Early on he made a post pointing out a roles specific powers, and saying we should keep an eye out for a role that is lynched with the second most votes. I think he has a lynch protect, or he can't be lynched until a certain thing happens, or something to that effect, I have no idea what, and is trying for cred. He is already calling himself "confirmed". I think were he a civ, he would not try to draw attention to himself in this way. Civs don't need cred. I think id he was NOT a civ, he would try to draw attention to himself this way for the cred.Matt wrote:Do you think Long Con is a civilian or mafia?S~V~S wrote:I do not plan on voting for you today, though, slip or no slip, because I think you were trying to get lynched last day. I think you will gain some benefit from it, maybe a permanent rezz, or something like that. Maybe your "all cylons must die" thing when that obviously is not true is part of that. But you have some sort of game going on here (a con, if you will) and I for one really don't want to give it to you.
If you think he's a civilian, why shouldn't we help the guy out and lynch him?
if you think he's mafia, how else do you expect to be rid of him if we don't lynch him?
Derp.
You're the other tinfoil guy here, help me out.
If that early mention of that role and the second most votes was just a coincidence, and he is a civ who wants to get lynched, he would have tried harder, a la Rico in GoC. He is not trying hard enough for that scenario,and he is trying too hard to be a civvie. So, no, I don't think he is a civilian. And I don't want to give it to him.Long Con wrote:So here's a list of who is Good and who is Bad, based on the show.
Admiral William Adama – GOOD
President Laura Roslin – GOOD *Roslin's prophecies are interesting, this seems to be an info role, and could be very important to figuring out the game.
Kara ‘Starbuck’ Thrace – GOOD *"cannot be resurrected" - she's not a Cylon, and yet Goldama felt it necessary to let us know this. Apparently humans have the option of being resurrected somehow as well... just not Starbuck. Just as well. They totally messed up her story arc by the end of the series with a confusing and too-weird storyline.
Gaius Baltar – NEUTRAL/INDY?
Lee 'Apollo' Adama - GOOD
Saul Tigh – GOOD *Who is silenced today?
Galen Tyrol – GOOD
Karl ‘Helo’ Agathon – GOOD *This guy could surprise us one day when someone with second-most votes gets lynched. We should watch the second-most-voted as we place our votes... just in case.
Felix Gaeta - BAD BAD BAD
Anastasia 'Dee' Dualla - GOOD *Ika was probably a Cylon because he died and Dee is still alive.
Cally Henderson -GOOD
Sam Anders – GOOD
Lou ‘Kat’ Katraine – GOOD
Brendon ‘Hot Dog’ Costanza – GOOD *Host, will we know that the kill rebounded? Or will it just look like a kill on the new target was intended?
Doc Cottle – GOOD
Billy Keikeya - GOOD
Tom Zarek - NEUTRAL/INDY? BAD? MAYBE GOOD???
Ellen Tigh - GOOD
Tory Foster – BAD
Romo Lampkin – GOOD
John Cavil (number one) - BAD
Leoben Conoy (number two) - BAD
D’Anna Biers (number three) - BAD
Simon O’Neill (number four) - BAD
Aaron Doral (number five) - BAD
Caprica Six (number six) – NEUTRAL/INDY?
Sharon ‘Boomer’ Valerii (number eight) - BAD
Sharon ‘Athena’ Agathon (number eight) – GOOD
[secret role] Might be human. Might be cylon. Might be stationed on Galactica. Might not. Who really knows. WHO REALLY KNOWS?
But I am convinced that if we lynch him he is not gonna die. If you want to lynch him and go in with that mindset, that he is pulling a con on us, I guess I would be in favor of lynching him.
You reread him & give me your opinion; does he sound like a civvie to you?