Biblical Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Tangrowth]

So the moral of the story is that apparently Epi loves invisible vote manipulation.

[nijuukyugou]

G-man, I appreciated your ass jokes. I laughed so much in this game

[S~V~S]

Alex, when you assume etc & so forth.

[Ricochet]

Yeah MP when this game started I asked Epi what the punishment for missing votes is. He told me nothing unless I miss four. I initially considered missing 3 just because I could with no consequence. Then I was contemplating using missed votes to build cases on people and decided against it. That one missed vote was on purpose though.

Why didn't you save yourself, on the day of your lynch?

We didn't know Samsons vote counted.

But Samson's vote came in the last second, after Mordecai's.

In case you missed it, hats off again to your post-rezz posts. I was in awe how much of a creative fight you were able to pull, even with zero chances to be taken as anything else but a rezzed Heathen.

I started targeting Heathens after they started getting lynched, even though I realized it would leave to nothing significant, as long as Joshua was alive. I got stuck with my Ruth pick on the day Mordecai got lynched, then it was another Day and I got lynched, so that's why she had risen. My "last words" was just a sudden flavour story, considering I knew what would happen after my death - plus the kill Jacob part, which would have helped both me and the Heathens throughout the rest of the game.

[Tangrowth]

G-man, I appreciated your ass jokes. I laughed so much in this game

This. So much.

Everyone's in-character behavior was so funny.

Except Martha's, that was just annoying. :P Sorry, Boogs.

[Ricochet]

it would lead*

[timmer]

Oh, and I felt awful for the Mordecai lynch. I knew he was in danger that day and I really did get saddled with a meningitis case and missed the vote by five fucking minutes. i had EVERY intention of voting to save him, no matter how it would make us look.

Interesting to ponder how the game could have changed if I hadn't gotten waylaid! No Mordecai lynch = no leading right into a Ruth lynch, etc...

[Tangrowth]

Alex, when you assume etc & so forth.

Indeed, I can relate so much. Actually, it's a similar assumption that screwed me in Recruitment 1. That damn amulet.

In a way, I still can't believe you guys lost. In fact, all four of the last baddies were CRUCIAL lynches where you definitely could have kept the necessary momentum to win thereafter if those players hadn't been lynched.

The civilians really earned it at endgame though. I'm so glad they didn't listen to me and they lynched Esther instead of Pilate.

[Tangrowth]

Yeah MP when this game started I asked Epi what the punishment for missing votes is. He told me nothing unless I miss four. I initially considered missing 3 just because I could with no consequence. Then I was contemplating using missed votes to build cases on people and decided against it. That one missed vote was on purpose though.

Why didn't you save yourself, on the day of your lynch?

We didn't know Samsons vote counted.

But Samson's vote came in the last second, after Mordecai's.

In case you missed it, hats off again to your post-rezz posts. I was in awe how much of a creative fight you were able to pull, even with zero chances to be taken as anything else but a rezzed Heathen.

I started targeting Heathens after they started getting lynched, even though I realized it would leave to nothing significant, as long as Joshua was alive. I got stuck with my Ruth pick on the day Mordecai got lynched, then it was another Day and I got lynched, so that's why she had risen. My "last words" was just a sudden flavour story, considering I knew what would happen after my death - plus the kill Jacob part, which would have helped both me and the Heathens throughout the rest of the game.

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

[thellama73]

I'm glad nobody was around to see how pissed off I was after Ruth got rezzed (and Golden wanted to NOT lynch her!)

I was working so hard to finish off my marks, to have one suddenly pop back alive was infuriating.

[Epignosis]

So the moral of the story is that apparently Epi loves invisible vote manipulation.

Samson's vote was completely visible.

[thellama73]

I was also convinced Lot was Judas by endgame, since I could think of no other reason why the baddies would keep him alive (and he kept suggesting things like NOT LYNCHING BADDIE RUTH!)

[Tangrowth]

Interesting to ponder how the game could have changed

I know right? The what if game.

Many moments in this game, including as well if Uzziah had been lynched earlier whether it actually would have been helpful for you guys.

[Tangrowth]

So the moral of the story is that apparently Epi loves invisible vote manipulation.

Samson's vote was completely visible.

Well, yeah, but it was unexpected. :P

[Ricochet]

I don't know what else to say, at this point, I still haven't processed everything about the reveals. I still haven't even finished processing my spreadsheets, god damnit. Will do it later or tomorrow because holy crap 2am.

If you have any other remarks about my sock play, I welcome them. I'm sorry if I upset any civ during my last words, with Ruth getting rezzed and all. As I've said, I got stuck with the option due to no-Night being in effect. As for the last words, it had to be done. Heathens were getting lynched, I was only at halfway towards my win completion, so it was desperate times. I still don't think I would have won if so many double-deaths these past days wouldn't have happened. This game was pretty great baddie hunting all in all and I sucked at it, the more I tried to act civ-like. Mislynching is still my main issue in Mafia playing, regardless of alignment.

[Tangrowth]

I was also convinced Lot was Judas by endgame, since I could think of no other reason why the baddies would keep him alive (and he kept suggesting things like NOT LYNCHING BADDIE RUTH!)

I was kind of surprised a few of the Nights there at the end, but I just figured they left him alive for tinfoiling. It's easy to get the thread suspicious of a high contributor near endgame by specifically keeping them alive, especially if they're known for amazing behavior regardless of alignment (like Golden).

[timmer]

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

Ahh, computer lab... she was not only an outed baddie, thanks to, uhm, me... but she had actually replaced into the role AFTER it had been outed. It was a ballsy move, and yes, she was amazing there. I still sometimes haven't quite learned my lesson regarding info, but I'll get there one day!

[Tangrowth]

That's why I thought Pilate was bad; I saw that as a calculated baddie ploy at first and was convinced it was the case. But as time went by, it became increasingly clear that wasn't the case.

[Tangrowth]

I don't know what else to say, at this point, I still haven't processed everything about the reveals. I still haven't even finished processing my spreadsheets, god damnit. Will do it later or tomorrow because holy crap 2am.

If you have any other remarks about my sock play, I welcome them. I'm sorry if I upset any civ during my last words, with Ruth getting rezzed and all. As I've said, I got stuck with the option due to no-Night being in effect. As for the last words, it had to be done. Heathens were getting lynched, I was only at halfway towards my win completion, so it was desperate times. I still don't think I would have won if so many double-deaths these past days wouldn't have happened. This game was pretty great baddie hunting all in all and I sucked at it, the more I tried to act civ-like. Mislynching is still my main issue in Mafia playing, regardless of alignment.

I'm very intrigued to see your spreadsheets, as always.

[S~V~S]

Yeah MP when this game started I asked Epi what the punishment for missing votes is. He told me nothing unless I miss four. I initially considered missing 3 just because I could with no consequence. Then I was contemplating using missed votes to build cases on people and decided against it. That one missed vote was on purpose though.

Why didn't you save yourself, on the day of your lynch?

We didn't know Samsons vote counted.

But Samson's vote came in the last second, after Mordecai's.

In case you missed it, hats off again to your post-rezz posts. I was in awe how much of a creative fight you were able to pull, even with zero chances to be taken as anything else but a rezzed Heathen.

I started targeting Heathens after they started getting lynched, even though I realized it would leave to nothing significant, as long as Joshua was alive. I got stuck with my Ruth pick on the day Mordecai got lynched, then it was another Day and I got lynched, so that's why she had risen. My "last words" was just a sudden flavour story, considering I knew what would happen after my death - plus the kill Jacob part, which would have helped both me and the Heathens throughout the rest of the game.

Thank You

I have made a career of sorts of being a survivable outed baddie. And yeah, Samson was the last Mordi vote. We did not try hard to pull it out of the hat, or get frantic to pull in Deborah, since we thought it didn't count. Doh.

And to be on the record, the thing that got Paul looking at me Day One was totally something i would have done as a civ; that's why i did it. I drew attention to myself pointing out an anomaly. It backfired, but I would have called Paul out, maybe even harder, had I been a civ.

And TGG, you're always Rommel to me. He came in and he took charge like a boss.

Linki~ I was best in Dexter. I stayed alive for WEEKS.

[Tangrowth]

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

Ahh, computer lab... she was not only an outed baddie, thanks to, uhm, me... but she had actually replaced into the role AFTER it had been outed. It was a ballsy move, and yes, she was amazing there. I still sometimes haven't quite learned my lesson regarding info, but I'll get there one day!

Wasn't that game something else?

I was one of the three IRCers with LittleTiger and blindfaeth. I suspected that one of them had been recruited to the Botnet, but never both. They played me like a fiddle.

S~V~S played me real hard that game too. It's what started my distrust of her for YEARS. :P

[Ricochet]

I don't know what else to say, at this point, I still haven't processed everything about the reveals. I still haven't even finished processing my spreadsheets, god damnit. Will do it later or tomorrow because holy crap 2am.

If you have any other remarks about my sock play, I welcome them. I'm sorry if I upset any civ during my last words, with Ruth getting rezzed and all. As I've said, I got stuck with the option due to no-Night being in effect. As for the last words, it had to be done. Heathens were getting lynched, I was only at halfway towards my win completion, so it was desperate times. I still don't think I would have won if so many double-deaths these past days wouldn't have happened. This game was pretty great baddie hunting all in all and I sucked at it, the more I tried to act civ-like. Mislynching is still my main issue in Mafia playing, regardless of alignment.

I'm very intrigued to see your spreadsheets, as always.

Oh I have one that will knock your rainbow socks off.

[Marmot]

Go figure, I do jackshit in this game and still win.


Good game everyone. I guess dying on Day 1 isn't always the worst thing.

[S~V~S]

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

Ahh, computer lab... she was not only an outed baddie, thanks to, uhm, me... but she had actually replaced into the role AFTER it had been outed. It was a ballsy move, and yes, she was amazing there. I still sometimes haven't quite learned my lesson regarding info, but I'll get there one day!

Wasn't that game something else?

I was one of the three IRCers with LittleTiger and blindfaeth. I suspected that one of them had been recruited to the Botnet, but never both. They played me like a fiddle.

S~V~S played me real hard that game too. It's what started my distrust of her for YEARS. :P

That was the game I changed my avatar to Satan, I replaced Canuck, who had been outed by Timmer I think (it was his first game iirc, it was the Hey Man game) and put my location as "I am a baddie", and you guys kept trusting me, lol. Good Times

[Tangrowth]

Thank You

I have made a career of sorts of being a survivable outed baddie. And yeah, Samson was the last Mordi vote. We did not try hard to pull it out of the hat, or get frantic to pull in Deborah, since we thought it didn't count. Doh.

And to be on the record, the thing that got Paul looking at me Day One was totally something i would have done as a civ; that's why i did it. I drew attention to myself pointing out an anomaly. It backfired, but I would have called Paul out, maybe even harder, had I been a civ.

And TGG, you're always Rommel to me. He came in and he took charge like a boss.

Linki~ I was best in Dexter. I stayed alive for WEEKS.

I knew it was you, and I honestly couldn't figure out your alignment one way or the other, but 75% of the stuff I did as Paul in the early stage was to get everyone talking, and I didn't necessarily believe most of it. I was reaction-baiting big time. I was hoping to approach the game very differently and be more successful than my old civvie self of the past year or two that almost always sucked it up every game.

I missed Paul for the longest time after I died. I wanted to continue my behavior as one of my subsequent socks, but I just couldn't bring myself to do it, since it was too much work. It was really refreshing though to be able to play with a completely new identity.

[Ricochet]

Go figure, I do jackshit in this game and still win.


Good game everyone. I guess dying on Day 1 isn't always the worst thing.

Hello winged servant.

[Tangrowth]

Go figure, I do jackshit in this game and still win.


Good game everyone. I guess dying on Day 1 isn't always the worst thing.

Blessed be your faith in Paul. You were the sacrifice necessary to further the cause of reaction baiting.

[Marmot]

So the moral of the story is that apparently Epi loves invisible vote manipulation.

Samson's vote was completely visible.

Well, yeah, but it was unexpected. :P

I waited so many days to toss a last minute vote into the mix to mess with everyone.

I didn't expect that my vote was actually going to get a baddy lynched, and get my ol' buddy Rico lynched the next day.

[S~V~S]

Lol, I knew you were Stephen, Alex, cause all Stephen did was talk about Paul and his suspicions

[Tangrowth]

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

Ahh, computer lab... she was not only an outed baddie, thanks to, uhm, me... but she had actually replaced into the role AFTER it had been outed. It was a ballsy move, and yes, she was amazing there. I still sometimes haven't quite learned my lesson regarding info, but I'll get there one day!

Wasn't that game something else?

I was one of the three IRCers with LittleTiger and blindfaeth. I suspected that one of them had been recruited to the Botnet, but never both. They played me like a fiddle.

S~V~S played me real hard that game too. It's what started my distrust of her for YEARS. :P

That was the game I changed my avatar to Satan, I replaced Canuck, who had been outed by Timmer I think (it was his first game iirc, it was the Hey Man game) and put my location as "I am a baddie", and you guys kept trusting me, lol. Good Times

LOL, yes, the Hey Man game! Every time I listen to Ziggy Stardust, I think of that game, and it makes me think of timmer, since it was my first time playing with him.

[Marmot]

Go figure, I do jackshit in this game and still win.


Good game everyone. I guess dying on Day 1 isn't always the worst thing.

Hello winged servant.

I am the Angel of Death, nice to meet you.

Yeah, Day 2 was not good for me. I think I broke rules three different times that day.

llama knew I was Samson too.

[nutella]

FUN FACT: All the heathens names were Mordecai, Uzziah, Ruth, Deborah, Esther, Rahab. If you cut out all but the first letters, it spells MURDER.

omg

[Tangrowth]

Lol, I knew you were Stephen, Alex, cause all Stephen did was talk about Paul and his suspicions

Yeah, that was me missing the Paul identity too much.

I knew I wouldn't ever get to pull this off again, even in future sockpuppet games likely, since people will view those who claim they are new in sockpuppet games more skeptically. It was SO refreshing to not be held to the standards of "normal MP" behavior.

[Ricochet]

So the moral of the story is that apparently Epi loves invisible vote manipulation.

Samson's vote was completely visible.

Well, yeah, but it was unexpected. :P

I waited so many days to toss a last minute vote into the mix to mess with everyone.

I didn't expect that my vote was actually going to get a baddy lynched, and get my ol' buddy Rico lynched the next day.

Yeah, that was quite the backfire.

And all because I didn't suspect Mordecai as much as others did. He seriously hid well within his posts, people! What more to say of Esther and Rahab!!

[S~V~S]

Yes! I echo this. Your ability to convincingly fight out of a lynch after resurrection, S~V~S, was outstanding. It reminded me of Computer Lab where you lived so long as outed baddie. It was truly amazing.

Ahh, computer lab... she was not only an outed baddie, thanks to, uhm, me... but she had actually replaced into the role AFTER it had been outed. It was a ballsy move, and yes, she was amazing there. I still sometimes haven't quite learned my lesson regarding info, but I'll get there one day!

Wasn't that game something else?

I was one of the three IRCers with LittleTiger and blindfaeth. I suspected that one of them had been recruited to the Botnet, but never both. They played me like a fiddle.

S~V~S played me real hard that game too. It's what started my distrust of her for YEARS. :P

That was the game I changed my avatar to Satan, I replaced Canuck, who had been outed by Timmer I think (it was his first game iirc, it was the Hey Man game) and put my location as "I am a baddie", and you guys kept trusting me, lol. Good Times

LOL, yes, the Hey Man game! Every time I listen to Ziggy Stardust, I think of that game, and it makes me think of timmer, since it was my first time playing with him.

Yeah I felt bad for Timmer, first he outed Canuck and took all kinds of flack for that, then the Hey Man thing, lol. I do the same, I have Suffragette city on my shortlist 25, and it always makes me smile.

[nutella]

That whole sounding-like-another-site ploy was really clever, you had me fooled

[Tangrowth]

That whole sounding-like-another-site ploy was really clever, you had me fooled

I was hoping it would work. It was really difficult to maintain at times, that's for sure. I actually forced myself to post from my phone as much as possible in order to keep myself from posting long posts.

[Ricochet]

Why did TH get so lazy as Jonah/Solomon? He didn't even post proverbs much, except one time, I think.

[XthAtGAm3RGuYX]

And all because I didn't suspect Mordecai as much as others did. He seriously hid well within his posts, people! What more to say of Esther and Rahab!!

The thing I found most hilarious about that, is that you were lynched right after me. Even though you were one of the first people I tried to make a case on in the game. Read backs didnt help you guys there did it


And the rules really helped you guys out here. I am used to not really having any restrictions. Info dumping and what not being allowed as long as it's something you found out or deduced within means of the rules. Unfortunately here you cannot out another player, even when they are dead.

My plan was that, in the event that I was facing guaranteed death, before I died I was going to throw a topic grenade into the thread that Nicodemus is famine, and allude that civs lose if Horseman meet their win conditions. Ya know since we nightkilled him, and only heathens know that because of deadchecking. That way it would take some heat off of heathens and force you guys to look elsewhere for completely different reasons.

[Ricochet]

As always, in the interest of fully updating my spreadsheets, if any player that had a special ability can remember which players they targeted and on which nights and kindly state so in the thread, that'd be great.

[Tangrowth]

I know it's been said, but you really adapted to our culture so well, Mr. X. It was impressive. No way I would have figured out it was you if you hadn't used the slightly wrong shade of green for OT (and then later posted your .gifs). I very much look forward to playing other games with you.

[XthAtGAm3RGuYX]

As always, in the interest of fully updating my spreadsheets, if any player that had a special ability can remember which players they targeted and on which nights and kindly state so in the thread, that'd be great.

Well as it would so happen, I do remember who I targeted and why. Just let me give you a copy- wait mainute? It's not in my briefcase? How unfortunate. It looks like you'll never know

I'm telling you guys some stuff but I don't give out all of my secrets. Not even to my team. Rommel here has a mind like a tank.

[Tangrowth]

Oh, and I want to give another civilian cred shout out to Rachel (Dom). Very well played game. I actually found you as one of my most pronounced civilian reads after the first couple of cycles. You really played a good game here.

[Ricochet]

And all because I didn't suspect Mordecai as much as others did. He seriously hid well within his posts, people! What more to say of Esther and Rahab!!

The thing I found most hilarious about that, is that you were lynched right after me. Even though you were one of the first people I tried to make a case on in the game. Read backs didnt help you guys there did it


And the rules really helped you guys out here. I am used to not really having any restrictions. Info dumping and what not being allowed as long as it's something you found out or deduced within means of the rules. Unfortunately here you cannot out another player, even when they are dead.

My plan was that, in the event that I was facing guaranteed death, before I died I was going to throw a topic grenade into the thread that Nicodemus is famine, and allude that civs lose if Horseman meet their win conditions. Ya know since we nightkilled him, and only heathens know that because of deadchecking. That way it would take some heat off of heathens and force you guys to look elsewhere for completely different reasons.

You wouldn't have been allowed to info dump on Nicodemus being Famine, though. (Sorry about these rules being applied, I guess)

But, as others have already said, you have adapted well. I started thinking about your identity when you got testy during rebuttals, tbh, then the gifs definitely sealed it (but you were already dead by then, so not much of a guess anymore).

[Epignosis]

Isn't anyone interested in how ties work?

[Ricochet]

As always, in the interest of fully updating my spreadsheets, if any player that had a special ability can remember which players they targeted and on which nights and kindly state so in the thread, that'd be great.

Well as it would so happen, I do remember who I targeted and why. Just let me give you a copy- wait mainute? It's not in my briefcase? How unfortunate. It looks like you'll never know

I'm telling you guys some stuff but I don't give out all of my secrets. Not even to my team. Rommel here has a mind like a tank.

I'm asking for simple stats, not tactics reveal.

It's because I'm obsessed with list making.

Isn't anyone interested in how ties work?

I'm just interested in why Heathens got on the wrong side of it so many times.

[Tangrowth]

I am very curious as to what all of the other players have to say and I look forward to seeing your spreadsheet, Rico.

I want to say that, now that there are no active games running, anyone here who hasn't signed up for Dom's awesome game REALLY should consider doing so. He needs 5 more players at the moment. It's going to be amazing.

Once it gets started, another full game and a speed game will go into sign-ups, and thereafter we can start running the shiny new games from the upcoming queue.

[S~V~S]

Isn't anyone interested in how ties work?

I am. I coulda been a contender, I tell ya.

[G-Man]

G-man, I appreciated your ass jokes. I laughed so much in this game

You're quite welcome. How ironic that the guy making LOT jokes and the guy making ASS jokes had BTSC?

I'm amazed that I lived for as long as I did. Golden (Lot) and I gained BTSC the first night and I was worried his sudden reversal on me would look obvious or shifty. Golden's vouching for me also probably should have been a giveaway to the baddies as to who we were.

At first my technicolor lists were fun. I suck at reading people so I really far too much on vote analysis. I think I started doing my Technicolor Vote lists after seeing MP's rainbow reads in Econ Mafia. I was curious if anyone thought I was MP because of that. But yeah, those technicolor lists stopped being fun around the time I died.

Epi told us that we could retain BTSC even though I was dead, so I kept composing the technicolor lists and PM'ed them to Golden's sock account. I was also keeping abreast of the game and theorizing with Golden in our chat room. We didn't always see eye to eye. At the end, I was paranoid that Bathsheba was Judas because that sock got active again right around the time Judas killed me.

Also, I totally had four of the five Heathens pegged at various points. I caught Ruth in what I thought was a lie when she claimed she had been silenced. Then my technicolor lists exposed Mordecai, Deborah, and Esther. I was going nuts in the chat with Golden, all but screaming at you guys to go after Deborah. Glad you guys did. I didn't provide Golden with much input at all for the final day because I wanted the civvies to win or lose without outside help.

So proud of you guys! Way to win it!

I actually intended to be like a lot of you guys and just slack off and post as little as necessary. But then I got BTSC with Golden and I felt obligated to commit as much effort as possible. I put in a full-game effort despite only being alive for 2/3 of the game. Ironic that Golden was working so hard with me in this game and so hard against me in Econ. Good thing he didn't know I was his BTSC partner. That could have gotten awkward.

I also had a lot of fun writing the "Dear Living Players" posts. I did something like that when I died during The Office Mafia on Lostpedia. It was an alternate storyline where all the dead players were still working I think. I laughed good and hard when some of you speculated that my "DLP" posts actually meant something. Since I was still working BTSC with Golden, I figured I ought to contribute some cheeky humor in the game thread too.

Serious question- did anyone suspect I was Balaam at any point? I don't know if any of the LP/TP'ers of old remembered me or my play style. Heck, I don't even know if it was my old style.

[G-Man]

Isn't anyone interested in how ties work?

I am. I coulda been a contender, I tell ya.

Instead of a bum, which is what you are? :P