Spectator Thread

#1

Welcome to the Survivor: Mafia Spectator Chat!

Thanks for tuning in, viewer.

You may use this thread to chat about the happenings in the game.

If you have information from the game after being voted out, please add spoiler tags. Otherwise, feel free to speculate to your heart's desire!

#2

I bet someone will win this game.

#3

Marmot wrote:I bet someone will win this game.

Always knew you were a gambling man

#4

How did this Spectator thread start February 28th when it didn't exist before today, March 4th?

#5

juliets wrote:How did this Spectator thread start February 28th when it didn't exist before today, March 4th?

#6

Marmot wrote:I bet someone will win this game.

You're on! I bet it ends in a draw.

#7

Not first!

#8

DH is all hyperactive about this game! I hope he doesn't die first because of his bravado.

#9

juliets wrote:DH is all hyperactive about this game! I hope he doesn't die first because of his bravado.

It is definitely a bold strategy. In the TV show, this either is someone that tribe can't stand and wants off, or takes to the end as a goat.

Either way, he's sure setting himself up to be affected by night actions..

#10

yes, he is. Don't know why he's playing it that way but we'll see. He got killed early in GOC as you remember by mistake so I'd think he's want to be safer here.

#11

juliets wrote:yes, he is. Don't know why he's playing it that way but we'll see. He got killed early in GOC as you remember by mistake so I'd think he's want to be safer here.

he messaged me that he is goaling to be the biggest tv villain of all time.

So...

#12

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:yes, he is. Don't know why he's playing it that way but we'll see. He got killed early in GOC as you remember by mistake so I'd think he's want to be safer here.
he messaged me that he is goaling to be the biggest tv villain of all time.

So...

oh my...I hope he knows what he's doing...

#13

Scotty where is Opt_Outside? Oh wait, I guess you guys are performing at the moment.

#14

juliets wrote:Scotty where is Opt_Outside? Oh wait, I guess you guys are performing at the moment.

Hah yeah we're a bit indisposed but yeah she'll be along soon. She'd rather opt outside than be on her phone playing this, but I appreciate her for agreeing to sign up anyway.

#15

Scotty are you going to divide them into teams or will they form their own teams?

Oops Eloh double voted.

#16

juliets wrote:Scotty are you going to divide them into teams or will they form their own teams?

Oops Eloh double voted.

The luxury items they pick will dictate which tribes they're on.

And then they'll be in separate tribes and threads

#17

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:Scotty are you going to divide them into teams or will they form their own teams?

Oops Eloh double voted.
The luxury items they pick will dictate which tribes they're on.

And then they'll be in separate tribes and threads

Oh cool!

#18

Now I wish I was playing this game instead so I can be a non-conformist and NOT join the DH Idol-Wagon.

#19

Marmot wrote:Now I wish I was playing this game instead so I can be a non-conformist and NOT join the DH Idol-Wagon.

Yes, I don't understand why everyone is joining it so easily unless they are just saying they are and really aren't.

#20

juliets wrote:
Marmot wrote:Now I wish I was playing this game instead so I can be a non-conformist and NOT join the DH Idol-Wagon.
Yes, I don't understand why everyone is joining it so easily unless they are just saying they are and really aren't.

Opt_Out literally yelled at her screen when she was reading through that, and wants nothing to do with DH's power play.

Guess we'll see if they end up on the same tribe...

#21

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:
Marmot wrote:Now I wish I was playing this game instead so I can be a non-conformist and NOT join the DH Idol-Wagon.
Yes, I don't understand why everyone is joining it so easily unless they are just saying they are and really aren't.
Opt_Out literally yelled at her screen when she was reading through that, and wants nothing to do with DH's power play.

Guess we'll see if they end up on the same tribe...

I'm rooting for her!!! For her username and her response to DharmaHelper.

#22

That would be awesome if a first timer won.

I hope the people who aren't in the thread yet show up. I don't know why Epi hasn't posted - he's been posting all afternoon in the other game.

#23

I would legit try to get rid of DH, if he would keep playing like this. Geez. You can tell he's been itching to get back in the saddle for the past year.

#24

I think the only people who will even be able to kowtow to DH will be the people in his own tribe. I mean, it looks like they are the only ones he could vote for.

#25

Well dang, Soneji came on the site but didn't say anything in the thread. I wonder if he decided not to play.

#26

Soneji tends to be a pretty quiet player, especially early in games. I figure he'll get involved eventually.

#27

juliets wrote:Well dang, Soneji came on the site but didn't say anything in the thread. I wonder if he decided not to play.

He still hasn't checked either of his PMs- his role card or my reminder that he has a rolecard.

#28

Congrats Scotty on your double Sockys win!!

#29

lol, DH calls leg 3 without even talking to the rest of the team about who should do what. The other team had a good idea about checking people's energy levels before deciding who should do what.

#30

Wow SVS scores big in her ball throwing! Only one more hoop to get.

#31

juliets wrote:Wow SVS scores big in her ball throwing! Only one more hoop to get.

When playtesting this, I didn't even think to just shoot those light balls. It's a slight loophole, and I'll leave it to these smart people to exploit them. Good work there! I should have set a limit on light balls, but oh well.
Lol the other team is not even contemplating that. Hilarious.

Also, DH has been working on his water puzzle for 42 minutes now and says it's impossible.

Those are 42 real minutes being added to the challenge, so it's almost as if nothing else matters

#32

Oh wow he passed. It will be interesting to see if the other team can get it.

#33

juliets wrote:Oh wow he passed. It will be interesting to see if the other team can get it.

Lol.

What's funny is that LC has been right on money already with his prediction:

Long Con wrote:The water puzzle may be some variation of the classic "make 4 L from a 3 L and a 5 L jug".

That's exactly what the water puzzle is!

#34

Scotty, do you want me to let the technical mods know to fix the players ability to edit their posts in the tribe thread? They shouldn't be able to do that as far as I know.

#35

juliets wrote:Scotty, do you want me to let the technical mods know to fix the players ability to edit their posts in the tribe thread? They shouldn't be able to do that as far as I know.

Sure, I just let Marmot know as well. Dunno why that's happening.

#36

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:Scotty, do you want me to let the technical mods know to fix the players ability to edit their posts in the tribe thread? They shouldn't be able to do that as far as I know.
Sure, I just let Marmot know as well. Dunno why that's happening.

Oh, marmot is a technical mod so he'll fix it.

#37

Oh man, DH caught my slip up. Both tribes are blending together for me already ahhhhhh.

#38

Nice save though. Don't know whether they believed it but really it doesn't make that much difference. They don't know what she did which is the important part.

#39

juliets wrote:Nice save though. Don't know whether they believed it but really it doesn't make that much difference. They don't know what she did which is the important part.

At this point, it's all about if the puzzle solver takes more than 50 minutes to solve the puzzle lol

I posed that puzzle to family members and the longest time was 11 minutes.

#40

Oh did someone on the team solve it in 50 minutes?

#41

juliets wrote:Oh did someone on the team solve it in 50 minutes?

No. DH took 44 minutes and gave up. He was confused by the question. I feel bad he didn't understand it, but I can't do anything about that. I know it works and I know the directions are there.

#42

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:Oh did someone on the team solve it in 50 minutes?
No. DH took 44 minutes and gave up. He was confused by the question. I feel bad he didn't understand it, but I can't do anything about that. I know it works and I know the directions are there.

Yeah if you tested it on people you know it's fine. They really should have let speedchuck try it. Golden won't be on till this afternoon and he'll be at work where it may be hard to get the focused time necessary.

Edit: lol I don't think Epi read the directions about #4.

#43

juliets wrote:
Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:Oh did someone on the team solve it in 50 minutes?
No. DH took 44 minutes and gave up. He was confused by the question. I feel bad he didn't understand it, but I can't do anything about that. I know it works and I know the directions are there.
Yeah if you tested it on people you know it's fine. They really should have let speedchuck try it. Golden won't be on till this afternoon and he'll be at work where it may be hard to get the focused time necessary.

Edit: lol I don't think Epi read the directions about #4.

Yeah the thing is- DH is gonna DH. But more importantly, he has a puzzle solving advantage and still didn't finish

#44

Scotty DH is saying it's not his fault he didn't solve the puzzle. What's he talking about?

#45

Man, this game is out of control with people requesting actions all over the place! Poor Scotty.

#46

Yup, Scotty is killing it as a host. This is not an easy game to keep up with!

#47

juliets wrote:Man, this game is out of control with people requesting actions all over the place! Poor Scotty.

I could have specified better in the Original rules. Meh. I'm learning as I go. First time hosting and all that.

juliets wrote:Scotty DH is saying it's not his fault he didn't solve the puzzle. What's he talking about?

About 20 minutes in, he asked for clarification of the rules of the puzzle, and was asking certain questions that I gave him clarity to, which turned out to confuse him even more. I dunno. Golden finished the puzzle in 9 minutes, so

Meanwhile, DF has been sitting with the puzzle now for over an hour and counting

#48

Scotty does Faraday have the puzzle? Or did he solve it?

#49

juliets wrote:Scotty does Faraday have the puzzle? Or did he solve it?

He......just got back to me. It took him 2.5 hours or so to solve. I was perfectly clear that the timer started as soon as I sent him the puzzle so it's not like the sense of urgency is lost.

But he will most certainly lose the challenge for his tribe.

#50

Scotty wrote:
juliets wrote:Scotty does Faraday have the puzzle? Or did he solve it?
He......just got back to me. It took him 2.5 hours or so to solve. I was perfectly clear that the timer started as soon as I sent him the puzzle so it's not like the sense of urgency is lost.

But he will most certainly lose the challenge for his tribe.

Oh wow. And I was so sure the other side was going to lose.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous