U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[sig]

Omar was on day 1879 of the much anticipated Sonemic build. Beta 46 has been taking forever and he was very frustrated. Cornering a small innocent creature he decided to take his frustrations out on it. He kicked and stomped on the poor thing until it stopped moving. Lord knows why he decided to do it in the middle of the town though. For repercussions there would surely be.

ColinIsCool has been killed.

He was

Spoiler: show

Fergus, Son of Shrek, Civilian. You are an adorable baby ogre. If someone kills you they will be brutally murdered for justice.

Sloonei has been hanged by the townsfolk for an unspeakable crime.

He was

Spoiler: show

Sharifi, Al-Pieda. Each night you can target an RYMer and share a BTSC with them.

It is now day 7, and on we go.

Last time I buy the burnout story.

[sig]

7 left

6 after indy is removed.

We weren't told that we were at lylo, which Mac said we would be therefore we have two lynches, I'd suggest not tieing it today.

[mention]colonialbob[/mention] Will you be willing to say who you targeted?

[sig]

I'll dig into Sloonie later in the phase and see if anything pops up, but I doubt it will.

I'd suggest we look into TH just because he's playing the same type of game Sloonie is and it makes me wary.

In theory the last mafia member could be inactive, but that would just leave motel room and I don't know if I want to risk that.

[colonialbob]

7 left

6 after indy is removed.

We weren't told that we were at lylo, which Mac said we would be therefore we have two lynches, I'd suggest not tieing it today.

colonialbob Will you be willing to say who you targeted?

I didn't target anyone. Would've probably been Colin if I had.

[colonialbob]

Also I think hopefully voting Sloonei the other day (yesterday?) gives me a little non-Pie cred.

Can we please lynch TH now?

[Kylemii]

nice!!! so there's just two left right? how is The Math doing?

[Turnip Head]

Omar was on day 1879 of the much anticipated Sonemic build. Beta 46 has been taking forever and he was very frustrated. Cornering a small innocent creature he decided to take his frustrations out on it. He kicked and stomped on the poor thing until it stopped moving. Lord knows why he decided to do it in the middle of the town though. For repercussions there would surely be.

ColinIsCool has been killed.

He was

Spoiler: show

Fergus, Son of Shrek, Civilian. You are an adorable baby ogre. If someone kills you they will be brutally murdered for justice.

Sloonei has been hanged by the townsfolk for an unspeakable crime.

He was

Spoiler: show

Sharifi, Al-Pieda. Each night you can target an RYMer and share a BTSC with them.

It is now day 7, and on we go.

My work here is done. Good luck guys, this has been a blast.

<-- Colin our fallin hero

[sig]

nice!!! so there's just two left right? how is The Math doing?

I can't see more then 2 if we're lucky 1. If there were 3 we would be in lylo I believe.

[sig]

[mention]juliets[/mention] Thoughts?

[Kylemii]

wait does shrek get a baby in one of the movies? is that a thing that happens

[sig]

wait does shrek get a baby in one of the movies? is that a thing that happens

Three babies yes.

[Turnip Head]

I'd suggest we look into TH just because he's playing the same type of game Sloonie is and it makes me wary.

It's pretty reductive to say I'm playing the same type of game as Sloonei. I'm used to you digging deeper and this feels like a very surface level read of my game. I don't feel like my playstyle has much in common with Sloonei's... like, at all.

[sig]

I'd suggest we look into TH just because he's playing the same type of game Sloonie is and it makes me wary.

It's pretty reductive to say I'm playing the same type of game as Sloonei. I'm used to you digging deeper and this feels like a very surface level read of my game. I don't feel like my playstyle has much in common with Sloonei's... like, at all.

I mean the general fluffyness type thing.

[Kylemii]

wait does shrek get a baby in one of the movies? is that a thing that happens

Three babies yes.

what

[Turnip Head]

I'd suggest we look into TH just because he's playing the same type of game Sloonie is and it makes me wary.

It's pretty reductive to say I'm playing the same type of game as Sloonei. I'm used to you digging deeper and this feels like a very surface level read of my game. I don't feel like my playstyle has much in common with Sloonei's... like, at all.

I mean the general fluffyness type thing.

That's my point sig. "General fluffyness" is NAI. My fluff is different than Sloonei's fluff or anybody else's. Again, I call it reductive. Are we lynching people for "general fluffyness" now? Is that the kind of world we want our children to inherit?

[Kylemii]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

[Turnip Head]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

Just a snake for me thanks

[Kylemii]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

Just a snake for me thanks

i sent you a snake game and you didn't even play it :/

[Turnip Head]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

Just a snake for me thanks

i sent you a snake game and you didn't even play it :/

I know dude I was out of town and didn't have time: (

[nutella]

Hooooo buddy grandma sloon was fuckin bad

[Kylemii]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

Just a snake for me thanks

i sent you a snake game and you didn't even play it :/

I know dude I was out of town and didn't have time: (

animorphs is such a terrible game but the solution to the first puzzle is to transform into a snake and you missed out on it. it was gonna be such a good prank...

[Kylemii]

operation trustfall

reasons to read each player as civ....

colonialbob: has a role which i think balance-wise would be extremely dangerous in mafia hands, mafia cbob letting his vote add role be made public would be revealing his team's ace in the hole, for no real strategic gain.

Dragon D. Luffy: has claimed indie, has a role that seemed counter to LC's role, his role being on the same team as LC's role would make for bizarre and unlikely synergy

juliets: kidnapped by LC, also a strong component of his lynch after becoming free, which makes her being a recruit unlikely

Kylemii: that's me

motel room: voted for long con.... if mafia probably wouldn't be so absent?

sig: also kidnapped by LC, and a strong component of his lynch

Turnip Head: sloonei threw a stick at him on day 6, LC threw a pinecone at him on day 4. he's been very relaxed and casual throughout most of the game.

motel was the hardest trustfall by far. turnip's there in second place, his reasons required a little more digging and don't feel as strong. 3rd place would be I guess cbob.

[wolbre04]

who would like to join me in an........... Operation Trustfall?

Just a snake for me thanks

i sent you a snake game and you didn't even play it :/

I know dude I was out of town and didn't have time: (

animorphs is such a terrible game but the solution to the first puzzle is to transform into a snake and you missed out on it. it was gonna be such a good prank...

play the boobquest instead tbh

[Kylemii]

these are motel's only on topic posts

Spoiler: show

I think dunya looked worse at the start with her vs jjj, her reactions were just like jay said. When i read through it first, it being the first significant blow up, i thought some of the names that popped up to say so and so is civ felt likr where the dodgy non drinkers sit. But i need to read through it again whichever page it was. Man typing on my phone is bullshit it takes ages to shit out a sdntence

Hmm seems like all of them may be if they don't post today

@Kites
@motel room
@insertnamehere

Come and play.

Hi I'm alive who do i vote for?

cool, voting Long Con

[/vote]

[dunya]

shocked and miserable Mr. Sloonei

[Quin]

shocked and miserable Mr. Sloonei

cant trust the guy as far as i can throw him which is probably to be expected because salad rolls don't have arms

[colonialbob]

The dead are getting restless

[colonialbob]

I'll vote motel or TH today. Still lean TH myself.

[juliets]

Holy crow, Sloonei was bad! Wow.

So here we are again. I need to ISO motel room and Kyle today. I have thought a lot about Turnip and decided his explanation of his ability rings true. It bothered me at first that he wouldn't tell us his results but then again if he was lying as a baddie he could just make up results and we'd never know the difference. So, I'm inclined to think he is civ. Here's a beer Turnip

Sloonei's flip makes me think more about Kyle though. If Sloonei's ability was bad then Kyle's could be too, thus my reason for wanting to re-read him. I also need to catch up with what you guys have said since the night post. Also, was Colin on to something? Need to re-read him too. RIP Colin.

[dunya]

[sig]

Smh Dunya stealing marsh's gif.

[sig]

So would it be worth it to aim for a tie if we have two suspects?

Motel room has nothing to lynch on, but beyond gut there's no reason to civ read him either.

[juliets]

So would it be worth it to aim for a tie if we have two suspects?

Motel room has nothing to lynch on, but beyond gut there's no reason to civ read him either.

I know, there's really not anything to ISO. This is so hard. Haven't read Kyle yet, unpacking and I have rehab this afternoon so it will be this evening probably before I can get to it.

[Turnip Head]

Here's a beer Turnip

[Turnip Head]

I'ma vote for sig tbh Something's not quite right with the boy

[sig]

I'ma vote for sig tbh Something's not quite right with the boy

Lol great logic.

[sig]

In related news i did a reread of TH and juliet I'm certain they're civ. Kyle and bob look okay as well so that would just leave motel but in unsure there so id suggest a reread of kyle and bob

[sig]

Also i disagree that a double vote for mafia would ne overpowered looking at their other powers.

[colonialbob]

Also i disagree that a double vote for mafia would ne overpowered looking at their other powers.

I agree with you, mafia double vote is a pretty standard power imo. It lets you break or create ties basically. Also I can't even self-target so.

[Turnip Head]

In related news i did a reread of TH and juliet I'm certain they're civ. Kyle and bob look okay as well so that would just leave motel but in unsure there so id suggest a reread of kyle and bob

Certain, you say?

[Sloonei]

Smh Dunya stealing marsh's gif.

It was introduced by Strawhenge on RYM, I believe. #mafiahistory

[JaggedJimmyJay]

The OG, lost to the image hosting gremlins.

This post is in red.

[sig]

In related news i did a reread of TH and juliet I'm certain they're civ. Kyle and bob look okay as well so that would just leave motel but in unsure there so id suggest a reread of kyle and bob

Certain, you say?

Very certain

[Turnip Head]

In related news i did a reread of TH and juliet I'm certain they're civ. Kyle and bob look okay as well so that would just leave motel but in unsure there so id suggest a reread of kyle and bob

Certain, you say?

Very certain

[juliets]

Kyle:

1. Shows suspicion of Elo day 1. Votes Epi. Town read
2. Talks about sending people games early on so it probably is his power. NAI
3. Votes for option 2 over 6. Slight town read.
4. Long Con accuses Kyle of saying he targeted Quin with a non-kill power on purpose to throw off a tracker, slightly town or not Al Pieda.
5. Long Con votes for Kyle - possible distancing or LC voting for someone he thinks is ISIS. Can't tell at this point.
6. Kyle asks Luna why she has him as a town read, slightly town.
7. List of reads here looks pretty good.
8. Has several posts digging at Elo but if he's Al Pieda this doesn't mean anything. NAI
9. States that long con seems off because his vote for Kyle was based on inaccuracies. Kyle is in danger of getting lynched this phase. Town read.
10. Votes sprityo, slight scum read though so did speedchuck, Golden and JJJ.
11. Reiterates LC suspicion after he gets out of the sex cave and says he wants to review him (town) but I don't believe he ever does (slightly scum)
12. Votes Long Con, town read.
13. Votes INH, town read.

Well, I would have liked to find reasons to read Kyle as Al Pieda but I think his treatment of LC convinces me he is not. I guess he could have been distancing early and seen the writing on the wall when he voted him but that intermediate mention of him after he got out of the sex cave does not seem like distancing. I come out of my re-read of Kyle seeing him as town.

This presents me with a real dilemma though - who are the last two Al Pieda? I can see one being motel room even though he voted Long Con but who is the other? I don't think it's sig or Turnip or DDL. So is it c-bob? I just read him the other day as town. GAH! I guess I will read him again. Thoughts anyone?

[juliets]

I'm putting a vote on motel room for now.

[Kylemii]

Also i disagree that a double vote for mafia would ne overpowered looking at their other powers.

I guess you're right, mafias have had other strong powers, i just have trouble reconciling any reason why he would let his role be known publically if he were mafia? i guess he'd need to be honest about his role's involvement in the tie since I knew about it, but why not make up something fake in the sex cave in the first place?

[Kylemii]

I appreciate having the opportunity to say "sex cave" as often as possible

[juliets]

Also i disagree that a double vote for mafia would ne overpowered looking at their other powers.

I guess you're right, mafias have had other strong powers, i just have trouble reconciling any reason why he would let his role be known publically if he were mafia? i guess he'd need to be honest about his role's involvement in the tie since I knew about it, but why not make up something fake in the sex cave in the first place?

It does seem like he wouldn't want it known if he were mafia. Kyle, who do you think the last ones are?

[Kylemii]

It does seem like he wouldn't want it known if he were mafia. Kyle, who do you think the last ones are?

i don't believe you sig or ddl are Al Pieda, based on your roles in LC's lynch. that leaves turnip head, motel room, and cbob. I'd say TH/Motel seems more likely than CBob/Motel.