The Polka Heist [GAME OVER]

[MacDougall]

Spanking town. I'll allow it.

[Long Con]

I am 100% certain Sloonei is scum. Lynch me or him idc. Just lynch the other one next.

So, you're saying you're both town then?

[Michelle]

I am 100% certain Sloonei is scum. Lynch me or him idc. Just lynch the other one next.

i wish to know on a scale from 1 to 10 how much you believe this. And by comparison how much you were convinced that Dom will flip scum?

[Michelle]

I'm voting Tony in the meantime. Gut, plus I didn't like his entrance after the Creature lynch, it felt phony to me with the "I don't know what's going on", plus the unnecessary jab from Creature early D1.

[VOTE: Tony] aubergine

Rereading the last page of Dizzy's Iso, this is his last post before Eod.
Reposting it to ask everyone:
- why do you think Dizzy was NKed?

[Sloonei]

Does anyone have reason to disagree with my four person POE of DDL, Mac, Sorsha, and Tony?

[MacDougall]

I am 100% certain Sloonei is scum. Lynch me or him idc. Just lynch the other one next.

i wish to know on a scale from 1 to 10 how much you believe this. And by comparison how much you were convinced that Dom will flip scum?

3/10 on Sloonei. 0/10 Dom.

[Long Con]

This game got pretty quiet.

@drwilgy which of the current Lynch candidates is most likely to be bad?

[Sloonei]

This game got pretty quiet.

@drwilgy which of the current Lynch candidates is most likely to be bad?

Why are you asking wilgy?
What’s your answer to this question, and who are “the current lynch candidates”?

[Long Con]

It was just a quick off the top of my head thing from the bathroom at work, because of the dead thread. I didn't really have time to put a deep post together.

Wilgy was sort of the first name I saw.

[Long Con]

The current Lynch candidates are those with one vote, at least that's what I meant. He's free to interpret it however he likes, anything is better than nothing in a dead thread.

[Long Con]

Oh, and my answer to this question is DDL.

[Sloonei]

Oh, and my answer to this question is DDL.

Why?

[Long Con]

Well, it's not me, I don't think it's you, and Mac has very little content to work with, and I've been pinged by DDL before.

[G-Man]

novaselinenever has replaced Sorsha

[TonyStarkPrime]

Oh, and my answer to this question is DDL.

politiciany?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I'm voting Tony in the meantime. Gut, plus I didn't like his entrance after the Creature lynch, it felt phony to me with the "I don't know what's going on", plus the unnecessary jab from Creature early D1.

[VOTE: Tony] aubergine

Rereading the last page of Dizzy's Iso, this is his last post before Eod.
Reposting it to ask everyone:
- why do you think Dizzy was NKed?

Dizzy was the top poster and was almost town cleared with no one voicing any suspicion. Sloonei and I hinted earlier that it seems that the mafia are killing off members of TMNT, which if WIFOMy but gives the impression that scum has a streamlined and rather obvious kill list.

[TonyStarkPrime]

would you like to share your idea?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Does anyone have reason to disagree with my four person POE of DDL, Mac, Sorsha, and Tony?

yes add LC and Wilgy
Where is Wilgy? Did you explain this I’ll go look

[TonyStarkPrime]

unfortunately creature did not leave us with much content to work with.

other people might have said things about him that could be revealing though

Yeah I peeked through it and the only thing I saw that caught my eye was some banter with tsp that I read as distancing.

This post contains an actual observation from Creature’s ISO without any bells and/or whistles. This tells me that wilgy actually took the time to look at Creature’s posts, but didn’t make a show of it or anything like that. He was looking just to look. Scum wilgy doesn’t need to do that.

Just this?

[Sloonei]

unfortunately creature did not leave us with much content to work with.

other people might have said things about him that could be revealing though

Yeah I peeked through it and the only thing I saw that caught my eye was some banter with tsp that I read as distancing.

This post contains an actual observation from Creature’s ISO without any bells and/or whistles. This tells me that wilgy actually took the time to look at Creature’s posts, but didn’t make a show of it or anything like that. He was looking just to look. Scum wilgy doesn’t need to do that.

Just this?

Kinda. Also just a general appreciation for the direction of his posts. Wilgy's wilgy. He's probably got the weakest case to not be in the POE.

[novaselinenever]

Hi I'm town

[Long Con]

Hi I'm town

[novaselinenever]

Does anyone have reason to disagree with my four person POE of DDL, Mac, Sorsha, and Tony?

I disagree with it

[Sloonei]

... i didn't realize nova had subbed in.

[Sloonei]

Does anyone have reason to disagree with my four person POE of DDL, Mac, Sorsha, and Tony?

I disagree with it

Go on, please!

[novaselinenever]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

[Sloonei]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

[novaselinenever]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

DDL's rant about people circle-jerking is hard town. Same with inactive/not fully engaged Mac suspecting you strongly. Both are very genuine.

[novaselinenever]

Granted I haven't read the whole game yet.

[novaselinenever]

It's scaring me, seems like a daunting task.

[novaselinenever]

Also the fact that I've read bits and bits makes me even more lazy. It's like that feeling you get trying to pick up a tv show you saw a few episodes of a while ago lol.

[novaselinenever]

First scum read of the game was Epi. I'll give a cookie to anyone that tells me why.

[Sloonei]

Granted I haven't read the whole game yet.

#downwithketchup

[Sloonei]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

DDL's rant about people circle-jerking is hard town. Same with inactive/not fully engaged Mac suspecting you strongly. Both are very genuine.

I believe DDL’s feelings about the hot potato lynch reflect an honest position of his, but I don’t think that indicates that he is town in this game.

Mac pretending to suspect me means absolutely nothing. He literally does every game we play together.

[Sloonei]

First scum read of the game was Epi. I'll give a cookie to anyone that tells me why.

Because he’s being low key?

[novaselinenever]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

DDL's rant about people circle-jerking is hard town. Same with inactive/not fully engaged Mac suspecting you strongly. Both are very genuine.

I believe DDL’s feelings about the hot potato lynch reflect an honest position of his, but I don’t think that indicates that he is town in this game.

You actually may be right

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

DDL's rant about people circle-jerking is hard town. Same with inactive/not fully engaged Mac suspecting you strongly. Both are very genuine.

Mac pretending to suspect me means absolutely nothing. He literally does every game we play together.

What does that mean? Unless it's a running joke, it usually means something. He either really suspects you or he's faking it. It doesn't feel completely fake here, the smirky tone coupled with his general inactivity makes it genuine.

[novaselinenever]

First scum read of the game was Epi. I'll give a cookie to anyone that tells me why.

Because he’s being low key?

No. The series of trigger votes with hot takes, and a whole vibe of concise snarky posts. Very fake.

[TonyStarkPrime]

First scum read of the game was Epi. I'll give a cookie to anyone that tells me why.

You can’t count?

[TonyStarkPrime]

unfortunately creature did not leave us with much content to work with.

other people might have said things about him that could be revealing though

Yeah I peeked through it and the only thing I saw that caught my eye was some banter with tsp that I read as distancing.

This post contains an actual observation from Creature’s ISO without any bells and/or whistles. This tells me that wilgy actually took the time to look at Creature’s posts, but didn’t make a show of it or anything like that. He was looking just to look. Scum wilgy doesn’t need to do that.

Just this?

Kinda. Also just a general appreciation for the direction of his posts. Wilgy's wilgy. He's probably got the weakest case to not be in the POE.

Noted.

[Sloonei]

Mac pretending to suspect me means absolutely nothing. He literally does every game we play together.

What does that mean? Unless it's a running joke, it usually means something. He either really suspects you or he's faking it. It doesn't feel completely fake here, the smirky tone coupled with his general inactivity makes it genuine.

I compiled a list in a game several months ago:

Here's Mac tinfoiling me in the GoC. I was town.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in A World Asunder. I was town. He was not.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in Mega Man. I was town.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in IASIP. I am town.

It's happened a few more times since then. I don't think he's serious anyway. He gave his seriousness a 3/10 earlier.

So it tells me nothing about his alignment.

[novaselinenever]

Mac pretending to suspect me means absolutely nothing. He literally does every game we play together.

What does that mean? Unless it's a running joke, it usually means something. He either really suspects you or he's faking it. It doesn't feel completely fake here, the smirky tone coupled with his general inactivity makes it genuine.

I compiled a list in a game several months ago:

Here's Mac tinfoiling me in the GoC. I was town.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in A World Asunder. I was town. He was not.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in Mega Man. I was town.
Here's Mac tinfoiling me in IASIP. I am town.

It's happened a few more times since then. I don't think he's serious anyway. He gave his seriousness a 3/10 earlier.

So it tells me nothing about his alignment.

I remember that IASIP game lol.

[novaselinenever]

Great remontada

[Michelle]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

i wish an ellaboration for 'Mac is town' please

trying to catch up, glad to see you playing o/

[novaselinenever]

I'm town, Mac is town and DDL is town. Don't know about Tony.

Bad poe Slonei, bad

i wish an ellaboration for 'Mac is town' please

trying to catch up, glad to see you playing o/

Smirky tone and burst of activity while seemingly being busy feels genuine. While being busy 'cause of RL is generally NAI, busy scum are usually informed thanks to btsc, he doesn't seem to be and I like his vibe.

[novaselinenever]

Sloonei, how did you arrive at that PoE of 4?

[novaselinenever]

No seriously I wanted to write poems about how civ Quin was

Damn I tried not to make it too obvious that Quin was extremely civ but I guess that was obvious to the mafia too.

Does scum!DDL make these comments just after murdering poor Quin in cold-blood?

[Sloonei]

Sloonei, how did you arrive at that PoE of 4?

timmer was town at the wazoo on Day 1.
Epi and Long Con have not looked they’re trying to deceive or misguide the thread at any point.
Michelle’s early posts upon subbing in looked like someone who both wanted to solve the game and was not informed about specific happenings.
Wilgy has been relatively engaged at times, and I think one specific post of his pointed to an earnest effort to read Creature post-flip for teammate interactions.
sig flipped out after we lynched Creature and thought we should have lynched me instead. No teammate is going to react that way.

DDL has done nothing that I think is incompatible with him being scum and I have found more questionable content in his ISO than anyone else’s.
Tony has not done anything that strongly suggests that he is either alignment to me.
Sorhanova did nothing until right now.
Mac did nothing for days and then showed up and did his Mac shtick for 10 minutes and left.

[Sloonei]

No seriously I wanted to write poems about how civ Quin was

Damn I tried not to make it too obvious that Quin was extremely civ but I guess that was obvious to the mafia too.

Does scum!DDL make these comments just after murdering poor Quin in cold-blood?

These posts come after he had publicly stated (and drawn attention to) his desire not to share reads during the night phase. I do not like the way that post, coupled with these ones here, seems to suggest that DDL is responsible for Quin getting killed by having town read him too much. It seems phony and a little calculated.

[novaselinenever]

Hmmm, the not wanting to share reads at night feels fake. Pretty unnecessary remark, especially for someone having seemingly missed most of the earlier stuff.

[novaselinenever]

Sloonei, how did you arrive at that PoE of 4?

timmer was town at the wazoo on Day 1.
Epi and Long Con have not looked they’re trying to deceive or misguide the thread at any point.
Michelle’s early posts upon subbing in looked like someone who both wanted to solve the game and was not informed about specific happenings.
Wilgy has been relatively engaged at times, and I think one specific post of his pointed to an earnest effort to read Creature post-flip for teammate interactions.
sig flipped out after we lynched Creature and thought we should have lynched me instead. No teammate is going to react that way.

DDL has done nothing that I think is incompatible with him being scum and I have found more questionable content in his ISO than anyone else’s.
Tony has not done anything that strongly suggests that he is either alignment to me.
Sorhanova did nothing until right now.
Mac did nothing for days and then showed up and did his Mac shtick for 10 minutes and left.

Agree on timmer
LC looks fine I guess. Epi is scum though, so re-read him
Okay
His remark about Sig maybe wanting to shame people for lynching Creature pre-flip 'cause Sig knows Creature is about to flip town was great.
Agree