do about it. The place we are spending the night tomorrow night does not have working wifi.

[Glorfindel]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

Yes, I'm afraid you are G-man but if you feel that's what you need to do...

[Polo]

Something's been bugging me.

Epignosis, were you aware on D1 that Cylons could resurrect?

[Long Con]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

I'll follow you on Glorfindel.

I wouldn't mind lynching Long Con at this point either. He was been active in the thread up until the point where I suggested everyone say "I am a Cylon". I would have expected him to be on board with it if he was human.

I'm still active. I don't think this plan will do anything. I also don't want to say that I'm a Cylon.

[Long Con]

Maybe if, say, Nerolunar would say it.

[Epignosis]

Something's been bugging me.

Epignosis, were you aware on D1 that Cylons could resurrect?

No. I didn't know shite about this theme.

[Marmot]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

I'll follow you on Glorfindel.

I wouldn't mind lynching Long Con at this point either. He was been active in the thread up until the point where I suggested everyone say "I am a Cylon". I would have expected him to be on board with it if he was human.

I'm still active. I don't think this plan will do anything. I also don't want to say that I'm a Cylon.

Why don't you think this plan will do anything?

I think it is a clever plan that could eliminate the amnesty of several Cylons if people get on board with it.

[sig]

I'm also fine with a Nero vote.

Vote Nerolunar

I've got a bad gut read and his actions surrounding nutella were odd.

I wouldn't mind an LC lynch, but right now I think we need unity and I also think Nero is mafia so I have no problem voting for him. Now I've gotta go to sleep.

[G-Man]

All the time I spent writing that case can't go to waste.

But then Long Con goes and says that.

[Polo]

Am I crazy for still wanting to vote for Glorfindel? I mean I see the logic of voting for one of the six one-vote folk but I still think Glorfindel is bad.

I'll follow you on Glorfindel.

I wouldn't mind lynching Long Con at this point either. He was been active in the thread up until the point where I suggested everyone say "I am a Cylon". I would have expected him to be on board with it if he was human.

I'm still active. I don't think this plan will do anything. I also don't want to say that I'm a Cylon.

Why not? Do you think you may need to save the immunity for a later moment?

[ObscureAllure]

Maybe if, say, Nerolunar would say it.

[Glorfindel]

I'm happy at this point to support the vote for Magnus Nerolunar

[Epignosis]

The downside is that teammates of Lorab would know she was going to claim and then hold their votes for whatever inevitable countermeasure came about.

[DrumBeats]

So say we all!

I prefer bea or glorfindel for the counterwagon, anyone else?

I am a cylon.

Jk jk, but I'll gladly get rid of the possibility of amnesty if I am final five.

[Glorfindel]

So say we all!

I prefer bea or glorfindel for the counterwagon, anyone else?

I am a cylon.

Jk jk, but I'll gladly get rid of the possibility of amnesty if I am final five.

Interesting... Based on what precisely, my friend?

[G-Man]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

[Epignosis]

People in this are making things far more complicated than they must be. Relax. Lynch bad guys. Go.

[bea]

I'm still stuck in the world's worst Sunday at work. I'm going to go with Nero in light of LoRab amnesty claim. I'm sorry I've been quiet. Hellish 5.99bcarry out weekend has been hellish.

vote nero

Back to hour 12 of work with no end in sight.

[DrumBeats]

Well we would need a ton of people if we wanted to counter the Nero wagon so maybe not.

Idea time! What if we pushed the Nero wagon past the Lorab wagon?

My thoughts on that is that if Lorab is human, he would be lynched regardless, if he is cyclon it would default to Nero. If we push Nero past, then we save a human Lorab if that is the case. It would make no difference if Lorab is a cylon. Only thing here is we would be uncertain in the end if Lorab is cylon or human. I'm not sure how you guys feel about it, but it's a possibility imo. We need to come up with a group consensus on that though, so nobody jumps the gun and does it anyway.

And @Glorfindel - G-man has a convincing case on you imo and I do not like Bea's interactions with nutella

[Marmot]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

[Long Con]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

Smart move.

What I mean is, I don't think it will take away amnesty unless that amnesty is tested. Hence me asking Nero to say it only.

[DrWilgy]

Voted Nero! #Ties

[Marmot]

A new law has been passed.

Cylon Amnesty Act: Any person may publicly admit to being a cylon and, if the declaration is true, they will have immunity from the lynch for that day. Once a person has outed themselves as a cylon, they cannot do it a second time.

Nah, I think that it only works the day the say it, the first time that they say it.

[Long Con]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

Smart move.

Wait, no, he's not someone with a vote already!

[Golden]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

To be abundantly clear - immunity does not equate to no lynch if an immune person is the lynch leader. It equates to none of the votes against the immune person being worth anything, and so them not being the top vote getter.

[Epignosis]

Voted Nero! #Ties

Some tie.

[Marmot]

It is now mathematically impossible for anyone apart from Nerolunar or Lorab to be lynched (in a normal universe).

Linki: Oh, never mind. I probably missed someone else getting the answer to that question.

[DrWilgy]

Voted Nero! #Ties

Some tie.

Aint it great?

[Long Con]

And if Nero comes in last-second like and outs himself, we need another option. I'm gonna go with my gut on this one.

Vote = Glorfindel

There are 7 votes left to be placed, so at this point, you would need every other player available to follow suit in order to push Glorfindel into the lead.

I'll probably vote for Nerolunar. If he's a Cylon, eliminating his amnesty would still be a good result, even if no one is lynched.

Linki: Never mind. Now it's mathematically impossible for Glorfindel to be lynched outright.

To be abundantly clear - immunity does not equate to no lynch if an immune person is the lynch leader. It equates to none of the votes against the immune person being worth anything, and so them not being the top vote getter.

Does amnesty get used up if the self-declared Cylon doesn't get the most votes?

[S~V~S]

Also,

A human has nothing to lose by saying this. A Cylon has a lynch to lose by saying this today.

I propose that every player state "I am a Cylon" at this moment.

Sure, I think it is a good idea.

I am a Cylon

I don't love any rule that allows for self outing, tbh, so if we all say that that eliminates that possibility.

[Marmot]

Wilgy! Will you follow the plan and say you're a Cylon?