Voting Scotty for now, as we're kinda close to the deadline and idk if I'll be able to post again.
He's not more suspicious to me than the other players (Mac, NSawyer) that have been asked questions they haven't answered but he's certainly more suspicious than me (from my perspective, at least) and more suspicious than Quin.
I'm reading through. I have to say I'm leaning on agreeing with Epi on Scotty. Some of his posts feel to me like how I would play when mafia, by trying to look helpful in his attempt to analyse the host's post, and by looking like he's doing some serious hunting, while it doesn't feel genuine to me.
I have two reservations:
1. the part where he randomly chooses a low poster. That's poor hunting, and I think Scotty is smarter than that. 2. I also understand where he's coming from, with his suspicion of the marmot. He tends to lay low and be more fluffy when he's bad.
So
Elohcin wrote:Referring to the Quin/llama/svs stuff....I think any of the three could be bad atm. BUt if one of them is bad, I think the other two are cleared. If Quin is bad, I don't think llama or SVS would go after their teammate so soon. If llama or svs is bad, I don't think the other would be so obviously in agreement with the other about the alignment of another.
Llama bussed Mac, his baddie teammate, on day 1 of the still-ongoing Game of Champions.
okay. I'm not sure how much that could be discussed since the game is still going. Was Mac portraying any kind of odd behavior that would give llama the reason to do so?
Banners are cool, but a pain to scroll through so...
I've won a lot of games. I've hosted some games. The end.
My vote will most likely go to Scotty today. There are other people I think could possibly be bad (that I've mentioned) but what Epi caught carries more weight atm. I am going to put my vote there now in case I get caught up doing other things and forget to come back. But I will try to do so b/c I would love to hear Scotty's explanation.
Banners are cool, but a pain to scroll through so...
I've won a lot of games. I've hosted some games. The end.
I won't be able to catch up on the thread until tonight, so I randomized Sawyer. I hate randomizing, but I haven't read since page 3 and literally have no suspicions yet.
If he lied about flipping a coin (and I can't imagine a scenario in which he was being genuine), that can only mean he specifically voted for JackofHearts and did so intentionally. One must judge the purpose behind singling out JoH in this manner.
Oh, I only have a half hour to finalize my vote don't I? I'm moving it to NotSawyer. I thought his waffle-ironing on Quin was the most suspicious thing I've seen so far.
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
Scotty, if you're around, now is the time to speak.
I have to say Wilgy is starting to worry me too. While his first "Epi is bad" comment didn't bother me at all, his joking around and zero meaningful contribution, does bother me.
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Wilgy's vote is an enigma of science. Philosophers are known to throw their tomes across the auditorium in a fit of frustration after failing to solve its mystery.
insertnamehere wrote: ↑Wed Jun 28, 2017 11:50 pm
WTF was up with Wilgy's entire deal?
How well the players know one another's personalities and play-styles.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Seems like you're both saying you don't understand why Mac is voting for me AND you think he is voting me cause I'm suspicious because of culture clash/lack of skill/experience.
Which is it?
I'm not sure how you got that. I asked him for something substantial as opposed to just not liking the "cut of (your) jib." Do people on this site intentionally misinterpret what I say no matter how clear and direct I am?
FZ. wrote:I'm reading through. I have to say I'm leaning on agreeing with Epi on Scotty. Some of his posts feel to me like how I would play when mafia, by trying to look helpful in his attempt to analyse the host's post, and by looking like he's doing some serious hunting, while it doesn't feel genuine to me.
I have two reservations:
1. the part where he randomly chooses a low poster. That's poor hunting, and I think Scotty is smarter than that. 2. I also understand where he's coming from, with his suspicion of the marmot. He tends to lay low and be more fluffy when he's bad.
So
You can expect me to lay low somewhat in this game, I'm a bit busier these days.
Linki: @G-Man, yes I know. Just giving you a hard time.
thellama73 wrote:I don't think I'v played with Jack of Hearts before, but I'm finding him annoying. He apologized for not being "entertaining" enough. Entertainment is not the goal of the game, boyo. Finding baddies is. Take the snark down a notch, why don't you, and answer me this:
Who are looking at voting today and why?
I know this post was accidentally aimed at me but I'll answer anyway.
We were in Unfortunate Events together but you got lynched on Day 1.
If I had a day kill that I had to use this second, I'd shoot Mac. Three seconds in and he's sure I'm scum? Never played with him before so his certainty is either a bluff or a lie (depending on his alignment and if he's bad, how many scum he thinks exist outside his group). Plenty of townies are jokingly certain of scum on Day 1 but with two posts about it, I get the impression he isn't joking. Some townies can act really certain on Day 1 when they actually just have a hunch. Don't know Mac's meta to know if he plays that type of a townie game or if he's just looking for a mislynch or to look like he's contributing.
I'm not actually planning on voting for Mac, though. I'm planning on voting for whoever pings me enough that I want to lead a lynch or my top suspect that is getting enough votes to make them lynchable. (I don't vote third party very often cause I want my vote to matter.) I don't know who that is, yet, but I'll let you know.
Why you seem so bad then?
I don't know, Mac.
Why don't you tell me why you think I'm bad? Please be more detailed than your post about the cut of my jib.
Can you tell me more about yourself? How often do you catch scum on Day 1? How often do you act more sure of alignments than you really are? Whats your favorite role? You a site native or migrant mafia player? How long have you been playing?
I'm comfortable with Scotty voting for me early. Doesn't mean he's town but I've played enough with Scotty to kinda get his play style and I think is vote on me matches his style. I don't know you, though.
Am I McStrangepost? What's strange about which post?
I have a very very good day 1 scum catchy record actually. I just never ever convince people to follow me.
I always act with surety because I enjoy the melodrama.
My favourite role is insane indy role cop.
I am from RYM. I have been playing forums Mafia for 6 years.
Yes you are. Your posts make me scrunch my nose up. This usually tends to be when one is a bad.
Marmot wrote:I'm voting Scotty for this atrocity of a post.
Now you're going to get Eloh's vote.
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.