Elemental Mafia - Day 7

[Quin]

hi, i'm quin and i'm totally going to wing this game. please don't vote me out.

[Quin]

also i have 11 immunity idols

[sprityo]

also i have 11 immunity idols

A theory I'm willing to test

VOTE QUIN

[Golden]

@ Long Con: That was one damn fine Intro post you have there... made me feel like I was right in that cave witnessing all that was happening...

Oh, you haven't played a Long Con/Black Rock game yet, huh!

The masters of mythology. The prodigies of prose. The stars of storytelling.

No, indeed I have not, my friend It's awesome to be back playing a game with you though

[Quin]

also i have 11 immunity idols

A theory I'm willing to test

VOTE QUIN

[DrWilgy]

What is good fam?

[Bass_the_Clever]

What is good fam?

The site is back up!!! That's what's good.

[S~V~S]

Mediocrates, I lol'ed. Wonderful mood setting post,LC.

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I can't really see any benefits to it, but that is me, I am sure there is something I am missing. I think it is a good topic for conversation for sure.

Votes are changeable
Marmot isn't here...

So, I'll be marmot.

I randomised and I'm voting Dom for being shifty, k?

Glad we have changeable votes. I am dropping a temp vote on Golden because, well, because I like voting for Golden, it's a hobby of mine and i am sure he expects it, but also his temp vote randoming for a reason. Random or not?

*VOTING GOLDEN*

also i have 11 immunity idols

A theory I'm willing to test

VOTE QUIN

@Sprit~ you said you voted Quin, but no one voted for him in the poll. I'm confused? Did you forget to vote, or did you bold a joke vote? I only ask becasue it is gonna be hard enough to keep track of votes with no names in the polls.

(And so you know I still <3 you, Golden, I fixed your typo in your quote xoxo)

[S~V~S]

Also I find I am only vaguely amused by Negan memes, they're less threatening out of the tribal framing.

[Glorfindel]

It is indeed a singular pleasure to have you back and playing Mafia with me again, my friend!

[S~V~S]

It is indeed a singular pleasure to have you back and playing Mafia with me again, my friend!

You too!

Any thoughts on Bass' question; do you see and benefits or drawbacks to sharing info about our roles etc?

I think prefer not to, especially this early without having discussed it. But I do know that discussing things like this is something LC likes to do himself when he plays, so I am open to sharing if people present good reasons for it.

[Tranq]

Votes are changeable
Marmot isn't here...

So, I'll be marmot.

I randomised and I'm voting Dom or being shifty, k?

I wanted to be marmot.

LMS = Last Marmot Standing

[Long Con]

Current Vote Tally:

Dom - 1 (Golden)
Golden - 1 (S~V~S)

[Glorfindel]

It is indeed a singular pleasure to have you back and playing Mafia with me again, my friend!

You too!

Any thoughts on Bass' question; do you see and benefits or drawbacks to sharing info about our roles etc?

I think prefer not to, especially this early without having discussed it. But I do know that discussing things like this is something LC likes to do himself when he plays, so I am open to sharing if people present good reasons for it.

I've never played a game like this before, S-V-S so I'm feeling somewhat like a 'fish up a tree' with this. A game of Mafia with no 'baddies' is a conundrum for me. Like you, my initial reaction is to keep my role to myself and I can't see (at this point) any compelling argument to do so. I am curious though - are there equal numbers of each element or are some more 'rare' than others? If this question has already been answered somewhere, please forgive me - I'm notorious for lack of attention early in games of Mafia

[Tranq]

Any thoughts on Bass' question; do you see and benefits or drawbacks to sharing info about our roles etc?

I think prefer not to, especially this early without having discussed it. But I do know that discussing things like this is something LC likes to do himself when he plays, so I am open to sharing if people present good reasons for it.

This early in the game i'm not sure if there's any benefit in doing so. It would make for a boring couple of lynches, knowing everyone's role already. I like the Element of Surprise

[Glorfindel]

AMENDMENT:

It is indeed a singular pleasure to have you back and playing Mafia with me again, my friend!

You too!

Any thoughts on Bass' question; do you see and benefits or drawbacks to sharing info about our roles etc?

I think prefer not to, especially this early without having discussed it. But I do know that discussing things like this is something LC likes to do himself when he plays, so I am open to sharing if people present good reasons for it.

I've never played a game like this before, S-V-S so I'm feeling somewhat like a 'fish up a tree' with this. A game of Mafia with no 'baddies' is a conundrum for me. Like you, my initial reaction is to keep my role to myself and I can't see (at this point) any compelling argument NOT to do so. I am curious though - are there equal numbers of each element or are some more 'rare' than others? If this question has already been answered somewhere, please forgive me - I'm notorious for lack of attention early in games of Mafia

[sprityo]

@SVS I forgot to vote in the poll, I did now though

[Long Con]

Current Vote Tally:

Dom - 1 (Golden)
Golden - 1 (S~V~S)
Quin - 1 (sprityo)

[speedchuck]

It is indeed a singular pleasure to have you back and playing Mafia with me again, my friend!

You too!

Any thoughts on Bass' question; do you see and benefits or drawbacks to sharing info about our roles etc?

I think prefer not to, especially this early without having discussed it. But I do know that discussing things like this is something LC likes to do himself when he plays, so I am open to sharing if people present good reasons for it.

Given that I absolutely 100% do not want to lynch any holy elements, I differ slightly.
But I don't care about any of the other elements, so . We can let random chance handle it.

[Black Rock]

Just a small host announcement. Day 1 is set to 48 hours because we were still waiting for people to show up. If all votes are in and everyone is fine with their final vote then we will shorten the day. All days after this will be 24 hours.

[speedchuck]

Glorfindel is my top candidate for being holy cuz he's so nice. Maybe BassTheClever. They are lookin' pristine, ifn I do say so myself, and I jus' did.

Vote SVS

[DrWilgy]

Kay, I think I've figured out how I'm doing this.

Hello everyone, my name is DrWilgy and I am most definitely a doctor.

I'd like for 4 people to choose between red, blue, green, and white. No two should double up. First come first serve. Gogogo!!

[speedchuck]

White

[Long Con]

Current Vote Tally:

Dom - 1 (Golden)
Golden - 1 (S~V~S)
Quin - 1 (sprityo)
S~V~S - 1 (speedchuck)

Someone cast a second vote on Golden, but it wasn't in the thread so it's not in the tally yet.

[DharmaHelper]

I'm gonna hold my vote in case we end up with a tie situation and someone can beg me to save them

[DrWilgy]

I'm gonna hold my vote in case we end up with a tie situation and someone can beg me to save them

I respect this.

[S~V~S]

Glorfindel is my top candidate for being holy cuz he's so nice. Maybe BassTheClever. They are lookin' pristine, ifn I do say so myself, and I jus' did.

Vote SVS

Srs bsns reason or goofy reason?

[S~V~S]

I'm gonna hold my vote in case we end up with a tie situation and someone can beg me to save them

I respect this.

Yeah, me too, although putting people in the position of publicly begging may make them hold a grudge against the person who made them beg, so that is something to keep in mind.

I have a "People I won't vote for Day One" list. DH is one of them due to the hatchet job I did on him in Survivor.

[speedchuck]

Glorfindel is my top candidate for being holy cuz he's so nice. Maybe BassTheClever. They are lookin' pristine, ifn I do say so myself, and I jus' did.

Vote SVS

Srs bsns reason or goofy reason?

I don't see any reasons, goofy or not.

[speedchuck]

Also, we get notified when quoted now, which is pretty sweet.

[G-Man]

Going to be a little scarce until Thursday or Friday but I will do my best to chime in when I can. I see we can no longer click "REPLIES" in the Side Mission page to see post counts. Is there anyone who hasn't shown up yet? I'm not gunning after the no-shows just yet, because the UFH needs to be factored in to those who are late to the party at first. We'll see how I feel about that tomorrow.

Glorfindel- I'll be your friend this game. I promise!

[Sorsha]

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I'm waiting to be reminded by the hosts about the three elements I chose and I won't mind sharing a little bit at that time. There is one element that when combined with mine will be bad (just for that element and I). Other than that I'm going to hold off on sharing.

[Sorsha]

Kay, I think I've figured out how I'm doing this.

Hello everyone, my name is DrWilgy and I am most definitely a doctor.

I'd like for 4 people to choose between red, blue, green, and white. No two should double up. First come first serve. Gogogo!!

Blue

[speedchuck]

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I'm waiting to be reminded by the hosts about the three elements I chose and I won't mind sharing a little bit at that time. There is one element that when combined with mine will be bad (just for that element and I). Other than that I'm going to hold off on sharing.

Ooh, I didn't et any bad ones. That's interesting.

[Sorsha]

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I'm waiting to be reminded by the hosts about the three elements I chose and I won't mind sharing a little bit at that time. There is one element that when combined with mine will be bad (just for that element and I). Other than that I'm going to hold off on sharing.

Ooh, I didn't et any bad ones. That's interesting.

Oh I hope no one expects this game to be all candy apples and bon-bons!

[Tranq]

Sorsha, are you saying players shouldn't combine their element with yours?

[Sorsha]

Just one player that I know of.

[Sorsha]

Okay, I just got the pm from LC and its Darkness. I dont know who Darkness is and can't help if I chose that player but they should know that chosing to combine with me isn't advised. This is assuming that we would both get the same result from combining.

[speedchuck]

There aren't enough elements for players, btw. There could be more than one darkness player.

Riding the tide of sorsha's thing, I'll give an opposite thing: Good things happen if I find a holy element. For both of us.

@LC and BR: Are element combinings reversible? Is fire+darkness the same as darkness+fire?

[Long Con]

The alchemical combinations are still reacting... until this experiment is complete, it's really hard to say.

[Black Rock]

The alchemical combinations are still reacting... until this experiment is complete, it's really hard to say.

otherwise known as we're not giving you easy answers.

[sprityo]

I actually need my role resent to me too, along with my choices. It's not that I forgot it, it's just I would like to have it

[speedchuck]

The alchemical combinations are still reacting... until this experiment is complete, it's really hard to say.

otherwise known as we're not giving you easy answers.

That fair. No harm in asking though, ri- *explodes in elemental reactions*

[DharmaHelper]

Okay, I just got the pm from LC and its Darkness. I dont know who Darkness is and can't help if I chose that player but they should know that chosing to combine with me isn't advised. This is assuming that we would both get the same result from combining.

Don't pick me.

[sprityo]

Pick DharmaHelper

[Spacedaisy]

And it appears link back is a standard feature in this version.

[Elohcin]

What is good fam?

Stick with me if you know what's good for ya. I've been in two last man standing games and in both I've made it to the last few. I'm honest with those who allifn with me and won't turn on them unless it's the end and I have to.

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I'm waiting to be reminded by the hosts about the three elements I chose and I won't mind sharing a little bit at that time. There is one element that when combined with mine will be bad (just for that element and I). Other than that I'm going to hold off on sharing.

Ooh, I didn't et any bad ones. That's interesting.

I got one bad one too. But it wasn't darkness. I did choose darkness however as one of my three and darkness would be good for me. Shall I choose you, DH?

[DharmaHelper]

What is good fam?

Stick with me if you know what's good for ya. I've been in two last man standing games and in both I've made it to the last few. I'm honest with those who allifn with me and won't turn on them unless it's the end and I have to.

So what are people's thoughts about role and info sharing?

I'm waiting to be reminded by the hosts about the three elements I chose and I won't mind sharing a little bit at that time. There is one element that when combined with mine will be bad (just for that element and I). Other than that I'm going to hold off on sharing.

Ooh, I didn't et any bad ones. That's interesting.

I got one bad one too. But it wasn't darkness. I did choose darkness however as one of my three and darkness would be good for me. Shall I choose you, DH?

That depends.

[Elohcin]

When do we send in a name to combine with? At night? Or by EoD?

[speedchuck]

I'm gonna allifn with you Eloh if that's alright