U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[colonialbob]

10. I will probably not reveal the roles and alignments of the deceased. Haven't decided yet. I might with lynches only.

Just saw this. Janitored kills are bad enough, please don’t leave lynches blind too. It’s what I crave

Lol rip this game if there's no reveals on a random set of roles

Also "rip" as in "rest in potatoes" not as in "rip this game a new one"

Anyway back to saying stuff that won't put me in time out

[Quin]

Time Out is probably a scum role that benefits from civilians breaking the rules. Be on your best behaviour, everyone.

Or, you know, this.

Spoiler: show

[lapluie]

so much jibber jabber about salad tossing & cat paws what is going onnnnnnnnnnn???

hey lapluie. it's day 0 fun!

what or who are you?

A basketball

[lapluie]

Too many overwhelming pages.. pls slow down

[lapluie]

hi [mention]Turnip Head[/mention] I don't think we've met but your name reminds me of the turnip scarecrow from howls moving caste

[Kites]

yawn im still alive. why?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Does anyone know how to fix the time on the poll? It's sort of locked into the time that I originally created it because it goes up in days not hours/minutes and you can't set the time it finishes specifically?

It needs to not be what it is.

I believe you can just increase the number of days for the poll by one if that's your desire. It shouldn't delete votes, though a screenshot before hand would be safe.

If you mean to change the time itself, you cannot. The only way is to eliminate the deadline altogether and then tell us when it will be -- you close it manually when the time comes.

[Spacedaisy]

Join me my brothers and sisters

I’m more of an ass, man.

Spoiler: show

Fixed it.

[lapluie]

yawn im still alive. why?

I'll do the honors

[MacDougall]

I found a cool thing.

[motel room]

So i have a big mac mcvalue meal, what do i do woth it?

[motel room]

I dont know what to make of the 2nd man boob thing. I dont think its a persons character though.

[motel room]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

[wolbre04]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

Because I'm one of the boobs of Steven Tyler, lead singer of aerosmith

[motel room]

I think dunya looked worse at the start with her vs jjj, her reactions were just like jay said. When i read through it first, it being the first significant blow up, i thought some of the names that popped up to say so and so is civ felt likr where the dodgy non drinkers sit. But i need to read through it again whichever page it was. Man typing on my phone is bullshit it takes ages to shit out a sdntence

[motel room]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

Because I'm one of the boobs of Steven Tyler, lead singer of aerosmith

What happems if you find your boob

[wolbre04]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

Because I'm one of the boobs of Steven Tyler, lead singer of aerosmith

What happems if you find your boob

I'm not exactly sure aside from it being part of my list of tasks until I unlock more

[Spacedaisy]

He buys himself a mansiere.

[dunya]

what else you got?

You don't need to concern yourself with that. Do things. You have 150some posts and maybe 15-20% of them feature hunting. The rest are defensive or spam. Go to work and I'll observe.

this post pissed me off a lot last night. won't lie, I had to leave the thread because of it. it still pisses me off.

what pisses me off the most though (well, not the most. THAT post was the most...so maybe second most), is here is jay, throwing all this bullshit my way, setting up a case real nice with the all frills and ribbons and everything else, yet sitting firmly on that fence about me. either I'm bad after all this shade pushing on dunya and you vote for me like Golden did, or you're playing a really dangerous game here. you're not one to case baseless and meaningless suspicion. so do something about it. now. and I will observe your ass when it reacts.

[dunya]

I think dunya looked worse at the start with her vs jjj, her reactions were just like jay said. When i read through it first, it being the first significant blow up, i thought some of the names that popped up to say so and so is civ felt likr where the dodgy non drinkers sit. But i need to read through it again whichever page it was. Man typing on my phone is bullshit it takes ages to shit out a sdntence

what do you think of nutella, specifically, out of this?

[wolbre04]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

[novaselinenever]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

Because I'm one of the boobs of Steven Tyler, lead singer of aerosmith

What happems if you find your boob

I'm not exactly sure aside from it being part of my list of tasks until I unlock more

As of now, finding the other boob is your only task? Also, how do your tasks work?

[novaselinenever]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

Have you ever considered something for support?

[wolbre04]

I went back to how wolee announced it and it seems genuine, i think its a real task. Dunno why he has a singing task too

Because I'm one of the boobs of Steven Tyler, lead singer of aerosmith

What happems if you find your boob

I'm not exactly sure aside from it being part of my list of tasks until I unlock more

As of now, finding the other boob is your only task? Also, how do your tasks work?

I have 3 tasks i can see atm, the rest I unlock once i get through this group, I need to find the boob, sing an aerosmith song, and get someone else to sing or dance to a song (this one doesn't have to be aerosmith). I havent completed any yet so im not sure how they become available once i get through this first group

[wolbre04]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

Have you ever considered something for support?

[wolbre04]

Also I'd like to point out an observation: We still have a small handful of people who really haven't posted at all or very much. I'm not just saying this because last game mafia totally took advantage of lynching these low posters, but I have a feeling that it's either mafia controlling the narrative or town today, not much in between. In my experience hosting people seem to get more complacent with rolling town than mafia and might lack the enthusiasm to come out charging

[motel room]

I think dunya looked worse at the start with her vs jjj, her reactions were just like jay said. When i read through it first, it being the first significant blow up, i thought some of the names that popped up to say so and so is civ felt likr where the dodgy non drinkers sit. But i need to read through it again whichever page it was. Man typing on my phone is bullshit it takes ages to shit out a sdntence

what do you think of nutella, specifically, out of this?

Ive barely noticed nutella. Whats the scoop there?

[Golden]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

Have you ever considered something for support?

You have offended every decent New Zealander by picturing SBW there...

I’ll have to counter it with some actual rugby players.

[MacDougall]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

Have you ever considered something for support?

Wolbre has received 1 Happy Meal.

[dunya]

I think nutella is bad, here are some reasons why.

1. she came in innocent enough and made an intro post like the rest of us. she did choose gross runny eggs with salmonella, but that's beyond the point. the first opportunity nutella got was to throw shade at me when jay was reacting to my provoking.

dunya is scum.

and I thought you were one of the few who could town-read me accurately. I'm kinda upset. Lizzy too.

oh well. it's not meant to be.

hey we all know what happened in fire emblem. you really can't make that argument anymore

2. nutella has a tendency when scum to observe the thread and when things get lit (esp between 2 civs), she'll chip in. she did this in FE and I was scum with her for whatever duration I played and observed her till end game. it's a strategy and it strangely works, because in the heat of an argument, most people don't pay attention to you, but the quips you make add fuel to the fire. see above. she didn't want me to end the argument and added her fuel by reminding Jay how I flew under his radar in FE. she's basically provoking him into reading me as possible scum without actually saying it. calculated and scheming.

maybe jay and dunya are both scum, who knows?? meta is twisted yo

3. scum nutella also has a tendency to not harp on one person and have no definite reads on them. civ nutella is organically paranoid, with a healthy dose of tinfoil. scum nutella tries to find posts that wouldn't be deemed scummy if she looks into them and also scum reads them. she doesn't build cases of her own accord on someone with no suspicion. she would love to see a high poster like me, Jay or Sloonei or Golden (if he's not on her team), to get lynched early on. see above. she also adds little quips like "yo" "ayy" and similar when she is scum and trying to downplay something.

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

4. fake. she didn't think about shit. how did dunya come off as town and jay looked less town than me? it's all mumble mumble words. she probably decided N1 to kill me if I'm not lynched so what better way to do that when she town reads me.

5. she over uses the smiley when she's scum. FE was fulllllll of that shit. I can't unsee it. I'm looking straight into a scum nutella's eyes.

6. I realize that outlining these things will probably make it harder for me to catch a scum nutella in the future, but that's aight.

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

hahaha. and something else that's funny, cos you only have 10 posts yet, but you also did another little scumtell here within those 10 posts that you were guilty of in The Search for Quin and FE. you're a rotten egg.

sorry what? whatever you're seeing, I'm not scum

7. a little while later nutella calls me scummy. she town read me before, she is apologizing to me here, and a little while later, she is seeing scum dunya which she only saw for 1 phase in FE. she also used the shrug emoji, to appear totally clueless, but it's as fake as her little "hmmmm i think dunya is town and jay isn't" from before.

I am entertaining dunya and Golden as being on opposing mafia teams.

I believe Golden is probably town. He is confident enough that his role only makes sense as town that it probably is, even though it was confirmed randomized -- since it came up town he can't imagine it as a scum role. He could be faking but that's not the Golden we know, you know?

8. JaggedJimmyJay is supposed to be a less of a town read for nutella than me at this point, yet she engages him just fine about Golden. She doesn't mention me at all. she wants to be in Golden's good shoes. another scum tell for nutella is that she tries to buddy by using TMI. she knows Golden isn't on her mafia team (hey, he could still be on the second one, I ain't clearing Golden that easily), so she tells him exactly when she thinks he'd like to hear. Golden is being reasonable, she's parroting what was already said. and if Golden thinks I project emotion and try to manipulate him, how about that ending there "he could be faking it, but that's not the Golden we know, you know?" ---- I almost shed a tear.

A tendency I noticed in dunya's play both in Fire Emblem and Ancient Greece was to speak in absolute terms how a game is constructed (whether its roles or its mechanics) beyond the knowledge a civilian can have or the confidence a civilian should have. Indeed, she was critical of others who considered theories beyond the obvious truth she promoted -- one born of her unique knowledge given her mafia alignments.

Her early stature in this game given Golden's notion of a character submission inspiring a more probable civilian alignment is a suitable parallel. I actually agree with her logic in base terms -- a Mafia game would be in its most proper form, randomized entirely. Mac himself suggested though that this game may be bastardized or otherwise not entirely balanced. There ought to be some room to consider the less obvious or logical possibilities.

dunya's tone overall sounds very much like her mafia game so far.

9. fake as shit. nutella is being as wiffly waffly as she was in FE, she's not provided one solid reason why I'm bad except piggyback on Golden and JJJ. and coupled with everything else up to this point, I'm gonna bet my right and left paws that she is definitely one rotten egg.

10. I made my nutella case. My vote will stay on her. I'll revisit my other scum reads but I'd love people to weigh in on nutella too.

[dunya]

Golden's good shoes.

I meant Golden's good books.

I don't think anyone wants to be inside your shoes. sorry.

[motel room]

Im with the missus now, gonna be social. Comradebob is my pick for quiet scum thus far.

[motel room]

Aerosmith is fucking shithouse btw

[novaselinenever]

I think nutella is bad, here are some reasons why.

1. she came in innocent enough and made an intro post like the rest of us. she did choose gross runny eggs with salmonella, but that's beyond the point. the first opportunity nutella got was to throw shade at me when jay was reacting to my provoking.

dunya is scum.

and I thought you were one of the few who could town-read me accurately. I'm kinda upset. Lizzy too.

oh well. it's not meant to be.

hey we all know what happened in fire emblem. you really can't make that argument anymore

2. nutella has a tendency when scum to observe the thread and when things get lit (esp between 2 civs), she'll chip in. she did this in FE and I was scum with her for whatever duration I played and observed her till end game. it's a strategy and it strangely works, because in the heat of an argument, most people don't pay attention to you, but the quips you make add fuel to the fire. see above. she didn't want me to end the argument and added her fuel by reminding Jay how I flew under his radar in FE. she's basically provoking him into reading me as possible scum without actually saying it. calculated and scheming.

maybe jay and dunya are both scum, who knows?? meta is twisted yo

3. scum nutella also has a tendency to not harp on one person and have no definite reads on them. civ nutella is organically paranoid, with a healthy dose of tinfoil. scum nutella tries to find posts that wouldn't be deemed scummy if she looks into them and also scum reads them. she doesn't build cases of her own accord on someone with no suspicion. she would love to see a high poster like me, Jay or Sloonei or Golden (if he's not on her team), to get lynched early on. see above. she also adds little quips like "yo" "ayy" and similar when she is scum and trying to downplay something.

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

4. fake. she didn't think about shit. how did dunya come off as town and jay looked less town than me? it's all mumble mumble words. she probably decided N1 to kill me if I'm not lynched so what better way to do that when she town reads me.

5. she over uses the smiley when she's scum. FE was fulllllll of that shit. I can't unsee it. I'm looking straight into a scum nutella's eyes.

6. I realize that outlining these things will probably make it harder for me to catch a scum nutella in the future, but that's aight.

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

hahaha. and something else that's funny, cos you only have 10 posts yet, but you also did another little scumtell here within those 10 posts that you were guilty of in The Search for Quin and FE. you're a rotten egg.

sorry what? whatever you're seeing, I'm not scum

7. a little while later nutella calls me scummy. she town read me before, she is apologizing to me here, and a little while later, she is seeing scum dunya which she only saw for 1 phase in FE. she also used the shrug emoji, to appear totally clueless, but it's as fake as her little "hmmmm i think dunya is town and jay isn't" from before.

I am entertaining dunya and Golden as being on opposing mafia teams.

I believe Golden is probably town. He is confident enough that his role only makes sense as town that it probably is, even though it was confirmed randomized -- since it came up town he can't imagine it as a scum role. He could be faking but that's not the Golden we know, you know?

8. JaggedJimmyJay is supposed to be a less of a town read for nutella than me at this point, yet she engages him just fine about Golden. She doesn't mention me at all. she wants to be in Golden's good shoes. another scum tell for nutella is that she tries to buddy by using TMI. she knows Golden isn't on her mafia team (hey, he could still be on the second one, I ain't clearing Golden that easily), so she tells him exactly when she thinks he'd like to hear. Golden is being reasonable, she's parroting what was already said. and if Golden thinks I project emotion and try to manipulate him, how about that ending there "he could be faking it, but that's not the Golden we know, you know?" ---- I almost shed a tear.

A tendency I noticed in dunya's play both in Fire Emblem and Ancient Greece was to speak in absolute terms how a game is constructed (whether its roles or its mechanics) beyond the knowledge a civilian can have or the confidence a civilian should have. Indeed, she was critical of others who considered theories beyond the obvious truth she promoted -- one born of her unique knowledge given her mafia alignments.

Her early stature in this game given Golden's notion of a character submission inspiring a more probable civilian alignment is a suitable parallel. I actually agree with her logic in base terms -- a Mafia game would be in its most proper form, randomized entirely. Mac himself suggested though that this game may be bastardized or otherwise not entirely balanced. There ought to be some room to consider the less obvious or logical possibilities.

dunya's tone overall sounds very much like her mafia game so far.

9. fake as shit. nutella is being as wiffly waffly as she was in FE, she's not provided one solid reason why I'm bad except piggyback on Golden and JJJ. and coupled with everything else up to this point, I'm gonna bet my right and left paws that she is definitely one rotten egg.

10. I made my nutella case. My vote will stay on her. I'll revisit my other scum reads but I'd love people to weigh in on nutella too.

I like this case a lot. But I have a few questions,

2. What made you think that she was provoking him to read you as scum? He already stated that he read you as such, and she was quoting you and not him, with something that is true (you flowing under the radar as scum).

8. How come JJJ should be less of a Town read to her than you? I'm not following. And even if that were the case, what's the problem with her engaging him about other players?

[novaselinenever]

Im with the missus now, gonna be social. Comradebob is my pick for quiet scum thus far.

What about him? You've been quiet yourself.

[wolbre04]

Aerosmith is fucking shithouse btw

I think you're just


and

[dunya]

I like this case a lot. But I have a few questions,

2. What made you think that she was provoking him to read you as scum? He already stated that he read you as such, and she was quoting you and not him, with something that is true (you flowing under the radar as scum).

indirect provocation. Jay makes an accusation to dunya, dunya says "damn jay, I thought you could read town-me better than that", nutella makes a quip about how I shouldn't bring that up after my scum play in FE. regardless of who she was quoting, Jay was going to see it and that's the point.

8. How come JJJ should be less of a Town read to her than you? I'm not following. And even if that were the case, what's the problem with her engaging him about other players?

I don't know how come, but it's what she said and she still hasn't provided anything to back up anything she says:

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

it's not a problem, but to engage him specifically after I called her scummy only to buddy up with another one of my oppositions (Golden) and still not give any read on me when she had me and Jay at opposite sides of the pole, so despite her "town read on me" she switches tactics by trying to get him to discuss stuff about food, and turn the heat down a notch...seeing as Jay also called her sudden reads on us fake, then end it all by agreeing with him, and calling me the scum. yea. not buying it. it's completely forced.

[wolbre04]

I like this case a lot. But I have a few questions,

2. What made you think that she was provoking him to read you as scum? He already stated that he read you as such, and she was quoting you and not him, with something that is true (you flowing under the radar as scum).

indirect provocation. Jay makes an accusation to dunya, dunya says "damn jay, I thought you could read town-me better than that", nutella makes a quip about how I shouldn't bring that up after my scum play in FE. regardless of who she was quoting, Jay was going to see it and that's the point.

8. How come JJJ should be less of a Town read to her than you? I'm not following. And even if that were the case, what's the problem with her engaging him about other players?

I don't know how come, but it's what she said and she still hasn't provided anything to back up anything she says:

Hmm after some thinking/thread development I'm more inclined to think dunya is town and JJJ less so. Still subject to change though.

it's not a problem, but to engage him specifically after I called her scummy only to buddy up with another one of my oppositions (Golden) and still not give any read on me when she had me and Jay at opposite sides of the pole, so despite her "town read on me" she switches tactics by trying to get him to discuss stuff about food, and turn the heat down a notch...seeing as Jay also called her sudden reads on us fake, then end it all by agreeing with him, and calling me the scum. yea. not buying it. it's completely forced.

Where is she in reference to any other scum reads you may have? I presume she's at the bottom because your case seems to be charging out of the gates pretty confidently

[dunya]

yea, I'm revisiting Golden with a fresh mind today and see if I can put myself in his shoes with how he dealt with me yesterday.

I saw bits of Quin defending me today, but that doesn't shake him off my scum reads. I have to catch up on the thread.

and Lile is still on there, but he's been quiet so it's hard to develop reads from there.

I guess I'm most confident about nutella though and that's not bad for Day 1...

[Golden]

Golden's good shoes.

I meant Golden's good books.

I don't think anyone wants to be inside your shoes. sorry.

Sounds sort of kinky.

I like your case on Nutella. What is your experience of her civ meta?

[dunya]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

[dunya]

I like your case on Nutella. What is your experience of her civ meta?

mountains mafia I played with her in (and revisited her iso), and the Fiddler on the Roof game I watched her in.

she was scum in MK, The Search for Quin and FE. I called her out in the first two, and was on the scum team with her in the last.

[dunya]

there's also a burglary I hosted where quin and nutella were scummates. I know it's a completely different format, but some of the same stuff happened.

[Golden]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

[Golden]

Just because I like your Nutella case doesn’t mean I’m ignoring all that projecting you were doing.

[dunya]

Just because I like your Nutella case doesn’t mean I’m ignoring all that projecting you were doing.

ok, dad.

[dunya]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

which one of them where you actually rightly lynched?

[Golden]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

which one of them where you actually rightly lynched?

I cannot recall any game in which I was rightly lynched until everyone else was essentially mechanically cleared. I’m sure there are some, but none of those 4.

[Quin]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

Phenon. AKA my lesser known best mafia performance.

[Golden]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

Phenon. AKA my lesser known best mafia performance.

I wasn’t lynched there either.