It looked something like this.S~V~S wrote:I definitely would like to see it, since the page should not be just "broken".


Moderator: Community Team
It looked something like this.S~V~S wrote:I definitely would like to see it, since the page should not be just "broken".
Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 7:33 pm Just how many days of "let's yeet them tomorrow" can a mafioso survive?
The answer: all of them, if you are a marmot.
Sure thing.TinyBubbles wrote:@Epignosis, it gets less amazing each consecutive round lol
haven't played with Cookie before but agree that a lot of her posts seem like fluff, wouldn't rule out voting her today
Ninja could you link to Made's posts in DW to compare?
and sorry about the sprained angle sig! how did you get it? hope you feel better soon
So you would concur that scum doesn't really use their BTSC much here?nijuukyugou wrote:I also dig the idea of a newbie/fairly newbie being on Team Killface due to the NK - not that I don't think Eloh is an awesome playerbut she really isn't ever killed Night 1. It's an unusual choice. But then again, that could make a helluva WIFOM. Just thought of that. I'll keep it all in mind.
HamburgerBoy wrote:So you would concur that scum doesn't really use their BTSC much here?nijuukyugou wrote:I also dig the idea of a newbie/fairly newbie being on Team Killface due to the NK - not that I don't think Eloh is an awesome playerbut she really isn't ever killed Night 1. It's an unusual choice. But then again, that could make a helluva WIFOM. Just thought of that. I'll keep it all in mind.
Metalmarsh89 wrote:It looked something like this.S~V~S wrote:I definitely would like to see it, since the page should not be just "broken".
How many Roxy's do you know that are boys?Sig wrote:Page 5 Roxy pinged me, saying he/she? wouldn't vote for new players and would vote against anyone who voted for a new player. I'm all for voting for a new player and I think saying lets not lynch a new player is a good way for mafia members to slip by, they could either be new players or justify not voting for new players who are mafia by saying they don't want to vote for a new person.
No I would NOT concur. Whenever I have BTSC sometimes I cannot go to chatzy so I will FB or PM my teamies to keep in touch. Otherwise I quite enjoy BTSC as it gives you a chance to get to know other players.HamburgerBoy wrote:So you would concur that scum doesn't really use their BTSC much here?nijuukyugou wrote:I also dig the idea of a newbie/fairly newbie being on Team Killface due to the NK - not that I don't think Eloh is an awesome playerbut she really isn't ever killed Night 1. It's an unusual choice. But then again, that could make a helluva WIFOM. Just thought of that. I'll keep it all in mind.
Roxy wrote:Ans since no one else asked but instead ass-u-me -'d---
llama man - Was the last lynch a tie?
I explained why.Roxy wrote:Epi - Your entire list is of new players - except Timmer. Why? And why Timmer? Also I doubt very srsly that llama did not rand roles and put all newbs in a baddie group together. Unless you know something I don't - are we not supposed to random roles in every game we host? (maybe one or two tweaks tops?)
No I didn't, but I've come to find I should not be surprised at what I find the internet has to offer anymore. I don't know much about coding myself, but I'll be learning a lot about it over the next year.S~V~S wrote:Thanks, MM. I did some research, and that is due to the broken tags with THIS specific kind of spoiler tag; the the board was actually broken, fin=xing tags would not have fixed it. The first tag we tried would not have done that, but that tag did not work at all in one of the themes (and this one is not 100% visible in the dark theme), so it was not usable for us. If we want a spoiler tag that works in both themes, apparently, our options are more limited.
On a side note, did you know that there are discussion foums for every possible thing? Last night I found not one or two, but THREE forums dedicated to phpbb bb codes alone?
Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Wed Dec 16, 2020 7:33 pm Just how many days of "let's yeet them tomorrow" can a mafioso survive?
The answer: all of them, if you are a marmot.
I disagree with that notion. Although I have had some teammates as a baddie that were pretty MIA from BTSC, I am always fully engaged.HamburgerBoy wrote:So you would concur that scum doesn't really use their BTSC much here?nijuukyugou wrote:I also dig the idea of a newbie/fairly newbie being on Team Killface due to the NK - not that I don't think Eloh is an awesome playerbut she really isn't ever killed Night 1. It's an unusual choice. But then again, that could make a helluva WIFOM. Just thought of that. I'll keep it all in mind.
Epignosis wrote: <<<<<snippety-do-dah>>>>>>>
I explained why.
My response is purple
Ok but I totes disagree with your assessment. It could be you who killed Elo for the wifom and to be able to point out a theory that only involves newbs. It could have been any of us tbf and imo.
<<<snippy-snip>>>>>
What is your opinion of Saberface? I think he's either Killfish or on that team.
I don't think there are any hard rules on how roles get dispersed in a game. Some hosts might hand-pick all the players for their roles for all I know. I always randomize, and make tweaks if necessary. Players who have a history of low participation or disappearing are less likely to get roles that I consider important, cool, or high-maintenance.Epignosis wrote:I explained why.Roxy wrote:Epi - Your entire list is of new players - except Timmer. Why? And why Timmer? Also I doubt very srsly that llama did not rand roles and put all newbs in a baddie group together. Unless you know something I don't - are we not supposed to random roles in every game we host? (maybe one or two tweaks tops?)
As for timmer, he has said some slippery things, and in one case, claimed something that wasn't even true. He backed off this advance. That was still enough to give him a seat in my front row.
All new people could be bad after a randomization.![]()
What is your opinion of Saberface? I think he's either Killfish or on that team.
It could be any of us...but that's the point of the game. I have to go by what I think is the most reasonable explanation. You can't discount everyone's reasoning simply because "it could have been you."Roxy wrote:My response is purple
Ok but I totes disagree with your assessment. It could be you who killed Elo for the wifom and to be able to point out a theory that only involves newbs. It could have been any of us tbf and imo.
I appreciate that!Roxy wrote:Been listening to Jimi Hendrix and was thinking about next ChristmasI bet you can play Stone Free or Crosstown Traffic for me on my next cd, right? I mean your Little Wing cover is fucking fantasic.
Did it look like a tie? You just have to go by the votes you can see.Roxy wrote:dammit! ebwop-
Roxy wrote:Ans since no one else asked but instead ass-u-me -'d---
llama man - Was the last lynch a tie?
Epignosis wrote:If llama is good, it means we exist in a universe in which multitasking llama can call out the first of two mafia while simultaneously calling out two civilians.
I don't want to live in that universe.
I tend to tunnel on those particular people. I still think the whole thing felt faux to me, but I generally always read MP that way. Several people weighed in that they felt it would be out of character for Epi to act as I thought it looked to me. I am trying to be less tunnelish as it jest leads to shouting matches and grief for me. If the whole thing was a joke on Epis part, then i wish people would not joke about suspicions, becasue I have issues sometimes differentiating humor when i can't see peoples faces. I thought he was serious, some seem to think he was kidding. He dropped it quickly enough.Roxy wrote:
SVS (Someone pointed out earlier that it is unlike SVS not to stand by a minor suspicion for a vote Day 1 - I too found it odd she did not vote for you or MP)![]()
You suck tbqhthellama73 wrote:Did it look like a tie? You just have to go by the votes you can see.Roxy wrote:dammit! ebwop-
Roxy wrote:Ans since no one else asked but instead ass-u-me -'d---
llama man - Was the last lynch a tie?
DharmaHelper wrote:Any thoughts on my big post, Roxy?
Well then this is a new thing for you so I will take what you say under advisement. Though it was weird not to see you follow your own suspicion esp on Day 1.S~V~S wrote:I tend to tunnel on those particular people. I still think the whole thing felt faux to me, but I generally always read MP that way. Several people weighed in that they felt it would be out of character for Epi to act as I thought it looked to me. I am trying to be less tunnelish as it jest leads to shouting matches and grief for me. If the whole thing was a joke on Epis part, then i wish people would not joke about suspicions, becasue I have issues sometimes differentiating humor when i can't see peoples faces. I thought he was serious, some seem to think he was kidding. He dropped it quickly enough.Roxy wrote:
SVS (Someone pointed out earlier that it is unlike SVS not to stand by a minor suspicion for a vote Day 1 - I too found it odd she did not vote for you or MP)![]()
You want Llama to reveal Killface to us, basically?Roxy wrote:You suck tbqhthellama73 wrote:Did it look like a tie? You just have to go by the votes you can see.Roxy wrote:dammit! ebwop-
Roxy wrote:Ans since no one else asked but instead ass-u-me -'d---
llama man - Was the last lynch a tie?![]()
![]()
How about a straight answer? - Yes or No?
Long Con wrote:You want Llama to reveal Killface to us, basically?Roxy wrote:You suck tbqhthellama73 wrote:Did it look like a tie? You just have to go by the votes you can see.Roxy wrote:dammit! ebwop-
Roxy wrote:Ans since no one else asked but instead ass-u-me -'d---
llama man - Was the last lynch a tie?![]()
![]()
How about a straight answer? - Yes or No?
Yes, that is what I think. I think that if it was not a tie, then one of you three is probably Killface. I also think that if it was a tie, then everyone involved is definitely not Killface. I also think that it's not up to the host to narrow it down for us like that... he could, I suppose, but I just doubt he will.Roxy wrote:also forgot - If it was not a tie then it would have to be Me, SVS or Burger Boy. Is that what you think?
Long Con wrote:Yes, that is what I think. I think that if it was not a tie, then one of you three is probably Killface. I also think that if it was a tie, then everyone involved is definitely not Killface. I also think that it's not up to the host to narrow it down for us like that... he could, I suppose, but I just doubt he will.Roxy wrote:also forgot - If it was not a tie then it would have to be Me, SVS or Burger Boy. Is that what you think?
You may or may not recall the issues I used to have with DH. Finally I said I just have to learn how to deal with his tone, so I started to ignore his tone completely. This is a similar thing, Epis tone, and to a certain extent MPs as well (although its more demeanor than tone with MP) almost ALWAYS set off my alarms. So if I don't want to derail every game I play with them, I have to learn to look past that. If you recall, in one of my first posts i said something was catching my eye, but I wasn't sure if i wanted to discuss it, and that was the Epi/Mp thing.Roxy wrote:Well then this is a new thing for you so I will take what you say under advisement. Though it was weird not to see you follow your own suspicion esp on Day 1.S~V~S wrote:I tend to tunnel on those particular people. I still think the whole thing felt faux to me, but I generally always read MP that way. Several people weighed in that they felt it would be out of character for Epi to act as I thought it looked to me. I am trying to be less tunnelish as it jest leads to shouting matches and grief for me. If the whole thing was a joke on Epis part, then i wish people would not joke about suspicions, becasue I have issues sometimes differentiating humor when i can't see peoples faces. I thought he was serious, some seem to think he was kidding. He dropped it quickly enough.Roxy wrote:
SVS (Someone pointed out earlier that it is unlike SVS not to stand by a minor suspicion for a vote Day 1 - I too found it odd she did not vote for you or MP)![]()
I have seen you tunnel MP hard and vice versa but what do you think of Daisy's suspicion of MP? Do you agree with her?
I do not discount it I just do not care about it. If you want to find me suspicious for not wanting to vote new/returning players Day 1 so be it. Just get used to it bc I am that way every game.sig wrote:@Roxy I never assume genders, on a faceless internet site you could have picked your name from anything, so it is always good to be clear. You completely discount what I think about how you vote that is fine, but you seem to have an attitude and just blow off what I said. The whole point of mafia is to point what you find suspicious so should I have not commented at all or you are just going to ignore and not care what I say, not a very good strategy.
I think one of the three who voted for Metal is Killface and at the very least mafia. Saber could be mafia but why if he was killface would he ask about ties in the thread and not in BTSC or even Pm to the host/mod.
Tiny what do you think of the game so far who do you find the most suspicious?
Hamburger boy, who would you like to vote for this phase and why?
I don't really have any suspicion of any of you. If I had to vote for one of you, it would be S~V~S, but only because I feel a tiny bit Civ about you and Burger.Roxy wrote:Long Con wrote:Yes, that is what I think. I think that if it was not a tie, then one of you three is probably Killface. I also think that if it was a tie, then everyone involved is definitely not Killface. I also think that it's not up to the host to narrow it down for us like that... he could, I suppose, but I just doubt he will.Roxy wrote:also forgot - If it was not a tie then it would have to be Me, SVS or Burger Boy. Is that what you think?
I respectfully disagree. Maybe I am thinking wrong and my logic flawed (would not be the first time nor the last) but it is my logic so I will follow it.
What do you think of Me, SVS and Burger Boy?
Not that some of what I noticed matters now, as it will be taken as day late and dollar short butt covering. I should have spoken up earlier, but I hadn't noticed the baddies had BTSC. What I saw was that LC put a premium on finding Stan, since he explodes heads every night, which would likely put him somewhere on team Crews. I realized that would tip off team killface, so I opted against saying it. Clearly, that was to my detriment now.timmer wrote:I agree with this completely.Epignosis wrote:
Saberfish - "Noticed some stuff" but couldn't be bothered to state what that stuff is. Asked about ties before voting.After the lynch, makes the obvious speculation that S~V~S, Hamburger Boy, or Roxy could be Killface. Voted thirteenth overall for Mac's Mom for a vague reason. Still not sharing what "stuff" was noticed. Voted someone who had no votes when eight others had at least one vote.
Based on this, I say Saberface is Killfish.![]()
First time online. I haven't played with people in person in like a year or more.Epignosis wrote:Saberfish, how many times have you played Mafia, both online and real life?
Fuckin joker.G-Man wrote:So what saltpeter guys chorea saying is I need to pick a theme and Yin with it to stop getting dumped on?
Consider it done. Rooter 8 Ball it contriving anagoge single game.
I've got a life rapparee so I'm voting Made now. honeytongued I think he is team Killface for the reasons I have already Fictional Moustache.
Did you want to address my points against you?S~V~S wrote:You may or may not recall the issues I used to have with DH. Finally I said I just have to learn how to deal with his tone, so I started to ignore his tone completely. This is a similar thing, Epis tone, and to a certain extent MPs as well (although its more demeanor than tone with MP) almost ALWAYS set off my alarms. So if I don't want to derail every game I play with them, I have to learn to look past that. If you recall, in one of my first posts i said something was catching my eye, but I wasn't sure if i wanted to discuss it, and that was the Epi/Mp thing.Roxy wrote:Well then this is a new thing for you so I will take what you say under advisement. Though it was weird not to see you follow your own suspicion esp on Day 1.S~V~S wrote:I tend to tunnel on those particular people. I still think the whole thing felt faux to me, but I generally always read MP that way. Several people weighed in that they felt it would be out of character for Epi to act as I thought it looked to me. I am trying to be less tunnelish as it jest leads to shouting matches and grief for me. If the whole thing was a joke on Epis part, then i wish people would not joke about suspicions, becasue I have issues sometimes differentiating humor when i can't see peoples faces. I thought he was serious, some seem to think he was kidding. He dropped it quickly enough.Roxy wrote:
SVS (Someone pointed out earlier that it is unlike SVS not to stand by a minor suspicion for a vote Day 1 - I too found it odd she did not vote for you or MP)![]()
I have seen you tunnel MP hard and vice versa but what do you think of Daisy's suspicion of MP? Do you agree with her?
As for Daisy, her suspicion and her blowing my suspicions about Epi/MP off as she did seem somewhat contradictory. Unless she was just defending Epi, although I did not read it that way. Perhaps I just misread Epi, and Daisy is the one throwing MP under the bus
Nope.G-Man wrote:So what saltpeter guys chorea saying is I need to pick a theme and Yin with it to stop getting dumped on?
OK. Hmm.Saberfish wrote:First time online. I haven't played with people in person in like a year or more.Epignosis wrote:Saberfish, how many times have you played Mafia, both online and real life?
Why not Cookie?Epignosis wrote:At this stage, I'm voting Made.
I see no reason to wait.
You don't think Made is guilty as Adam? Their names are almost the same spelled backwards as they are forward. That's proof enough for me.DharmaHelper wrote:Why not Cookie?Epignosis wrote:At this stage, I'm voting Made.
I see no reason to wait.
Yeah.Epignosis wrote:Sorry, Made. Did you say something?
I will have to go look for them. Give me a sec. Or many secs, lol.DharmaHelper wrote:Did you want to address my points against you?S~V~S wrote:You may or may not recall the issues I used to have with DH. Finally I said I just have to learn how to deal with his tone, so I started to ignore his tone completely. This is a similar thing, Epis tone, and to a certain extent MPs as well (although its more demeanor than tone with MP) almost ALWAYS set off my alarms. So if I don't want to derail every game I play with them, I have to learn to look past that. If you recall, in one of my first posts i said something was catching my eye, but I wasn't sure if i wanted to discuss it, and that was the Epi/Mp thing.Roxy wrote:Well then this is a new thing for you so I will take what you say under advisement. Though it was weird not to see you follow your own suspicion esp on Day 1.S~V~S wrote:I tend to tunnel on those particular people. I still think the whole thing felt faux to me, but I generally always read MP that way. Several people weighed in that they felt it would be out of character for Epi to act as I thought it looked to me. I am trying to be less tunnelish as it jest leads to shouting matches and grief for me. If the whole thing was a joke on Epis part, then i wish people would not joke about suspicions, becasue I have issues sometimes differentiating humor when i can't see peoples faces. I thought he was serious, some seem to think he was kidding. He dropped it quickly enough.Roxy wrote:
SVS (Someone pointed out earlier that it is unlike SVS not to stand by a minor suspicion for a vote Day 1 - I too found it odd she did not vote for you or MP)![]()
I have seen you tunnel MP hard and vice versa but what do you think of Daisy's suspicion of MP? Do you agree with her?
As for Daisy, her suspicion and her blowing my suspicions about Epi/MP off as she did seem somewhat contradictory. Unless she was just defending Epi, although I did not read it that way. Perhaps I just misread Epi, and Daisy is the one throwing MP under the bus