Epignosis wrote:Roxy.
She likes new players and I think Cookie would appeal to her.
The "I will vote for anyone voting new players" angle (which Roxy does take regularly) turned into voting MetalMarsh89 for 3 votes when Cookie had 2 ("I broke the tie!"). She could have broken the Cookie Day 1. She didn't because of dogma.
The refusal to vote new players despite evidence is dogma, Roxy. Dogma.
She cast a wide net Day 2 ("I could vote any of these people") and ended up voting Cookie after I tipped the scales.
I feel confident Roxy is bad.
You cast a pretty wide net yourself. There is more than one baddie this game I try not to limit my suspicion to one player.
Tough shit about Day 1. Its how I play. It is who I am as a person. I will not change. The evidence you provided Day 1 just did not prick my interest. It was her flip floppy-ness on Timmer that I found so strange. I questioned her beginning with my "wide net" post you are referring to bc I linky'd with her while making it.
After my questioning my list narrowed here:
Roxy wrote:For me it is Made or Cookie.
Blooper -
Roxy wrote:nijuukyugou wrote:So many choices. I thought there would be more votes up given that several have announced their vote in the thread, but there are only 5 total so far? Huh.
Feeling slightly, slightly better about Made regarding tone, but that could be just him fixin' it up for me

Thoughts on timmer haven't changed since I last spoke of him. Then this happens:
Roxy wrote:I have so many that I am willing to vote for today: Saberfish, MP, Cookie, Burger Boy, Made, Bubbles or DP if he does not answer my question
Linky - oooooo Now you are suspicious of Timmer------again after you said after reading back you did not find him suspicious?
Yes, this caught my eye as well. Trying to look more contributory, Cookie McNasty?
I pointed out these same exactly things (minus the most recent quotes) when I voted him last and you made no comment on them then.]
Thats bc it was Day 1 and even though Cookie was not on my list I realized I had no prior experience with her. Day 2 I give no breaks to anyone

Here is the post and my response. No where after you quoted my post do I see a new paragraph or a break to say you were no longer talking to me about my post. I answered you the way I did bc of this part of your post that looks like a response to me.

(see bolded big)
I would think if her teammates voted for her it would have been Saberfish or ika. I am not so sure it was a claim now. Or just Epi reading to far into his post. I do feel like ika is very quiet and even after he said he would post a stream of conscience post before his vote he never did and instead did a drive by vote as I pointed out.
Epi - you knew she hated being mafia. I could see you bus her but I do agree it is more likely you would have helped her.
I guess you think I am a shitty player that could offer her no advice or help her in anyway if I had bts with her. That I would have let her flop around without help while helping to drive her lynch.
