Spider-verse Mafia [DAY 6]

[MacDougall]

Counterpoint, no.

Have you reversed your scumread on me yet?

I'll let you know after I cop check you

[Marmot]

Ok yeah, reywas is just scum here and so is Mac.

talk about why?

Mac has put some work in to defend reywas's chop. This is not what I'd expect from town Mac in the situation.


Per my point earlier, I think anyone who cast early shade on 112 is worth looking into since they might see 112 as a thread.


I'm also considering reversing my stance on KZA. His post asking 112 to "help" suddenly does look like open-wolfing if the mafia had all this knowledge already.

That post was a copypasta from our home forum actually, wasn't game related, sorry for any confusion

And yes this is the dumbest defence I've had to make in my career

When I say everyone, I think I do have to give some exception to CDC players. Y'all seem to post early scumreads on each other regardless. :P

[Marmot]

Counterpoint, no.

Have you reversed your scumread on me yet?

I'll let you know after I cop check you

Word.

[Kylemii]

Per my point earlier, I think anyone who cast early shade on 112 is worth looking into since they might see 112 as a thread.

do you mind expanding on this briefly?

[Marmot]

Per my point earlier, I think anyone who cast early shade on 112 is worth looking into since they might see 112 as a thread.

do you mind expanding on this briefly?

The lost wolf has an alternate win con that doesn't align with mafia. That reads as a possible mafia threat to me

[Kylemii]

Per my point earlier, I think anyone who cast early shade on 112 is worth looking into since they might see 112 as a thread.

do you mind expanding on this briefly?

The lost wolf has an alternate win con that doesn't align with mafia. That reads as a possible mafia threat to me

ah! ok.

so it's a role thing, and not 112 specifically who would be seen as a threat

[Marmot]

Not a thread. I mean, I get that we're spiders, but 112 meams more to me than his thread.

I assume this sort of topic has already been discussed @Kylemii so forgive me if I'm just rehashing old discussions

[Marmot]

Precisely

[Made]

But yeah, caught up tldr, reads on reywas are paper thin, sus on Nutella and Mac here. If reywas is bad, as marmot pointed out it means Mac is bad and is trying to bus. I don’t remember reading any opinions by MR on reywas. That’s suspicious

esooa Kyle me Guillotine dya are all obvious town

Paranoia doesn’t allow me to add Nanook and Marmot to obv town, but they’re prob not bad

G-man is either bad or just outta practice. ily, you don’t have to catch up or justify time you don’t have. But your need to stop being so defensive here pal.

Nutella Mac sus af, but prob only one is bad. Interactions between the two lead me to think the bad one is Mac

Falcon is hard to read. KZA’s “ALL HE DOES IS POST MEMES” reads like a baddie caught for the wrong reason. In my head I’m assuming Falcon is playing Kyles meta. This would mean he’s good, but not really sure either way here. Don’t feel the need to resolve this yet either.

Reywas could be a bus here. But on his post alone, he doesn’t look terrible. We could do worse

Epi is flying under the radar after his weird “Kyle thinks I’m wilgy, and therefore is bad” nonsense. I could see a Nutella Epi team here.

Imma go with a KZA vote and see how that feels

(Unless we’re ready to vote Mac)

[VOTE: KZA] aubergine

[Made]

What’s the case on TSP?

[Master Radishes]

Nah, Kaz is town. Try again.

I don’t remember reading any opinions by MR on reywas. That’s suspicious

Why?

[Made]

Actually what the hell Made? We vote G-man here

[VOTE: G-man] aubergine

[Master Radishes]

Also,

But yeah, caught up tldr, reads on reywas are paper thin, sus on Nutella and Mac here. If reywas is bad, as marmot pointed out it means Mac is bad and is trying to bus.

esooa Kyle me Guillotine dya are all obvious town

Paranoia doesn’t allow me to add Nanook and Marmot to obv town, but they’re prob not bad

The case on reywas is 'paper thin' and you're using it to suss Mac and Nut, yet half your obvious town are on Reywas too.

[nutella]

Esooa and I started the reywas train and I had to beat mac over the head to join it, so in that sense he could be bussing tbh

[nutella]

Gman and tsp are both just null lhf, if you wanna vote there it's whatever

[nutella]

KZA and radish are likely the same alignment and I lean town for now

[G-Man]

oh and also he was a cultist in one game and recruited me on n1 after i tunneled him day 1

cuz he was obviously not town, like he is here

how is he not town

you'd think people would stop questioning my d1 reads but then again i guess not

Posting this for posterity. This is all so hilarious to me. All these great mafia players, or so I’ve been led to believe, found baddie Reywas based on what exactly? There’s a lot to read and I haven’t been able to find the actual reason for the season. I’ll assume it’s because I said I was gonna use tarot to place my vote? Lmao

Ok then. Another reason I find this so hysterical is because after I signed up but before the roles went out I said in the discord, “I’m gonna end up lynched on day one for being weird.”

So, either you guys are just not that good at mafia OR some of you are full of shit.

Guys Mac is so good you just GOTTA trust his day one reads, guys. Ya just gotta.

Lol well at least you can’t use that line ever again, Big Mac.

I’m not mafia. Ffs anyone that has played with me before and thinks I would say some Tarot shit like that if I had teammates to think about...well you aren’t very mafia bright tbh.

Remember that no one is ever as good at mafia as they may boast, and that one of the key components of mafia is the ability to convince people after the fact that you weren’t as full of shit as you really were.

[nutella]

Marmot is actually playing now but he's certainly not out of scumrange, he's on my squintylist

[Made]

Also,

But yeah, caught up tldr, reads on reywas are paper thin, sus on Nutella and Mac here. If reywas is bad, as marmot pointed out it means Mac is bad and is trying to bus.

esooa Kyle me Guillotine dya are all obvious town

Paranoia doesn’t allow me to add Nanook and Marmot to obv town, but they’re prob not bad

The case on reywas is 'paper thin' and you're using it to suss Mac and Nut, yet half your obvious town are on Reywas too.

It really do be like that.
The case was Esooa’s idea and Nutella immediately sheeped. Since it was Esooa’s find I don’t think it’s a bad look for her. Idk where else guillotine would be voting right now tbh, so I give that a bye. I doubt the vote intend to stay there.

The dya vote is the most sus after Mac and Nutella, but I still think they’re town based on takes. Those aren’t the only reason I sus Mac and Nutella by the way. Add up the point, yo

Also re: yourself Mr. MR, I don’t like when players don’t take hard stances on wagons. You haven’t mentioned reywas all game. What are your thoughts on the merits of the wagon?

[Master Radishes]

Also,

But yeah, caught up tldr, reads on reywas are paper thin, sus on Nutella and Mac here. If reywas is bad, as marmot pointed out it means Mac is bad and is trying to bus.

esooa Kyle me Guillotine dya are all obvious town

Paranoia doesn’t allow me to add Nanook and Marmot to obv town, but they’re prob not bad

The case on reywas is 'paper thin' and you're using it to suss Mac and Nut, yet half your obvious town are on Reywas too.

It really do be like that.
The case was Esooa’s idea and Nutella immediately sheeped. Since it was Esooa’s find I don’t think it’s a bad look for her. Idk where else guillotine would be voting right now tbh, so I give that a bye. I doubt the vote intend to stay there.

The dya vote is the most sus after Mac and Nutella, but I still think they’re town based on takes. Those aren’t the only reason I sus Mac and Nutella by the way. Add up the point, yo

Seems reasonable.

Also re: yourself Mr. MR, I don’t like when players don’t take hard stances on wagons. You haven’t mentioned reywas all game. What are your thoughts on the merits of the wagon?

There are a lot of players I haven't taken stances on.

[reywaS]

Are there seriously 8 baddies in this game??

I apologize for not making an immediate return to my prime days on day one after mostly not playing for 4 plus years.

How much you played before this long hiatus?
Can you describe your play?

I played a ton on another forum and played probably 20 ish games on this site before going on hiatus.

My play is always all over the place. I’m always a lot more out there and weird when I don’t have teammates to consider. I usually do best in Indy roles.

There are people in this game that know how I play.

[Made]

Also re: yourself Mr. MR, I don’t like when players don’t take hard stances on wagons. You haven’t mentioned reywas all game. What are your thoughts on the merits of the wagon?

There are a lot of players I haven't taken stances on.

Same. Is your lack of a stance on reywas intentional or nah? If nah, what are your thoughts?

[Master Radishes]

Also re: yourself Mr. MR, I don’t like when players don’t take hard stances on wagons. You haven’t mentioned reywas all game. What are your thoughts on the merits of the wagon?

There are a lot of players I haven't taken stances on.

Same. Is your lack of a stance on reywas intentional or nah? If nah, what are your thoughts?

Yeah one of those.

[KZA]

But yeah, caught up tldr, reads on reywas are paper thin, sus on Nutella and Mac here. If reywas is bad, as marmot pointed out it means Mac is bad and is trying to bus. I don’t remember reading any opinions by MR on reywas. That’s suspicious

esooa Kyle me Guillotine dya are all obvious town

Paranoia doesn’t allow me to add Nanook and Marmot to obv town, but they’re prob not bad

G-man is either bad or just outta practice. ily, you don’t have to catch up or justify time you don’t have. But your need to stop being so defensive here pal.

Nutella Mac sus af, but prob only one is bad. Interactions between the two lead me to think the bad one is Mac

Falcon is hard to read. KZA’s “ALL HE DOES IS POST MEMES” reads like a baddie caught for the wrong reason. In my head I’m assuming Falcon is playing Kyles meta. This would mean he’s good, but not really sure either way here. Don’t feel the need to resolve this yet either.

Reywas could be a bus here. But on his post alone, he doesn’t look terrible. We could do worse

Epi is flying under the radar after his weird “Kyle thinks I’m wilgy, and therefore is bad” nonsense. I could see a Nutella Epi team here.

Imma go with a KZA vote and see how that feels

(Unless we’re ready to vote Mac)

[VOTE: KZA] aubergine

Why is MR specifically suspicious for not taking a stance on Rey? Pretty sure he's not the only one that didn't.

also I'm confused when was I "caught" or even voted for

[Marmot]

Marmot is actually playing now but he's certainly not out of scumrange, he's on my squintylist

Squintsy squint.

[Marmot]

My scumrange is massive, so I understand your concern nutella.

[G-Man]

G-man is either bad or just outta practice. ily, you don’t have to catch up or justify time you don’t have. But your need to stop being so defensive here pal.

Rusty like a wheelbarrow that only gets used three times a year. That’s about as often as I play anymore, and my civ game has always been lacking. I don’t keep up with all the new faces and meta, so I have a tendency to just stand in the middle of the stream and see what happens, rather than swim with it or against it. I am here for the experience of a flavorful LC game, not so much for the playing of the game itself. I am filling a role slot and present. I don’t intend to come off as defensive; I’m just disinterested in participating at the same level as most of you.

[nutella]

[Master Radishes]

Why is MR specifically suspicious for not taking a stance on Rey? Pretty sure he's not the only one that didn't.

Also I was actually asleep for the entirety of the Reywas wagon, and only recently returned to the thread, so...

[Master Radishes]

There's just, like...so much I could nitpick about Made's ketchup post.



So...he's probably just town.

[Master Radishes]

Since there are so many players and it's clearly hard to keep track of everyone, maybe we should divide the roster into different groups of 4-5 and each group only focuses on reading the others within it.

Spoiler: show

Bwoooonnngggg

[Michelle]

Are there seriously 8 baddies in this game??

I apologize for not making an immediate return to my prime days on day one after mostly not playing for 4 plus years.

How much you played before this long hiatus?
Can you describe your play?

I played a ton on another forum and played probably 20 ish games on this site before going on hiatus.

My play is always all over the place. I’m always a lot more out there and weird when I don’t have teammates to consider. I usually do best in Indy roles.

There are people in this game that know how I play.

Who are they?

[Marmot]

who is this raywaS person?

Tom Sawyer's morally backwards cousin.

I think this is the only thing 112 has said about reywas in the last 24 hours, I do want to hear an updated opinion @112

[Marmot]

112 open claiming suggests that he is open to aligning with civilians, but there is the possibility that 112 is actually just another wolf hiding under that guise.

[Marmot]

Are wolfspiders a thing?

[KZA]

112 open claiming suggests that he is open to aligning with civilians, but there is the possibility that 112 is actually just another wolf hiding under that guise.

Well Quas confirmed 112 is the lost wolf

So unless they're both normal wolves trying some ridiculous gambit we can probably trust that lol

[Marmot]

112 open claiming suggests that he is open to aligning with civilians, but there is the possibility that 112 is actually just another wolf hiding under that guise.

Well Quas confirmed 112 is the lost wolf

So unless they're both normal wolves trying some ridiculous gambit we can probably trust that lol

Oh right, forgot about that.

[reywaS]

i don't think their votes on you are just for lacking, mine isn't. It's about the fact that you weren't doing much in thread and the only read you gave was 112 smelling foul

what made you post that?

@reywaS

112’s post rang of shite to me. Simple as that.

Okay here's the solve fam.

Day 1 kill Reywas.

If Reywas is town kill Guillo day 2.

If day 3 we haven't killed mafia kill Nutella or Dyachei if they alive. If they are both dead you can just kill me because the game will be lost for town anyway by then.

Esooa and nanook are going to live til min day 5 as either alignment so if you're both town you better pace yourselves.

Let's autopilot dis.

I dont like this post at all, i think mac could be scum here.

First he conditions my survival to someone's flip, feels like setting me up for a yeet tomorrow now that he sees that i might not be flipped today.

Second, if he knows im not mafia he is saying he plans to push Nutella or Dyachei, meaning there gotta be a suspicion for that thought process but he has yet to call it out (or i missed it), unless they are exactly his scum buddies and he plans to change his mind.

Third, the comment about Esooa and Nanook, it feels like if both are town, are his pocket candidates to take to day5.

mac, as a data point you have suspected me early in every game we've ever played in where i've been town.

It looks like im gonna be your replacement when he gets tired of you.

I'm not voting Guillo unless you have good reasons too, cause I think his approach is towny due to it being so interspersed among people, it doesn't seem like it's directed in any way. For example scum reading 112 out of the blue, camping his vote on her, then after that dissolves, continuing to want them lynched, then immediately switching from trying to push outed scum, to hard pushing obv!town falcon, he just seems like he's doing his normal wacko stuff lmfao

And I think the 112 vote looked good and not like a bus, but maybe need to look into him more

Why did you disagree with the Epi read?

Is there anyone else you would put in scum?

That bittersweet moment when someone townreads you for being a wacko and you have to take what you can.

I am pretty confident that Esooa and Nutella are town but I am not really comfortable calling anyone else town. Esooa more so tbh. Falcon and Epi are also pretty strong town. I don't really feel like anyone else is out of their scumrange. Dyachei did do a thing where they were like "I feel like Quas would be townreading me if they were town" before Quas outed themselves as 3p which actually that is incredibly townie tbh so I'm gonna just lock Dya as town for now to make the game easier. Nanook is sheeping nutella and seems nanook like i guess so he can be town til he gets POE killed with his teammates all dying before him (or is on a wolf team that will easy win). I guess that makes Reywas likely a hit if all that is the case and if that's the case then someone is bussing Reywas and it's literally Guillotina (or me I suppose if you want to make a sucky read).

tl;dr Guillotina is mafia always here.

Lol you saw that one coming didnt you? The sucky read? It's called a guilty conscience.

If Reywa is scum I'm not the busser although, if you are town who is convinced that im scum i can see where the logic is coming from.

I am pretty confident that Esooa and Nutella are town but I am not really comfortable calling anyone else town. Esooa more so tbh. Falcon and Epi are also pretty strong town. I don't really feel like anyone else is out of their scumrange. Dyachei did do a thing where they were like "I feel like Quas would be townreading me if they were town" before Quas outed themselves as 3p which actually that is incredibly townie tbh so I'm gonna just lock Dya as town for now to make the game easier. Nanook is sheeping nutella and seems nanook like i guess so he can be town til he gets POE killed with his teammates all dying before him (or is on a wolf team that will easy win). I guess that makes Reywas likely a hit if all that is the case and if that's the case then someone is bussing Reywas and it's literally Guillotina (or me I suppose if you want to make a sucky read).

tl;dr Guillotina is mafia always here.

that last part doesnt really follow, why does there have to be a busser on rey already?

Because of the high amount of towncred you'd get maybe? What wolf busses on Day 1? Seems something I would if I was a wolf, maybe that's Mac's logic behind it. If I was scum with low effort Reywa!scum, i'd buss her and ride on that towncred.

[VOTE: Guillotine] aubergine

Does not sound trustworthy at all to me so that’s where my vote is going rn

There is absolutely no cap in my rap.

And look who are voting for me at the moment i clicked to reply to this. Falcon and Reywa.

@Esooa why is Falcon obv!town?

Impressed I am not.

@reywaS if you get yourself lynched day 1 in the first game we've played together in 4 years i'm going to take legal action. i'm gonna sue your ass dude.

Get myself lynched for what exactly? I’m not even sure the context yet because there are 30 pages to catch up on. Whatever it is it’s obviously a ball cap of a case.

Hey this dude is being weird! Let’s lunch his out of practice ass!

I’m assuming this is how it went. Seems legit

You are making it sound like i should give you a pass for being out of practice. Questions.

1) How are you being out of practice justify your fluff.
2) Wouldn't out-of-practice scum!you look this lost?

Out of practice meaning not jumping in head first and obsessively reading 2200 posts. It’s not an easy thing to do. It took me a while to get into the flow of the game. I won’t apologize for it. If you want to lunch me because I didn’t post enough for your liking so be it. It’s dumb but whatever.

I agree and glad you said a lynch of me would be low effort. Nobody be puttin any effort to make a case cuz there don’t be one there to make.

An out of practice scum me would probably be super nervous to say anything at all. JS I don’t like letting teammates down.

@reywaS welcome back, please explain this post

Hi guys! Just a spider tryna sling some web here. Happy to dip
My pretty little toes back into the mafia pool. Be gentle.

When did you get so good at this game

I've been ahead of the mafia meta for ages, it's finally caught up with me.

Calm down rorschach

Haha. Mac is funny confirmed.

Welcome back to the game of mafia. Whobad??

112 smells a bit foul tbh

I hadn’t read the roles when I said that. It was a purely speculative feeling based in 112s posts.

112 was the only person at the time that made furrow my brow at the time. I want to contribute and help. I didn’t come back to the game only to fuck off and die straight away.

oh and also he was a cultist in one game and recruited me on n1 after i tunneled him day 1

cuz he was obviously not town, like he is here

how is he not town

you'd think people would stop questioning my d1 reads but then again i guess not

Posting this for posterity. This is all so hilarious to me. All these great mafia players, or so I’ve been led to believe, found baddie Reywas based on what exactly? There’s a lot to read and I haven’t been able to find the actual reason for the season. I’ll assume it’s because I said I was gonna use tarot to place my vote? Lmao

Ok then. Another reason I find this so hysterical is because after I signed up but before the roles went out I said in the discord, “I’m gonna end up lynched on day one for being weird.”

So, either you guys are just not that good at mafia OR some of you are full of shit.

Guys Mac is so good you just GOTTA trust his day one reads, guys. Ya just gotta.

Lol well at least you can’t use that line ever again, Big Mac.

I’m not mafia. Ffs anyone that has played with me before and thinks I would say some Tarot shit like that if I had teammates to think about...well you aren’t very mafia bright tbh.

Remember that no one is ever as good at mafia as they may boast, and that one of the key components of mafia is the ability to convince people after the fact that you weren’t as full of shit as you really were.

No doubt. I was directly addressing his claim that his day 1 reads shouldn’t be questioned.

[Grogu]

Hi, did 112 claim something else? Why are we not killing scum?

[Grogu]

Hi, did 112 claim something else? Why are we not killing scum?

[Grogu]

*69
NICE

[Grogu]

112 open claiming suggests that he is open to aligning with civilians, but there is the possibility that 112 is actually just another wolf hiding under that guise.

Well Quas confirmed 112 is the lost wolf

So unless they're both normal wolves trying some ridiculous gambit we can probably trust that lol

KZA is ToWn!
We should be lovers, if you die I want to die also. I really like how smart you are, no one else sees the game like we do.

[Grogu]

KZA is my jaggedjimmy this game. What a legend!

[BoKnows]

wth baby yoda

[Michelle]

Grogu double posting saying he wants to kill scum means he really wants that

[Michelle]

KZA is my jaggedjimmy this game. What a legend!

This is a thing I need proof for tbh

[Michelle]

I remember someone said (Nutella but i am not 100% sure) that TSP is lhf
Why is he considered lhf?

[nutella]

I remember someone said (Nutella but i am not 100% sure) that TSP is lhf
Why is he considered lhf?

he has only 14 posts and I don't remember any content in them. He's second lowest to enrique with 5

[nutella]

Rey didn't really explain what he found sus in 112 still. I think the fact that 112 is the name that stood out to him early makes him >>rand likely to be mafia

[Kylemii]

what is lhf