Zodiac Mafia [GAME OVER]

#651

So I was right about Daisy!

It seems like we had about three bad teams I'm guessing?

#652

I knew you were bad Epi. You know why? You didn't once suspect me. Come on man, you can call me as bad better than anyone else, so I knew you were off.

#653

Wow, three baddie teams of three and just three devastatingly charming civvies?

#654

For those of you wondering how the game shaped, up, here's a look.

Civilians [3]

Lynch Survivor - G-Man (Pisces)
NK Survivor - Sloonei (Taurus)
First Kill Survivor - thellama73 (Sagittarius)

Mafia Team I [3]

First Kill Survivor - Quin (Pisces)
Vanilla - Epignosis (Virgo)
Vanilla - Sorsha (Cancer)

Mafia Team II [3]

First Kill Survivor - Bubbles (Taurus) Nerolunar (Aquarius)
Vanilla - S~V~S (Gemini)
Vanilla - sig (Cancer)

Mafia Team III [3]

First Kill Survivor - Spacedaisy (Taurus)
Vanilla - DrWilgy (Leo)
Vanilla - Bullzeye (Capricorn)

#####################################################################################################

Also, here is a list of all the personal win conditions. They were handed out depending on the player's sign. However, a player's sign did not dictate what team they were on.

Aquarius - You are an Aquarius. You are vulnerable and sensitive, and get aggrieved when someone wants to take advantage of you. At least once in the game, your vote at the end of the day must be on someone whose vote is also on you.

Cancer - You are a Cancer. You are loyal to those who are friendly to you, yet you also have difficulty trusting anyone. To overcome this, once in the game, you must exhibit trust in another player in the game thread, and follow that person's vote.

Capricorn - You are a Capricorn. You are ambitious and set high goals for yourself, enjoying making things more challenging for yourself. At the start of the game, you will name one person who you will try to lynch. That person must be lynched during the game.

Gemini - You are a Gemini. You sometimes see situations from a dual perspective and this can appear to others to be changeable and inconsistent. Once in the game, you must vote for someone who you have declared that you think is a civilian.

Leo - You are a Leo. You seek admiration and acknowledgement from others. Once in the game, you must make a case against and vote another player in the game, and gain the support of another player who agrees with your case, and/or votes for that player.

Pisces - You are a Pisces. You are versatile and independent. Once in the game, you must vote for four different people in a Day Phase, and make sure that at the end of the Day Phase no-one else is voting for the same person that you are.

Sagittarius - You are a Sagittarius. You seek adventure, and live with fortune on your side. Once in the game, you must finish a Day Period with at least one vote against you without being lynched.

Taurus - You are a Taurus. You are easy going and avoid unnecessary risk. Once in the game, you must survive a day phase without taking any votes.

Virgo - You are a Virgo. You seek perfection in all that you do. Once in the game, you must finish the Day Phase with your vote on a successfully lynched player from an opposing faction.

#655

G-Man wrote:Wow, three baddie teams of three and just three devastatingly charming civvies?

Yes indeed. I'm still surprised that you wound up being lynched on Day 2. That coupled with Sloonei attracting two nightkills on Night really threw a wrench in the civ's chances.

But the funny thing was, your Day 2 list of suspects was pretty accurate.

#656

For those who weren't in the dead thread, my shenanigans were subtle. In honor of the twelve zodiac signs, I self-imposed a posting limitation. Each one of my posts in this thread contains exactly twelve words.

#657

And now I will break with the 12-word shtick. I achieved my personal wincon Day 1 since that was going to be the best day to pull it off. That's about the only thing I have to feel good about with this game.

#658

G-Man wrote:For those who weren't in the dead thread, my shenanigans were subtle. In honor of the twelve zodiac signs, I self-imposed a posting limitation. Each one of my posts in this thread contains exactly twelve words.

This actually sounds vaguely familiar. :P Only vaguely though.

#659

Gg pals. I am surprised I did as well as I did. I didn't receive a single vote at any point

Can someone explain how it ended though?

Did it come down to a coin toss or something? Since I wanted bullz dead and they clearly wanted Epi dead, and if both happened it would've been a draw between Daisy and I.

#660

Quin wrote:Gg pals. I am surprised I did as well as I did. I didn't receive a single vote at any point

Can someone explain how it ended though?

Did it come down to a coin toss or something? Since I wanted bullz dead and they clearly wanted Epi dead, and if both happened it would've been a draw between Daisy and I.

Nevermind. I didnt even read the post where I died.

#661

Also, I want to apologize to you players for running this setup under the Heist label. I submitted this game a while ago, back when we first started doing Heists here. I wasn't aware that the guidelines for Heists are actually supposed to be strict for this game type, and I became aware of this after the game had started. That was when there was some confusion among a few players as to why there were all these power roles cropping up. I apologize for lying about the roles in that regard. I know that a bulletproof counts as a power role, but I chose to adjust the definition to keep the game running and still somewhat intact. Yes there were more than 3 power roles. They were all roughly the same type, but still more than 3.

Thank you all for being patient with me on that. I hope you still had fun regadless.

#662

Quin wrote:Gg pals. I am surprised I did as well as I did. I didn't receive a single vote at any point

Can someone explain how it ended though?

Did it come down to a coin toss or something? Since I wanted bullz dead and they clearly wanted Epi dead, and if both happened it would've been a draw between Daisy and I.

Oh, good question!

So going into Day 5, it was only Spacedaisy and Epignosis left. Had they both been vanilla, the game would have ended in a tie, but because Spacedaisy still had her bulletproof survival intact, the Day 5 lynch was decided by a coin-flip. If Epignosis had won the flip, the game would have ended in a tie, and both teams would have won. If Spacedaisy won the flip, than her team wins outright.

Spacedaisy wound up winning the coinflip, thus her team won outright.

#663

Spacedaisy wrote:I knew you were bad Epi. You know why? You didn't once suspect me. Come on man, you can call me as bad better than anyone else, so I knew you were off.

Almost everybody was bad, apparently.

I don't see how this was a balanced game at all. Or Mafia.

This all boiled down to luck: Who got night killed.

And it all came down to a coin flip.

Might as well have played craps.

#664

Send your votes for MVP, and best roleplayer, to me and marmot.

#665

I hope lots of you enjoyed the game. It was certainly more than a little unorthodox, but we really wanted to give it a go, and from my perspective it was really fun to watch you all try your best to get to grips with it.

Congrats also to the winning team on all meeting your personal win cons... it was touch and go there for a bit.

#666

Golden wrote:I hope lots of you enjoyed the game. It was certainly more than a little unorthodox, but we really wanted to give it a go, and from my perspective it was really fun to watch you all try your best to get to grips with it.

Congrats also to the winning team on all meeting your personal win cons... it was touch and go there for a bit.

I didn't understand it. What was the point of having civilians? They had no chance of winning.

#667

Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:I hope lots of you enjoyed the game. It was certainly more than a little unorthodox, but we really wanted to give it a go, and from my perspective it was really fun to watch you all try your best to get to grips with it.

Congrats also to the winning team on all meeting your personal win cons... it was touch and go there for a bit.
I didn't understand it. What was the point of having civilians? They had no chance of winning.

I'm sorry if you don't like the game setup or didn't find it fun. We did our best to make the experience fun and fair for all, and I hope at least that most people did enjoy it. We certainly went for whimsy as a focus in preference to serious mafia. The game was always going to play out in confusion given the existence of three night kills and all the personal win cons that drove many of the lynch behaviours.

#668

If I had know this game was going to be so crazy I would have signed up, I love radically unorthodox games. You get to see a particular kind of psychological chaos that you never get to see in regular games. You get to watch everyone desperately try to figure out what the hell is going on and no one ever does until the end. I love it. For more radically different games, visit https://rateyourmusic.com/board_message ... 20&start=0 since I'm on a roll for shameless self-promotion today. :P We need seven more players!

#669

Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:I hope lots of you enjoyed the game. It was certainly more than a little unorthodox, but we really wanted to give it a go, and from my perspective it was really fun to watch you all try your best to get to grips with it.

Congrats also to the winning team on all meeting your personal win cons... it was touch and go there for a bit.
I didn't understand it. What was the point of having civilians? They had no chance of winning.

I would argue that Day 1 result would have a strong impact on the game. There was a 50 % chance that a mafia member would be lynched on Day 1, and a 50 % chance that nothing happens. Had a mafia been lynched, the other two mafia teams would be thinking a bit differently about their nightkills for Night 1, instead of targetting the most civilian player.

What we didn't acount for was how the civilians would use their role. G-Man knew he'd survive a lynch, so he tried to get lynched Day 1 to prove it. Sloonei knew he'd survive a nightkill, so he went hardcore civ mode to draw the opening nightkill to go into Day 2 with little damage. Unfortunately, Sloonei drew two nightkills, and G-Man wound up being lynched a second time somehow.

And my super-secret ulterior motive: This game gave me a peek at 9 different players' meta for when they're mafia.

#670

a2thezebra wrote:If I had know this game was going to be so crazy I would have signed up, I love radically unorthodox games. You get to see a particular kind of psychological chaos that you never get to see in regular games. You get to watch everyone desperately try to figure out what the hell is going on and no one ever does until the end. I love it. For more radically different games, visit https://rateyourmusic.com/board_message ... 20&start=0 since I'm on a roll for shameless self-promotion today. :P We need seven more players!

This is also part of it. :P

#671

I actually really hate being mafia. Townies are fantastic.

#672

Quin wrote:I actually really hate being mafia. Townies are fantastic.

Me too. No-one believes it because I have played well as mafia. But I'd be fine being a townie every time.

Although I guess I wouldn't say 'really hate'. More like 'prefer' to be town.

I thought you did a good job seeming townie, Quin. If I was playing, I think I would have had you pegged as town.

#673

Some of my favourite things in this game...

G-Man naming a set of six suspects who he was happy to lynch and every one being right... but even more so...

Daisy saying "I don't think that both G-Man and llama are civs" when they were literally the only two civs.

#674

Golden wrote:
Quin wrote:I actually really hate being mafia. Townies are fantastic.
Me too. No-one believes it because I have played well as mafia. But I'd be fine being a townie every time.

Although I guess I wouldn't say 'really hate'. More like 'prefer' to be town.

I thought you did a good job seeming townie, Quin. If I was playing, I think I would have had you pegged as town.

That's probably because you haven't seen me play as town. I'm pretty much a giveaway any other time.

#675

Interesting stuff, to say the least. Quite the spice up, in that the Hosts rather put everything they found in the cabinet. But everyone mostly seems to have enjoyed it nevertheless and that's what matters.

I make no claims to understand the form this game took or how it was intended to work in any particular direction or even to the equal odds of all factions involved, but I certainly don't think the Heist format favored it. A good reminder for Heists is that, depending on a faction's performance (i.e. whether the civs or the mafia happen to have a bad time overall), such games could be over in 4 or 5 cycles, tops. It's a really small space for elaborate win cons, lynch/NK pdd outcomes, heavy but undisclosed power roles, triple night kills and such.

If I would have played, a slightly irksome factor tbfh would have been the closed setup. The more "what the what" a game would reveal itself to be, the more it'd feel I had no real chance of getting a real grip on it whilst playing. Take for instance that the first chain of one-time survivors turned out to be civilians. That eventually led me, even as a spectator, to believe that one-time survival is a purely civilian trait. Then Nero, I think, died as the first one-time survivor mafioso and every simple rationale went to smoke.

There would be many other questionable details, but I see no point in taking it point by point.

I can only hope this won't create precedent for future Heists to be even stricter enforced. It's why I proposed the "And Now for Something (Slightly) Different" series, as a leeway for when someone feels like adding a bit of crazy or unprecedented into the mix.

Golden wrote:Some of my favourite things in this game...

G-Man naming a set of six suspects who he was happy to lynch and every one being right... but even more so...

Daisy saying "I don't think that both G-Man and llama are civs" when they were literally the only two civs.

Well G-Man basically had an 18% chance to be wrong about calling anyone scum, apparently.

Daisy saying she finds G-Man and Llama to be civs would have been impressive, on the other hand. Stolen from the MP guessbook, even.

#676

This game was awesome and my first win in nearly two years!

Thanks a lot for a fun game, hosts. Also I absolutely loved my team and trying to work out what the hell was going on in btsc. Will all the btsc/spectator threads be made public?

#677

Awesome game! Thanks for hosting guys

Im still quite inexperienced at Mafia so if anyone has some constructive critisism to me, I would be pleased to listen

#678

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:G-Man knew he'd survive a lynch, so he tried to get lynched Day 1 to prove it. Sloonei knew he'd survive a nightkill, so he went hardcore civ mode to draw the opening nightkill to go into Day 2 with little damage. Unfortunately, Sloonei drew two nightkills, and G-Man wound up being lynched a second time somehow.

I wouldn't go so far as to say I was willing to get lynched to prove I could survive a lynch. I was just willing to take the chance on a con flip exposing me so I could fulfill my personal wincon of voting for four different people during the same day and ending as the solo vote on one person.

Can we get a breakdown of all the killings? I'd like to know which team targeted which players.

#679

Epignosis wrote:
Spacedaisy wrote:I knew you were bad Epi. You know why? You didn't once suspect me. Come on man, you can call me as bad better than anyone else, so I knew you were off.
Almost everybody was bad, apparently.

I don't see how this was a balanced game at all. Or Mafia.

This all boiled down to luck: Who got night killed.

And it all came down to a coin flip.

Might as well have played craps.

I don't see how three civilians were supposed to have a chance against 9 mafia.

#680

thellama73 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Spacedaisy wrote:I knew you were bad Epi. You know why? You didn't once suspect me. Come on man, you can call me as bad better than anyone else, so I knew you were off.
Almost everybody was bad, apparently.

I don't see how this was a balanced game at all. Or Mafia.

This all boiled down to luck: Who got night killed.

And it all came down to a coin flip.

Might as well have played craps.

I don't see how three civilians were supposed to have a chance against 9 mafia.

We would have needed the baddie teams to pick each other apart through both the lynches and the NK's. It wasn't impossible for we civvies to win, just improbable. I don't mind the chaotic setup though. It was fun even though I lost. There's no shame in losing against such unfriendly odds.

#681

Golden wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Golden wrote:I hope lots of you enjoyed the game. It was certainly more than a little unorthodox, but we really wanted to give it a go, and from my perspective it was really fun to watch you all try your best to get to grips with it.

Congrats also to the winning team on all meeting your personal win cons... it was touch and go there for a bit.
I didn't understand it. What was the point of having civilians? They had no chance of winning.
I'm sorry if you don't like the game setup or didn't find it fun. We did our best to make the experience fun and fair for all, and I hope at least that most people did enjoy it. We certainly went for whimsy as a focus in preference to serious mafia. The game was always going to play out in confusion given the existence of three night kills and all the personal win cons that drove many of the lynch behaviours.

I did have fun, but no, I don't like the game setup. This was essentially last man standing with three players at an impossible disadvantage.

#682

I had fun too, I don't want any confusion about that. But it was disheartening to learn how little chance I had of actually winning this game (I did fulfill my individual win condition with ease, though!)

The first five kills could all have hit mafia and we still would have been outnumbered.

#683

I voted llama for MVP. And Epi for role play, hippie you don't mind me saying that here. I kinda want to pull for these two. If they hadn't ppps much talked everyone into lynching nero instead of me or bullz, we would not have won.

#684

Hippie = hope
Ppps = pretty much

#685

I'm about to leave for classes, but I'll post a write-up later with all the nightkill targets from each night.

#686

Lol. Fun game, wish I could have stuck around longer.

Way to go Quin. And others, but mostly quin. Please play more

#687

GG all.

Wilgy was pretty proud of his play this game.
*Pets Quin while chewing on a tomato*

#688

Oh yeah!i totally thought you werecivQuin. Well played"

#689

Sloonei wrote:Lol. Fun game, wish I could have stuck around longer.

Way to go Quin. And others, but mostly quin. Please play more

I shall. I thoroughly enjoyed this.

#690

So who won MVP & roleplay?

#691

G-Man wrote:So who won MVP & roleplay?

We need more votes first.

Don't forget to send in your MVP & roleplay votes players!

#692

Metalmarsh89 wrote:We need more votes first.

Ted Cruz, John Kasich, Marco Rubio, and Bernie Sanders can all relate. :P

#693

G-Man wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:We need more votes first.
Ted Cruz, John Kasich, Marco Rubio, and Bernie Sanders can all relate. :P

PUMP FOR TRUUUMMMMPP #DANKMEMES!

#694

G-Man wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:We need more votes first.
Ted Cruz, John Kasich, Marco Rubio, and Bernie Sanders can all relate. :P

Indeed. They be like "Why you voting those other hooligans?"

#695

Only three people have voted.

#696

Three's a crowd.

#697

Golden wrote:Only three people have voted.

It is hard to pick someone since this was really a NK fest more than anything. Who had the most successful NKs? That person, maybe.

#698

To be honest I think Wilgy's strategising in our btsc was pretty good, he came up with a few of our kills and had good logic behind them so maybe he should be it. As for roleplay Epi is the obvious winner.

#699

I will announce the winner of the MVP and roleplay awards tonight. Feel free to PM them to me before.

I don't feel like imposing a deadline, but if you guys want one we can do that. :P

#700

The MVP of Zodiac Mafia is:

Spoiler: show

The roleplay MVP is:

Spoiler: show

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who killed the Best Mafia of 2015?