Lost Again Mafia (Season 2) - Game Over

#651

Elohcin wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm calling a baddie team of Elo/INH/Quin right now.
Why would I be teammates with Quin? That makes no sense at all MP. Listen, I think you are civ. But I also think you need to take a step back to evaluate your read on me here. I called out Quin for THREE days. And I called out INH today. You all were so convinced that Quin was claiming a power role to distract the baddies. I thought he was doing it b/c he knew he wasn't in trouble of being killed b/c he WAS a baddie. Now how do you change your story on that topic? Was I correct on the matter? Would I call out a teammate like that if I were bad and if I were correct on that matter. Your reads are getting all jumbled, MP. I think the baddies are Scotty/Sorsha, INH, and Quin. I think that makes a lot more sense.

I know Scotty is a new name for me to throw around, but I just about forgot he was even playing

Something else that I noticed and wanted to point out here... Elo went on and on about Quin's question as though she didn't know what we all thought he was doing but her post here reads to me like someone who knew exactly what we all thought he was doing. It looks like a baddie slip to me.

#652

The bussing begins.

Well, we'll see.

#653

50 minutes to go...

#654

Can someone pass the popcorn? This is getting interesting.

#655

G-Man wrote:Can someone pass the popcorn? This is getting interesting.

We're stranded on an Island and the hatch blew up. For a dead guy you've got some real high expectations.

#656

Eloh, MP, Epi, INH - 3 of them are bad

(Quin if you end up being bad you get the MVP

)

I'll vote MP

#657

20 minutes to go, three votes missing...

#658

I'm waiting for a thing.

#659

For a thing?

#660

Yes, a thing.

#661

What kind of thing? A particular thing? I find this very fascinating.

#662

Me too

#663

It is a very fascinating thing. Maybe I'll talk more about it after the lynch.

#664

I very much look forward to that.

#665

Voted MP.

In Parks and Rec, I thought a shifty-acting player who was saved on multiple occasions had to be bad. I was wrong, and got a large amount of egg on my face. I'm not 100% sure that Elo isn't a civ that is just being set up. MP and Daisy's quick votes in her direction make me a little nervous.

So, I went with the person I had the strongest negative gut read of.

#666

That thing isn't going to happen anymore.

#667

Then what was the thing you were waiting for that is now no longer going to happen?

#668

A tie, I guess.

We still don't know what would happen, right?

#669

insertnamehere wrote:A tie, I guess.

We still don't know what would happen, right?

Bzzzzt.

I'll explain after the poll closes.

#670

I just got off work.

#671

Epignosis wrote:I just got off work.

How was work?

#672

https://soundcloud.com/user-183375310/the-chaos-carol1

#673

insertnamehere wrote:https://soundcloud.com/user-183375310/the-chaos-carol1

spooky

#674

Day 4 has ended.

Spoiler: show

#675

Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I just got off work.
How was work?

Long 12 hour day.

#676

#677

Poll's closed Quin, so what was the thing...

#678

I think he was waiting for a CFD from the baddies to save someone.

#679

Golden wrote:I think he was waiting for a CFD from the baddies to save someone.

#680

Will that be a fedora with cheese or a derby with sautéed mushrooms?

#681

Of course my top suspects were all good.

#682

me right now

#683

insertnamehere wrote:

me right now

#684

Congrats Daisy, Sorsha and Epignosis! You are the winners.

Please vote for game MVP and roleplay MVP by PM to me.

#685

This game was just so much fun for me, you don't even know...

#686

WWWWAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLT!

#687

Spacedaisy wrote:This game was just so much fun for me, you don't even know...

I'm glad I decided not to trust you against my better judgement

#688

Golden wrote:
Spoiler: show
Sorsha has won. She was:

You are Michael Dawson. This season, you are a one note character who is only around to find your son. At least, that's what we all thought...

You are bad. You are a mafia godfather. This means that you are protected from any ability that could reveal you to be bad. This includes having to be in the same location as your kill target, although you must declare your location in order to be able to kill.

Called it.

#689

Any questions?

The hardest thing for me was answering Quin's questions about whether the baddies had btsc, with me knowing that they were all in one place. As it happened, there was no rule that would have deprived them of btsc had they been in different places, but even if they were it would not have applied since they weren't in different places.

#690

So there wasn't even a baddie in the hatch?

just

my god

i sucked.

#691

I came out hard against Sorsha starting with the beach thread because I was sure you all were going to lynch her, she was acting scummy. I think she was acting so scummy no one could believe she actually was scummy, lol.

#692

Curious to know how they were able to kill Rico in the Hatch when they were all at the Beach.

#693

G-Man wrote:Curious to know how they were able to kill Rico in the Hatch when they were all at the Beach.

Read sorsha's role!

#694

Read Sorsha's godfather role description.

#695

G-Man wrote:
Golden wrote:
Spoiler: show
Sorsha has won. She was:

You are Michael Dawson. This season, you are a one note character who is only around to find your son. At least, that's what we all thought...

You are bad. You are a mafia godfather. This means that you are protected from any ability that could reveal you to be bad. This includes having to be in the same location as your kill target, although you must declare your location in order to be able to kill.
Called it.

I guessed Sorsha, Epi and MP to Golden prior to the Scotty kill. I totally bought MP's saying daisy was good - I figured he did it to get civvie cred in case she got killed. Also I didn't see her tell which I guess means it's not a tell after all.

Congrats to you Epi, Sorsha and Daisy. INH and Quinn, tough loss but I totally got why you thought it was MP. MP, I can't read you for anything.

#696

Golden wrote:
G-Man wrote:Curious to know how they were able to kill Rico in the Hatch when they were all at the Beach.
Read sorsha's role!

Us being separated was just a massive red herring

#697

Spacedaisy wrote:I think she was acting so scummy no one could believe she actually was scummy, lol.

Can't agree with you there. I used reason to surmise that Michael could be bad based on the show. And Sorsha's behavior. Too bad this game suffered a sever case of quietitis. #CivShame

#698

Quin wrote:
Golden wrote:
G-Man wrote:Curious to know how they were able to kill Rico in the Hatch when they were all at the Beach.
Read sorsha's role!
Us being separated was just a massive red herring

Check that. Would the separation have been in effect and a burden to the baddies had we lynched Sorsha Day 1?

#699

Yeah I have no idea what tell he thought he saw, but I milked that for all it was worth, lol.

Linki @G-Man, you were dead early. I was really referring to everyone else. I mean why didn't anyone suspect her enough to vote for her? I was terrified she would get lynched, her role revealed and suddenly everyone would realize all three of us were probably on the beach while we killed Rico. Then we would have been toast.

#700

G-Man wrote:
Quin wrote:
Golden wrote:
G-Man wrote:Curious to know how they were able to kill Rico in the Hatch when they were all at the Beach.
Read sorsha's role!
Us being separated was just a massive red herring
Check that. Would the separation have been in effect and a burden to the baddies had we lynched Sorsha Day 1?

If you ever lynched sorsha, you would have 1) known her role and so not drawn any false conclusions and 2) epi and daisy would have had to have killed from their location. However, in practice, it only mattered on night one since rico died (his role was holding the location rule in place).

In fact, I saw it as a bit of a risky move to all go to the beach since it might be surmised by the civilians as a smart tactic after seeing sorsha's role.

Will you run, hide, or die?