Frisky Dingo ENDGAME

[Marmot]

Theoretically, Xander could say "Cliff and Clint, target this player tonight".

But if Cliff is nightkilled, nobody would know he was dead, so this strategy might not be ideal. Imo, Xander would be better off choosing players he thinks should be nightkilled.

[Scotty]

RULES
1. No illegal BTSC with anyone, ever. Seriously.
2. No editing or deleting of posts.
3. No on topic talk from dead players. Please use Dead Red to post off topic.
4. No role outing. Infodumping should be handled with extreme caution.
5. No reproducing the host PMs in thread.
6. No jackassery. If you feel the need to be a jackass, send a message to the Mod on Duty istead of posting it in the thread. This is a big one.
7. Have fun!

I noticed this as well. I think extreme caution indicates that role outing should not be insinuated with an info dump. That is just a guess.

[Long Con]

LC, I don't think you're thinking through these strategies, and honestly I don't think you are on Xander's team.

I'm not sure why you felt the need to let us all know how honest you are being when you said that. Maybe you thought that if you had said "I don't think you're on Xander's team", we might not think you were being honest about it. So, good thing you clarified that with a totally necessary adverb.

As for thinking through these strategies, the problem you are having is a lack of vision. This can be done, and it can be well-coordinated and executed by Xander. We can make him invincible. Unlynchable, unkillable.

I took Llama's rule to mean in-thread stuff. If he wants to limit what Xander can say in the secret message, so be it. The Xtacles will know soon enough.

[Scotty]

Theoretically, Xander could say "Cliff and Clint, target this player tonight".

But if Cliff is nightkilled, nobody would know he was dead, so this strategy might not be ideal. Imo, Xander would be better off choosing players he thinks should be nightkilled.

Ahhh, I didn't take into account that the Xtacles would know their own name.

So yes, hmm, this strategy could work for at least the first few days, until too many people are NK'd, then it would be dicey.

LC, I don't think you're thinking through these strategies, and honestly I don't think you are on Xander's team.

I'm not sure why you felt the need to let us all know how honest you are being when you said that. Maybe you thought that if you had said "I don't think you're on Xander's team", we might not think you were being honest about it. So, good thing you clarified that with a totally necessary adverb.

Don't get me started on adverbs. I use a lot of them, and tend to write how I talk, so deal with it.

As for thinking through these strategies, the problem you are having is a lack of vision. This can be done, and it can be well-coordinated and executed by Xander. We can make him invincible. Unlynchable, unkillable.

I took Llama's rule to mean in-thread stuff. If he wants to limit what Xander can say in the secret message, so be it. The Xtacles will know soon enough.

I'll admit that I haven't submitted any strategies myself, and have only harped on your ideas. Because if we follow through with your plan, what happens after a few Xylaphones are possibly killed at Night? This bold strategy will not make him invincible in the long run.

So are you saying you are an Xtentacle with that "we"?

[Long Con]

No, I wasn't claiming Xtacle with that "we". That "we" was in reference to "we as a group of players".

If my plan goes through, then each Xtacle and Xander will know the identity of each other one, and will know if an Xtacle dies. The Xtacle strategy would then be adjusted for that new circumstance.

[DharmaHelper]

LC, I don't think you're thinking through these strategies, and honestly I don't think you are on Xander's team.

I'm not sure why you felt the need to let us all know how honest you are being when you said that. Maybe you thought that if you had said "I don't think you're on Xander's team", we might not think you were being honest about it. So, good thing you clarified that with a totally necessary adverb.

As for thinking through these strategies, the problem you are having is a lack of vision. This can be done, and it can be well-coordinated and executed by Xander. We can make him invincible. Unlynchable, unkillable.

I took Llama's rule to mean in-thread stuff. If he wants to limit what Xander can say in the secret message, so be it. The Xtacles will know soon enough.

Honestly is an aderb

[DharmaHelper]

Theoretically, Xander could say "Cliff and Clint, target this player tonight".

But if Cliff is nightkilled, nobody would know he was dead, so this strategy might not be ideal. Imo, Xander would be better off choosing players he thinks should be nightkilled.

Ahhh, I didn't take into account that the Xtacles would know their own name.

So yes, hmm, this strategy could work for at least the first few days, until too many people are NK'd, then it would be dicey.

LC, I don't think you're thinking through these strategies, and honestly I don't think you are on Xander's team.

I'm not sure why you felt the need to let us all know how honest you are being when you said that. Maybe you thought that if you had said "I don't think you're on Xander's team", we might not think you were being honest about it. So, good thing you clarified that with a totally necessary adverb.

Don't get me started on adverbs. I use a lot of them, and tend to write how I talk, so deal with it.

As for thinking through these strategies, the problem you are having is a lack of vision. This can be done, and it can be well-coordinated and executed by Xander. We can make him invincible. Unlynchable, unkillable.

I took Llama's rule to mean in-thread stuff. If he wants to limit what Xander can say in the secret message, so be it. The Xtacles will know soon enough.

I'll admit that I haven't submitted any strategies myself, and have only harped on your ideas. Because if we follow through with your plan, what happens after a few Xylaphones are possibly killed at Night? This bold strategy will not make him invincible in the long run.

So are you saying you are an Xtentacle with that "we"?

Possibly is also an adverb! GET HIM!

[DharmaHelper]

[thellama73]

Llama: In future lynches, would you mind reordering the players alphabetically? Because it makes it easier to keep track of everything!

I will totally do that.

[thellama73]

I also want to say that you all seem to be having fun, and that makes me a happy llama.

[Scotty]

u jus weight wen Epicnoses cohms on & c u makin dat gramar mistaiks.

[Made]

I also want to say that you all seem to be having fun, and that makes me a happy llama.

This "fun" however does not make for a happy Made, as I am actually getting nothing from what has been said so far. I suppose I can start with the salt spewing:

Ahem
MP smells funny
Nightwing is a second rate superhero

Actually tho, no pings thus far :/

[Roxy]

I will be voting for anyone that votes a new player to me.

*eyes Epi and MP*

Don't understand what LC is on about with the xtancle thing but that does not make him suspicious in my mafia playbook what does read suspiciously is Scotty's take on LC's post about it but I won't be voting Scotty Day 1 but may consider it for Day 2.

I also won't be voting Hambuger Boy, Ika, Sig, Mac's Mom or Saberfish.

I likely will not be voting Das Porcu or Made either.

Everyone else is fair game for me

I am not liking Gmans style this game the Magic 8 balls have always given me the creeps. It, however, is nothing to vote over.

I totes believe SVS when she said she had misread the roles. I read them and still do not understand them all.
Wish I was apje and could ask a ton a poignant questions about them.

I will catch back up after work and see if I feel anything else.

[DharmaHelper]

I also want to say that you all seem to be having fun, and that makes me a happy llama.

This "fun" however does not make for a happy Made, as I am actually getting nothing from what has been said so far. I suppose I can start with the salt spewing:

Ahem
MP smells funny
Nightwing is a second rate superhero

Actually tho, no pings thus far :/

NIGHTWING?


NIGHTWING?

What the fuck man.

[DharmaHelper]

I will be voting for anyone that votes a new player to me.

*eyes Epi and MP*

Don't understand what LC is on about with the xtancle thing but that does not make him suspicious in my mafia playbook what does read suspiciously is Scotty's take on LC's post about it but I won't be voting Scotty Day 1 but may consider it for Day 2.

I also won't be voting Hambuger Boy, Ika, Sig, Mac's Mom or Saberfish.

I likely will not be voting Das Porcu or Made either.

Everyone else is fair game for me

I am not liking Gmans style this game the Magic 8 balls have always given me the creeps. It, however, is nothing to vote over.

I totes believe SVS when she said she had misread the roles. I read them and still do not understand them all.
Wish I was apje and could ask a ton a poignant questions about them.

I will catch back up after work and see if I feel anything else.

Would you be willing to explain why the players you mentioned are exempt from your vote?

[DharmaHelper]

I will be voting for Made from now on.

[Made]

I will be voting for Made from now on.

Baller

[Made]

Would you be willing to explain why the players you mentioned are exempt from your vote?

[Long Con]

DharmaHelper: Do you consider Nightwing to be a first-rate superhero?

Roxy: Would you like to see an extensive example of how Xander and the Xtacles might secure the game a lot more tightly for the Civs, provided it gets the host's blessing?

[DharmaHelper]

DharmaHelper: Do you consider Nightwing to be a first-rate superhero?

Roxy: Would you like to see an extensive example of how Xander and the Xtacles might secure the game a lot more tightly for the Civs, provided it gets the host's blessing?

I think he's ok.

[Marmot]

Marmotorhead: Frisky-disky ding-dong
Marmotorhead: Where have all the baddies gone?

[Epignosis]

DharmaHelper: Do you consider Nightwing to be a first-rate superhero?

Roxy: Would you like to see an extensive example of how Xander and the Xtacles might secure the game a lot more tightly for the Civs, provided it gets the host's blessing?

I think he's ok.

[Elohcin]

This game has been so fun to read so far. Sorry it took me so long to get into Day 1. Four and a half hours left and I have no clue who I want to vote for. I don't see anyone standing out with mafia behavior but with so many new (to the syndicate) players, it will be hard to tell. Plus several players have yet to say anything or much.

@ G-Man - do you plan on keeping this gimmick up all game? How will be know your suspects or how will you make a case for anyone. I do think your gimmick is pretty awesome this game. It would be really cool as an insanifier. However, I am not sure you can actually play the game this way. Am I underestimating the G-Man?

You're Mafia. I'm confident. 100% I'll stake my Mafia reputation on it, MP.

Lol. Real funny. :P

But you're wrong.

But...but...what if I'm right?

Not possible, my friend.

How many drinks have you had? :P

At my age, I stop counting. 14 is a close mark.

Trying to discredit me?

I went to bed close to 11pm and he wasn't drunk at the time. I think its said this post was around 11:30 or so.

[Elohcin]

durp....day ends tomorrow. No wonder no one's talkin'.

[Marmot]

durp....day ends tomorrow. No wonder no one's talkin'.

I'm lurking.

[G-Man]

@ G-Man - do you plan on keeping this gimmick up all game?

It is certain

How will be know your suspects or how will you make a case for anyone.

Cannot predict now

Am I underestimating the G-Man?

As I see it, yes

[S~V~S]

Who should I vote for today?

You should vote for Stan.

I'm sorry, but who's Stan?

Stan is a guy who's going to automatically start killing some relatively important Civs every day on Day 2.

Stan - Runs the Crews company when Xander is too lazy to do it, but has no real allegiance except to himself. Briefly masqueraded as Awesome-X. While he is alive, one of the Xtacles’ heads will explode every day.

Sorry guys, I didn't realize that we had started!

I'm a little pinged by the fact that SVS apparently misread the roles, since her reply to Long Con about the Xtacles isn't accurate. But I suppose that's a ping that doesn't really indicate an alignment so I'm not sure where to go with it. I'll tune in more tomorrow night. Game on!

I dont really see how misunderstanding the roles could be indicative of her alignment. Are you thinking from an angle like baddies don't have to care as much as Civvies about understanding all the roles maybe?

I misunderstood Xanders messages, I was thinking any civs could get that info. Even understanding it, I am still leery of Xander sharing his identity. Although I think the risk is fairly minimal since the roles are not very vague as llama roles can sometimes be. I am sure Timmer has seen me make similar careless errors regardless of alignment, so Timmer. The last game we played together I went the whole game having misread my own role Lol.

I have read the Epi MP convo a few times. If I have learned anything it is that blurting out my opinion on either can be a mistake for me so I want to reserve judgment at this time.

My phone corrected Xander to Cancer yikes. And the color tags are really hard to read on the light theme, so I may have to switch to dark for this game.

Ok, no more colour tags.

And you're wrong, Xander should absolutely let the Xtacles know who he is. For starters, we won't be mislynching him then. And if he can get the Xtacles coordinated, they could actually protect him at night, every night! In addition to that, so long as enough live, they could coordinate a roleblock every night as well, which could end up finding baddies when kills fail.

Thats a good thing, you're right. I just get really paranoid about important roles taking risks. But the rish to reard ratio would be low, so I will stop worrying about it. Plus didn't Llama cut a few Xtacles?

And you did not have to change the colors, it was fun. But old eyes, tiny phone screen. I was bemoaning that rather than the colors themselves.

[Roxy]

I will be voting for anyone that votes a new player to me.

*eyes Epi and MP*

Don't understand what LC is on about with the xtancle thing but that does not make him suspicious in my mafia playbook what does read suspiciously is Scotty's take on LC's post about it but I won't be voting Scotty Day 1 but may consider it for Day 2.

I also won't be voting Hambuger Boy, Ika, Sig, Mac's Mom or Saberfish.

I likely will not be voting Das Porcu or Made either.

Everyone else is fair game for me

I am not liking Gmans style this game the Magic 8 balls have always given me the creeps. It, however, is nothing to vote over.

I totes believe SVS when she said she had misread the roles. I read them and still do not understand them all.
Wish I was apje and could ask a ton a poignant questions about them.

I will catch back up after work and see if I feel anything else.

Would you be willing to explain why the players you mentioned are exempt from your vote?

Sure but you should know me well enough by now to answer this question for yourself.

Scotty, Mac's Mom, Sig, Ika, Saberfish and Hamburger Boy are new players to me since I do not remember playing with them before (I may have played with Ika but I do not remember) so since I do not like to vote for new players I won't vote them on Day 1.

As for that prickly Porcupine and Made - well it has been sometime since I have played with either so I would like to enjoy more than one day of playing with them before I layeth the smackdown of my vote onto them.

Its been awhile since we have played DH so I prob will not vote for you either tbh.

[Roxy]

DharmaHelper: Do you consider Nightwing to be a first-rate superhero?

Roxy: Would you like to see an extensive example of how Xander and the Xtacles might secure the game a lot more tightly for the Civs, provided it gets the host's blessing?

I actually would like to see it. But also explained simply like you are talking to a child or as in my case an old lady.

[Roxy]

durp....day ends tomorrow. No wonder no one's talkin'.

I'm lurking.

and spamming --- just sayin'

[Epignosis]

I'll probably vote a new person just to incur Roxy's wrath.

[Roxy]

I'll probably vote a new person just to incur Roxy's wrath.

[Tangrowth]

So, seriously, who hasn't posted yet (still)?

Sig, Mac's Mom, and Saberfish?

Is that right?

I'm glad, on the one hand, that there haven't been many posts, because my life is super busy right now, but man this is a boring Day 1 so far.

Maybe I'll cast my vote soon.

[Tangrowth]

And Rox, I want the new folks to stick around, so I understand your hesitation to vote for them, but I really wish they'd come in and at least say something, even if it's "I don't know what to post".

I don't want Llama's game to be disrespected, and I don't want to have a situation where we have 3+ complete nonparticipants a few cycles from now, and then we have a giant debate as to what to do with them. That's just annoying, IMO.

[Tangrowth]

I'm trying as hard as I can to play a "zany" game and just pick someone for my vote, but I'm having trouble not being super srs bsns MP.

[Roxy]

So, seriously, who hasn't posted yet (still)?

Sig, Mac's Mom, and Saberfish?

Is that right?

I'm glad, on the one hand, that there haven't been many posts, because my life is super busy right now, but man this is a boring Day 1 so far.

Maybe I'll cast my vote soon.

srsly calm down we have until tomorrow night

Besides if ya posted more it would not be near as boring

Linky - Zany MP? LOL Zany MO does not vote a day early he waits until the funniest moment to place his vote

[Roxy]

aww damn

Not Zany MO but Zany MP would wait until it was funniest moment to place his vote

[Tangrowth]

So, seriously, who hasn't posted yet (still)?

Sig, Mac's Mom, and Saberfish?

Is that right?

I'm glad, on the one hand, that there haven't been many posts, because my life is super busy right now, but man this is a boring Day 1 so far.

Maybe I'll cast my vote soon.

srsly calm down we have until tomorrow night

Besides if ya posted more it would not be near as boring

Linky - Zany MP? LOL Zany MP does not vote a day early he waits until the funniest moment to place his vote

I know we do; I'm just impatient. :P

Well, I'm trying, but I'm playing a game on RYM and barely participating enough there (but I'll be lynched shortly here, I'm sure of it), and I have ten million things to do before I leave for Ohio next Wednesday. I'd love to post more, trust me.

Anyone want to donate to the "MP post more" fund by paying me some money? I can be a professional mafia player.

Good point.

[Tangrowth]

I GUESS I can wait to cast my vote. You all are boring. Not frisky enough.

It's Frisky Fucking Dingo, where's the frisky?

[Roxy]

And Rox, I want the new folks to stick around, so I understand your hesitation to vote for them, but I really wish they'd come in and at least say something, even if it's "I don't know what to post".

I don't want Llama's game to be disrespected, and I don't want to have a situation where we have 3+ complete nonparticipants a few cycles from now, and then we have a giant debate as to what to do with them. That's just annoying, IMO.

Thats what MdKills are for and Hosts need to learn to do it.

The last game I hosted (it was not here but on AW) I ModKilled a record 5 people for non participation. I find ModKilling to be quite liberating

[Epignosis]

I GUESS I can wait to cast my vote. You all are boring. Not frisky enough.

It's Frisky Fucking Dingo, where's the frisky?

Before the fucking?

[Tangrowth]

And Rox, I want the new folks to stick around, so I understand your hesitation to vote for them, but I really wish they'd come in and at least say something, even if it's "I don't know what to post".

I don't want Llama's game to be disrespected, and I don't want to have a situation where we have 3+ complete nonparticipants a few cycles from now, and then we have a giant debate as to what to do with them. That's just annoying, IMO.

Thats what MdKills are for and Hosts need to learn to do it.

The last game I hosted (it was not here but on AW) I ModKilled a record 5 people for non participation. I find ModKilling to be quite liberating

Well, you know I'm not afraid to modkill.

[Tangrowth]

I GUESS I can wait to cast my vote. You all are boring. Not frisky enough.

It's Frisky Fucking Dingo, where's the frisky?

Before the fucking?

Boosh.

[Long Con]

Seriously. Fight Club Mafia's survivors are still meeting with counsellors weekly.

[Long Con]

I GUESS I can wait to cast my vote. You all are boring. Not frisky enough.

It's Frisky Fucking Dingo, where's the frisky?

Am I not at all Frisky with my fun colours and my cool plan?

[thellama73]

And Rox, I want the new folks to stick around, so I understand your hesitation to vote for them, but I really wish they'd come in and at least say something, even if it's "I don't know what to post".

I don't want Llama's game to be disrespected, and I don't want to have a situation where we have 3+ complete nonparticipants a few cycles from now, and then we have a giant debate as to what to do with them. That's just annoying, IMO.

Thats what MdKills are for and Hosts need to learn to do it.

The last game I hosted (it was not here but on AW) I ModKilled a record 5 people for non participation. I find ModKilling to be quite liberating

I already have one replacement lined up which I am not afraid to use. I am good friends with Mac's Mom and have ben bugging him to post. He seems very cofused by the whole thing. If it comes to modkilling, I am not above that.

I'll give them a few days though.

[Tangrowth]

I GUESS I can wait to cast my vote. You all are boring. Not frisky enough.

It's Frisky Fucking Dingo, where's the frisky?

Am I not at all Frisky with my fun colours and my cool plan?

No worries, you are.

I shouldn't say EVERYONE is boring. G-Man's 8-ball shtick is pretty funny too. I don't know how frisky it is though.

I just hate Day 1's where everyone is twiddling their thumbs, only for a bunch of random or weird-ass votes to come in, but I don't frankly feel comfortable throwing my vote out there just yet, even in the name of zaniness, so I suppose I can understand why it's happening.

That said, part of me is definitely glad this thread isn't another Economics or Watchmen or Death Note. I just can't handle a game like that right now.

[Tangrowth]

Seriously. Fight Club Mafia's survivors are still meeting with counsellors weekly.

Oh, and

[Tangrowth]

And Rox, I want the new folks to stick around, so I understand your hesitation to vote for them, but I really wish they'd come in and at least say something, even if it's "I don't know what to post".

I don't want Llama's game to be disrespected, and I don't want to have a situation where we have 3+ complete nonparticipants a few cycles from now, and then we have a giant debate as to what to do with them. That's just annoying, IMO.

Thats what MdKills are for and Hosts need to learn to do it.

The last game I hosted (it was not here but on AW) I ModKilled a record 5 people for non participation. I find ModKilling to be quite liberating

I already have one replacement lined up which I am not afraid to use. I am good friends with Mac's Mom and have ben bugging him to post. He seems very cofused by the whole thing. If it comes to modkilling, I am not above that.

I'll give them a few days though.

You're good friends with someone's mom?

Sounds frisky.

[Epignosis]

I regularly have sexual intercourse with someone's mom.