MacDougall wrote:That is one dangerous indy role. Thanks Scotty though for vindicating me.
MacDougall wrote:Let's talk more about how I tone read a Mafia player on day 1 again.
Yeah, but you took your vote off of him and placed it on me, so I don't see that as vindication. And I see these two followup posts as an attempt to become a "confirmed civ."
FZ. wrote:What a pleasant surprise. To be honest, I didn't think JackOH was bad. Not to take anything from Scotty's hunting skills, I don't think he would have wanted to take out a baddie, since that would mean he would have to be the last man standing, and that is probably harder than winning with the mafia, but who knows. I don't get why he was going after the person he wanted to take down with him anyway. Wouldn't that be a waste?
I have a screen cap from before I changed my time from Summer. So it's at least 50 minutes before the end of the day, but I believe it was earlier. I opened another window at some point to see the names of the players, and I did it much earlier. How do I post it?
Looking at the voting pattern, Quin voted for notsawyer after Jack had 2 votes. A good way to try and save your friend. Scotty didn't have votes at that point yet (unless I missed a switch of vote somewhere along the way). So I think that would be a good place to start. Baddies often like to vote early on a lynch wagon so they don't seem like they are bandwagoning. If his suspicions were genuine, DF is another good option to look into.
Epi, I have to disagree on Mac. It doesn't seem contrived to me, not to mention the fact that Jack was not at risk of getting lynched at the time Mac moved his vote from him to notsawyer, and keeping it there would have looked pretty good for him later on
I tend to agree on llama.His confusion between Jack and Sawyer felt genuine, and I actually found it hard to set the two apart at first.
Then, there's the list of those voting for Scotty. I believe the baddies probably spread their votes around, and since Jack put his vote there, the chances for another baddie there are lower. I don't think it's notsawyer because I think he was being used as a possible target. I now don't think it's Marmot either.
Not sure yet whether you could be bad, but I'm not seeing it for now, and Eloh feels good to me.
I think there is a baddie in one of the solo voters or someone who didn't vote
Good work. What do you think is the most important thing we should take from this?
Also, I would like to point out that DFaraday, who has only three posts so far, came in close to the vote and claimed that he "randomized" his vote for me. Does anyone know of any scheduling or personal issues that preclude him from participating more fully?
While I'm on the topic of scheduling, I have three classes today and my commute is about an hour, so I'll be out with no computer access until it's Daytime in-game.
Fiddler on the Roof
