U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[colonialbob]

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

[Long Con]

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

[Turnip Head]

Okay so if I'm reading this right, it sounds like our vanishees were abducted by a clumsy gang of nincompoops who got nothing accomplished and didn't even have all that much sex. Still a better love story than twilight.

[juliets]

I'm sure sig is not mafia. dunya was also sure he was not mafia.

Why?

It's hard to explain c-bob. We started out suspicious of each other and then the more we shared about how we felt about players in the game the more we saw we were thinking alike. It just became obvious to me the more we talked and shared about ourselves - and we had nothing else to do but talk to each other - that sig was on the level. I feel sure about my read of him.

[colonialbob]

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

As in, last Wednesday I left the city where I live and traveled to another city, remained there until yesterday, whereupon I traveled back to my city of residence. So I was busy doing stuff instead of just sitting on my couch.

I believe dunya is vanished yes. Hopefully she will return.

[colonialbob]

I'm sure sig is not mafia. dunya was also sure he was not mafia.

Why?

It's hard to explain c-bob. We started out suspicious of each other and then the more we shared about how we felt about players in the game the more we saw we were thinking alike. It just became obvious to me the more we talked and shared about ourselves - and we had nothing else to do but talk to each other - that sig was on the level. I feel sure about my read of him.

Ok, so it's "just" a read. That's what I wanted to know.

Who are you and what do you do?

[juliets]

I'm sure sig is not mafia. dunya was also sure he was not mafia.

Why?

It's hard to explain c-bob. We started out suspicious of each other and then the more we shared about how we felt about players in the game the more we saw we were thinking alike. It just became obvious to me the more we talked and shared about ourselves - and we had nothing else to do but talk to each other - that sig was on the level. I feel sure about my read of him.

Ok, so it's "just" a read. That's what I wanted to know.

Who are you and what do you do?

I'm a 19th century figure who solves murders (not Sherlock Holmes). That's why Orange told me to prove myself by solving the Marmot murder.

[colonialbob]

I'm sure sig is not mafia. dunya was also sure he was not mafia.

Why?

It's hard to explain c-bob. We started out suspicious of each other and then the more we shared about how we felt about players in the game the more we saw we were thinking alike. It just became obvious to me the more we talked and shared about ourselves - and we had nothing else to do but talk to each other - that sig was on the level. I feel sure about my read of him.

Ok, so it's "just" a read. That's what I wanted to know.

Who are you and what do you do?

I'm a 19th century figure who solves murders (not Sherlock Holmes). That's why Orange told me to prove myself by solving the Marmot murder.

Interesting, interesting.

Who should we lynch?

[juliets]

LC, this is not the first time you've indicated you are not reading the game (underlined below) and I find it highly suspicious. In fact, even though you've been very careful I have a mafia read on you and specifically, I think you are in Al-Pieda.

Who do you see as being Al-Pieda at this point?

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

[juliets]

I'm sure sig is not mafia. dunya was also sure he was not mafia.

Why?

It's hard to explain c-bob. We started out suspicious of each other and then the more we shared about how we felt about players in the game the more we saw we were thinking alike. It just became obvious to me the more we talked and shared about ourselves - and we had nothing else to do but talk to each other - that sig was on the level. I feel sure about my read of him.

Ok, so it's "just" a read. That's what I wanted to know.

Who are you and what do you do?

I'm a 19th century figure who solves murders (not Sherlock Holmes). That's why Orange told me to prove myself by solving the Marmot murder.

Interesting, interesting.

Who should we lynch?

I think Long Con (see above) or there's someone else I suspect of being the vanisher (case to follow).

[colonialbob]

I just realized it's probably "al-PIEda," like the dessert, not "al-pi-e-da" like you'd pronounce it in Spanish.

[juliets]

Turnip Head, could you talk to me about these posts?

First starting here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 78#p452378 post number 5043 through 5050. And then this post http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 17#p452817 post #5114.

It sure looks like from these posts that you are the vanisher. All three of us, me, sig and dunya believe that you are he, "the dark lord" as he is called. Please tell me why we should change our suspicion if indeed we should.

[juliets]

Also regarding my post above, dunya vanished after this exchange between she and Turnip ^.

[Chuck]

[Turnip Head]

Turnip Head, could you talk to me about these posts?

First starting here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 78#p452378 post number 5043 through 5050. And then this post http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 17#p452817 post #5114.

It sure looks like from these posts that you are the vanisher. All three of us, me, sig and dunya believe that you are he, "the dark lord" as he is called. Please tell me why we should change our suspicion if indeed we should.

You forgot about post #5034.

[juliets]

Turnip Head, could you talk to me about these posts?

First starting here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 78#p452378 post number 5043 through 5050. And then this post http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 17#p452817 post #5114.

It sure looks like from these posts that you are the vanisher. All three of us, me, sig and dunya believe that you are he, "the dark lord" as he is called. Please tell me why we should change our suspicion if indeed we should.

You forgot about post #5034.

That is something to consider. If not you who do you think it is?

[Long Con]

LC, this is not the first time you've indicated you are not reading the game (underlined below) and I find it highly suspicious. In fact, even though you've been very careful I have a mafia read on you and specifically, I think you are in Al-Pieda.

Who do you see as being Al-Pieda at this point?

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

Well, I'm not in Al-Pieda. I'm just forgetful, it's NAI for me. Colin, motel, Lunalee. These are the people I think we should be focused on, and my vote will likely go to one of them.

[Turnip Head]

Turnip Head, could you talk to me about these posts?

First starting here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 78#p452378 post number 5043 through 5050. And then this post http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 17#p452817 post #5114.

It sure looks like from these posts that you are the vanisher. All three of us, me, sig and dunya believe that you are he, "the dark lord" as he is called. Please tell me why we should change our suspicion if indeed we should.

You forgot about post #5034.

That is something to consider. If not you who do you think it is?

I really have no clue juliets. I mean... who calls themselves "the dark lord"? Is it supposed to be ironic or could he not come up with anything better, or is his role even darker than has been hinted at? And the other kidnapper calls himself King Kong? Who are these clowns?

My kidnapper role would be named CreepySexyRyanGosling and we would have an amazing time together.

[Turnip Head]

I want to lunch sloonei. His gimmick is wearing thin and I think he's coasting

[Dragon D. Luffy]

im just gonna hope that we are in dawn i guess

cave daddy told me that sig had figured out who he was. he mentioned that he'd made a deal with sig that in exchange for sig keeping his identity a secret and pushing disappearer suspicion away from him if he was released somehow that he'd let sig choose who was kidnapped next (me), that seemed like a weird contradictory deal but I just kinda ignored it. later on he revealed that aig had revealed his alignment to him and that the deal was actually that sig would agree to have his team not kill zeph and to draw kidnapper-being suspicion away from zeph, in exchange for zeph trying to target civs or..... something... I didn't really understand all the details, but if zeph was telling the truth they had a basic mafia-rogue partnership going on, and I don't know if he told me everything. he said he was telling me all this because he didn't think sig was going to be out any time soon butin retrospect I think it also had something to do with the fact that he was facing pressure at the time, though that's mostly conjecture, i thought King Kong was turnip head.

idk if this is old news or not, and it's possible zeph lied for some personal gain loosely relating to his wincon, it just seems like it might be important data point moving forward.

When was this?

I also had btsc with Sig, and he told me the kidnapper was threatening him with telling people he was bad if he made a move against him. This was back in day 2.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

im just gonna hope that we are in dawn i guess

cave daddy told me that sig had figured out who he was. he mentioned that he'd made a deal with sig that in exchange for sig keeping his identity a secret and pushing disappearer suspicion away from him if he was released somehow that he'd let sig choose who was kidnapped next (me), that seemed like a weird contradictory deal but I just kinda ignored it. later on he revealed that aig had revealed his alignment to him and that the deal was actually that sig would agree to have his team not kill zeph and to draw kidnapper-being suspicion away from zeph, in exchange for zeph trying to target civs or..... something... I didn't really understand all the details, but if zeph was telling the truth they had a basic mafia-rogue partnership going on, and I don't know if he told me everything. he said he was telling me all this because he didn't think sig was going to be out any time soon butin retrospect I think it also had something to do with the fact that he was facing pressure at the time, though that's mostly conjecture, i thought King Kong was turnip head.

idk if this is old news or not, and it's possible zeph lied for some personal gain loosely relating to his wincon, it just seems like it might be important data point moving forward.

I'm not saying I don't believe you, but how do you think sig would have been able to figure out that Sexsquatch was Zephyrus?

Aren't them from the same home forum?

[juliets]

I want to lunch sloonei. His gimmick is wearing thin and I think he's coasting

I'm reading sloonei as civ. I believe he is experiencing burnout which is what dunya said earlier in the game.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Oh juliets already said it. Good.

[juliets]

LC, this is not the first time you've indicated you are not reading the game (underlined below) and I find it highly suspicious. In fact, even though you've been very careful I have a mafia read on you and specifically, I think you are in Al-Pieda.

Who do you see as being Al-Pieda at this point?

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

Well, I'm not in Al-Pieda. I'm just forgetful, it's NAI for me. Colin, motel, Lunalee. These are the people I think we should be focused on, and my vote will likely go to one of them.

What is the case on Luna? And I've seen a lot of people mention Colin but I never saw a case on him. Did I miss it?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Turnip Head, could you talk to me about these posts?

First starting here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 78#p452378 post number 5043 through 5050. And then this post http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 17#p452817 post #5114.

It sure looks like from these posts that you are the vanisher. All three of us, me, sig and dunya believe that you are he, "the dark lord" as he is called. Please tell me why we should change our suspicion if indeed we should.

How is Turnip the vanisher when we know it was Zeph?

[juliets]

civs, one thing all three of us noticed from the Lost Souls chatzy is there wasn't a lot of conversation last day phase. I feel it's imperative for the civs to discuss what they are seeing, even if the reads are tone reads. The mafia likes it when we are quiet.

Also, can anyone remember who voted for Lap and who voted for Zeph in the last poll? Mac forgot to capture the poll so we need to try and recreate it if possible.

linki DDL: remember there are two vanishers - one was the sex cave and one is the chatzy of lost souls. dunya and sig are still stuck in the chatzy of lost souls. Zeph was the sex cave vanisher.

[colonialbob]

Why Colin? I've consistently read him as civ.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Hmm I hadnt noticed that myself.

[Turnip Head]

It's hard to talk a lot when half the players haven't shown up much. That's not really a rag on anyone, I'm just saying. Also our stump is just sorta sitting in the ground all by himself.

[dunya]

[juliets]

It's hard to talk a lot when half the players haven't shown up much. That's not really a rag on anyone, I'm just saying. Also our stump is just sorta sitting in the ground all by himself.

Yes, it is hard when there are so many who are virtually inactive. I think Charlie indicated he's been busy but hopefully his time frees up now.

linki: hi dunya! hope the ghouls are keeping you entertained

[dunya]

[Turnip Head]

I hear dunyas voice but all I see is cats. *taps on the display glass* hello??

[juliets]

[ColinIsCool]

I’d need to look more but I have an okay gut feeling about the Turnip Head lynch. I was pegging him as teammate compatible with Eloh possibly but his tone does seem ... distanced. Kind of like people said with Zephyrus sort of dancing around the thread at times.

[ColinIsCool]

LC, this is not the first time you've indicated you are not reading the game (underlined below) and I find it highly suspicious. In fact, even though you've been very careful I have a mafia read on you and specifically, I think you are in Al-Pieda.

Who do you see as being Al-Pieda at this point?

i don't think he even offered the concept of a deal to cbob

Not really. Like he mentioned dealmaking was a thing he did but he never got very specific. Although I also didn't respond that strongly because i was also out of town.

"out of town"?

Also, this is such a fresh infusion into the game. I'm pretty happy to see all of you out... is dunya the only vanished one now? Or did dunya die...? I think she's vanished.

Well, I'm not in Al-Pieda. I'm just forgetful, it's NAI for me. Colin, motel, Lunalee. These are the people I think we should be focused on, and my vote will likely go to one of them.

What is the case on Luna? And I've seen a lot of people mention Colin but I never saw a case on him. Did I miss it?

Dunya has made a couple on me, but she may have also walked them back after admitting to tunneling.

[juliets]

Ok thanks Colin. Also, who did you vote for yesterday?

[ColinIsCool]

I believe I switched from Zephyrus to Lap.

[ColinIsCool]

I dunno, Zephyrus has an unfortunate read on me but he feels pretty earnest... lap on the other hand is a lot harder for me to read, but Charlie’s casing was pretty solid. I’m gonna park myself there for now but keep an eye on what’s going on

Yeah.

[Turnip Head]

I'm pretty sure that even a tomagatchi with the battery taken out could connect enough dots to put me on Elo's team but it still doesn't make it true. In that instance I'm just a wayward civ who thought he was defending a friend.

[Turnip Head]

Oh and don't compare what I'm doing to what I accused Zeph of doing. We may both be dancing but I've got swag in my steps

[Kylemii]

im just gonna hope that we are in dawn i guess

cave daddy told me that sig had figured out who he was. he mentioned that he'd made a deal with sig that in exchange for sig keeping his identity a secret and pushing disappearer suspicion away from him if he was released somehow that he'd let sig choose who was kidnapped next (me), that seemed like a weird contradictory deal but I just kinda ignored it. later on he revealed that aig had revealed his alignment to him and that the deal was actually that sig would agree to have his team not kill zeph and to draw kidnapper-being suspicion away from zeph, in exchange for zeph trying to target civs or..... something... I didn't really understand all the details, but if zeph was telling the truth they had a basic mafia-rogue partnership going on, and I don't know if he told me everything. he said he was telling me all this because he didn't think sig was going to be out any time soon butin retrospect I think it also had something to do with the fact that he was facing pressure at the time, though that's mostly conjecture, i thought King Kong was turnip head.

idk if this is old news or not, and it's possible zeph lied for some personal gain loosely relating to his wincon, it just seems like it might be important data point moving forward.

When was this?

I also had btsc with Sig, and he told me the kidnapper was threatening him with telling people he was bad if he made a move against him. This was back in day 2.

I recounted events spanning my entire week in the sex cave, so you're gonna have to be more specific.

attempted deal making took place during the first and second day of my sexy cave experience, cbob arrived on the third day, King Kong began talking about his deal with sig in more specifics sometime after cbob showed up, but I'd been trying to ask him about it from the beginning alongside trying to figure out his identity and make him fall in love with me.

how did you have btsc with sig on day 2?

[Kylemii]

[mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention] did you mean night 2?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I haven't mentioned that until now, but I get btsc with people I'm about to rescue.

The idea is that I'm supposed to use it to decide if they are civ or bad. Because I only have to rescue civs.

Actually I only mentioned it now because I didn't notice there were two kidnappers and I didn't want to give this information to the kidnapper before they died. So I kind of messed this up now.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

No Day 2.

[Turnip Head]

I just now realized how completely alone I've been this game. Everyone's having sexy btsc and none for turbup

[Long Con]

I forgot also: insertnamehere doesn't have a lot of redeeming posts, and JJJ made a pretty solid meta-comparison which I commented on here:

Spoiler: show

Now that you mention it, Colin, insertnamehere doesn't look that great. Pretty low poster, and I guess his role is maybe Tommy Wiseau? JJJ The Civ made a pertinent point on INH that kind of forms my main read on him now:

Apart from merely being quiet, I've a reason for concern regarding INH.

U-Pick Vol 1 (INH is unknown)

Dunya being annoyed by Golden is reminding me of my treatment of Golden waaaay back in Red vs. Blue, which might've been the last game I played with him. Lots of "stop trying to get the thread to strictly buy into certain viewpoints," followed by "that's not what I'm doing, you obviously don't know my meta." After a bunch of non-stop thread sniping and bickering, it turns out we were potential civvie BTSC partners. (Weeeell, that wasn't the whole story. He was actually an undercover LMS indie. That game really fucked me over.)

Nevertheless, I'm currently reading both Dunya and Golden as town.

Assassination Classroom (INH is mafia)

Who is we lynchin INH?

Dunno. I utterly suck at early-game read divination, so I plan on following people I think seem like gen-u-ine townies. I've been getting good vibes from you, JJJ, and Dys. Someone not checking their role PM before posting would draw my ire if it was anyone other than Scotty.

Evil INH has shown a willingness to hand out easy civilian reads to highly active players in the earliest stages -- something I don't recall seeing much of from his civilian self.

Eh, it varies from game to game. Certain things pique my townie-meter, and certain things don't. As you said, I didn't townread anyone early on in the GOC. However, I was more or less present for the entirety of that game, while I was AWOL for a large chunk of Ass Class, and the townreads were a way of deflecting possible attention.

TBH, I feel like the inability to really townread people is a weakness of my civ game, so I'm trying to shake things up a little.

In the spirit of that, here are some people who seem alright to me:
Wolbre
Nutella
Turnip
Daisy

INH has been AWOL for a large chunk of this game, so those townreads are a way of deflecting possible attention.

New rainbow:

Long Con
Epignosis (Charlie Blackmon)
dunya
Turnip Head
colonialbob
Kites
lapluie
Sloonei
speedchuck
Dragon D. Luffy
ColinIsCool
motel room
Scotty
Lunalee
insertnamehere
Zephyrus

Colin I have been back and forth on, sometimes he seems very Civ, and other times he doesn't. It raised my eyebrow a bit when Daisy was interrogating him about what he said about roles and alignments, and instead of answering her questions, he deflected to me "Long Con believed it too!" or something. Zephyrus was pretty adamant that Colin was bad as well, and made some posts that you should read while you're considering Colin. Sex Cryptid or not, I think he was genuinely baddie hunting.

The Lunalee suspicion is mostly gut I guess. I didn't like the results of her eager nova evaluation, because all it did was point at people who were Civ, or at least people who were not Al-Pieda. (Oh shit you're right... I've been saying Al Pee-ay-da in my mind and just realized it's about Pie and rhyming)

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I'm not lynching Colin until we have gotten rid of soma Al Pieda people.

[Long Con]

You believe he's the last ISIS?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I believe he is not al pieda.