Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Marmot]

If we win this game, it's due to an incredibly committed and collaborative team effort by the civilians. Great job civs, let's keep it up!

[G-Man]

I don’t even drink coffee.

What is wrong with you?

Coffee is for mortals. I spent my long nights hosting Chicka Chicka 1, 2, 3 drinking nothing but water. My kidneys are phenomenal.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I wonder if it's as simple as lynch Quin tomorrow, then voile!

Do you have lingering doubts?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I have never consumed a cup of coffee in my life.

[Marmot]

I wonder if it's as simple as lynch Quin tomorrow, then voile!

Do you have lingering doubts?

The only doubt I have is that I don't have any doubts.

[Scotty]

Quin doesn’t mention Colin as far as I can see until day 3, which is quite odd:

Quin, reads list?

GTH, sure.

colin - good
dizzy - bad
eloh - good
epi - good
3j - bad
lap - bad
MP - good
marmot - good
nutella - good
scotty - good

Y'all should give me a four-name POE pool.

Eloh
MP
Dizzy
Epi

Whaddya think of Colin?

He is a person that exists and suspects me for some reason.

“What’s your favorite type of ice cream?”
“Yes, I like ice cream”

DAY 4:

sorry all i'd do more but suddenly sick as a sig dog who still has a mountain of work to do

if someone could link me to some stuff about colin i'd appreciate it

He’s doing the bare minimum to look at Colin here, when colon is up in the poll

I am particularly interested in Dizzy and Colin. They're the most difficult cases to sort given my own preconceptions and also the fact that my own content plays a large role in what I compiled. A less biased perspective would be super.

I had a similar experience when I ISOed Dyslexicon earlier today -- I was expecting them to look mostly town but I came out of it with pretty much no solid reason to town read them (and not much solid reason to scum read them to be fair, but there is a little bit that points me in that direction, including the Gladys stuff).

If you presently had to compile a POE pool of four, who would it be?

You too, Quin, please.

Colin
Charlie
Dizzy
lapluie (she's gonna have an aneurism at this point)

Huh? When did Colin jump into the pool with the others? I missed your transition. Was it all in your head?

Colin is bad and 3J is his teammate.

He continues this newfound suspicion of Colin by also linking JJJ to it. I mean, at this point, it’s almost EoD so why throw this confusion in there?

nah colin is bad guys just wait

Confidence or hubris?

Did something happen at EoD with Quin’s vote? I saw Epi and JJJ having a curfuffle talking about ties when JJJ said “Jesus Christ Quin” but I can’t tell if that was just a response to the tinfoil? Quin said lap changed votes within 2 seconds of close, but I have no real indication if other people were jumping without writing in thread.

NIGHT 4:

My immediate thoughts after the flips is that the most likely scum is Quin. He seemed sure Colin was scum and seemed to have no real emotion or agony over this. I did suspect Jimmeey for being teamed with Marmot (cause I thought Marmot was the scum >_>). In some respect Quin's vote on Colin and the insisting of it being Colin even after the timer was out seems almost too obvious. The way both Colin and Marmot acted made me think we had the wrong lynch. Maybe that was conf bias on my end. I think Jimmeey, Nut and Scotty has a lot going for them to be town. Still I find myself doubting especially Jimmeey and Nut on certain points, and I almost feel bad, cause at least one is town and not unlikely both, so is it worth the doubt? I have more thoughts here that will go more into later. I think my suspicion on Jimmey is rather tinfoily.

---

D5 - 6 town vs 2 scum = 2 chances to hit scum.

It was pretty damn obvious he was bad once the poll ended. Colin knows what a legacy post is. How many did we get? None. How many times did Colin pretend not to know what a legacy post was? One.

It was not obvious to me. I didn't catch that he pretended not to know what a legacy post was. I thought Marmot's read list was just to look good. I mean, conf bias.

Are you saying I pretended to think it was Marmot here or that it was obvious to you?

It was obvious to me Marmot was good, so.

And after lynch, this is his explanation for his Colin bad decision, I think.

Anyway, for someone so mum on Colin and afaict town read him up until Marmot claimed, I see a perspective where bad Quin saw the writing on the wall, and went with the majority to oust Colin. I need to look more closely in his throughline at EoD because it doesn’t seem like he wavered from his approach that Colin was bad at beginning of day, which is a good look I guess.

I’m not done with Quin because I think there’s more to see, but I can currently see a strong avoidance of Colin until he had to confront that possibility that he was getting lynched. His Day 3 interactions leave much to be desired

[Tangrowth]

I don’t even drink coffee.

What is wrong with you?

Coffee is for mortals. I spent my long nights hosting Chicka Chicka 1, 2, 3 drinking nothing but water. My kidneys are phenomenal.

Man, that is crazy. Coffee singlehandedly got me through this PhD.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I wonder if it's as simple as lynch Quin tomorrow, then voile!

Do you have lingering doubts?

The only doubt I have is that I don't have any doubts.

The #2 suspect is probably the most important detail in the game right now, because if Quin ends up the one mislynch, we have to get it right after that. If it's not him, who do you think it is?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Did something happen at EoD with Quin’s vote? I saw Epi and JJJ having a curfuffle talking about ties when JJJ said “Jesus Christ Quin” but I can’t tell if that was just a response to the tinfoil? Quin said lap changed votes within 2 seconds of close, but I have no real indication if other people were jumping without writing in thread.

That remark came when I thought Quin had tied the lynch up at 4-4 with less than a minute remaining (and I wanted to be absolutely certain it didn't end in a tie). I was mistaken though, because it was lapluie who'd placed that vote.

[Marmot]

Least to Most

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
JaggedJimmyJay
Dyslexicon
Scotty
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

I honestly feel it's pretty cut and dry at this point. It's Quin and Colin.

Between the four green folks, Dizzy was, as you stated, the most involved a excited. I feel similarly about Scotty. Nutella and you sit slightly below them, but only by the thinnest of margins.

The only difference I feel between now and this moment is that Jay shifts up above Dizzy.

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
Dyslexicon
Scotty
JaggedJimmyJay
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

That is my order of suspicion right now. It's basically a cointoss between nutella and Scotty though.

[Marmot]

Least to Most

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
Dyslexicon
Scotty
JaggedJimmyJay
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

I honestly feel it's pretty cut and dry at this point. It's Quin and Colin.

Between the four green folks, Dizzy was, as you stated, the most involved a excited. I feel similarly about Scotty. Nutella and you sit slightly below them, but only by the thinnest of margins.

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
JaggedJimmyJay
Dyslexicon
Scotty
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

I edited the wrong rainbow, this is a correct picture of then and now.

[Marmot]

Least to Most

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
Dyslexicon
Scotty
JaggedJimmyJay
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

I honestly feel it's pretty cut and dry at this point. It's Quin and Colin.

Between the four green folks, Dizzy was, as you stated, the most involved a excited. I feel similarly about Scotty. Nutella and you sit slightly below them, but only by the thinnest of margins.

lapluie
Charlie Blackmon
JaggedJimmyJay
Dyslexicon
Scotty
nutella
Quin
ColinIsCool

I edited the wrong rainbow, this is a correct picture of then and now.

GAH!! This is what I want this post to look like.

[Marmot]

Also, Quin called lapluie out for switching her vote around in the Day 3 lynch without saying so.

Quin exhibited this same behavior in the Day 4 lynch. I don't know who else he voted for, but he was on Colin, then moved off, then moved back on. He likely didn't self-vote, so it's possible he had voted for me, which doesn't make sense given his read. Any recollection of where he voted?

[Marmot]

Quin has done no hunting since the lynch of Colin. Another sign of his likely alignment. Considering Quin was the only one who thought I was civilian before Day 4, and voiced his pleasure in his accuracy after the lynch, I'd hope for more from a civilian Quin.

[Scotty]

The more think of reviewing colin’s Interactions with everybody the more I’m just Shruggy McShoulderson. His role is unlynchable until his partner is lynched, so the WIFOM capability is palpable across the board. My biggest qualm with Colin all game is that his reads weren’t really digging into anyone, and thus what does he really think? Just read marmot’s analysis of Colin speaking about Quin, and I don’t feel like I can read his reads as anything more than empty calories. Y’all can take from it what you want, but I think the prize in the pudding is with the things people say about Colin.

[Marmot]

The more think of reviewing colin’s Interactions with everybody the more I’m just Shruggy McShoulderson. His role is unlynchable until his partner is lynched, so the WIFOM capability is palpable across the board. My biggest qualm with Colin all game is that his reads weren’t really digging into anyone, and thus what does he really think? Just read marmot’s analysis of Colin speaking about Quin, and I don’t feel like I can read his reads as anything more than empty calories. Y’all can take from it what you want, but I think the prize in the pudding is with the things people say about Colin.

It was Quin's handling of Colin that bothered me. I didn't get much from Colin's interactions with Quin either.

[Scotty]

Also, Quin called lapluie out for switching her vote around in the Day 3 lynch without saying so.

Quin exhibited this same behavior in the Day 4 lynch. I don't know who else he voted for, but he was on Colin, then moved off, then moved back on. He likely didn't self-vote, so it's possible he had voted for me, which doesn't make sense given his read. Any recollection of where he voted?

How do you know he switched off colin?

A big reason I suspected Quin over the past few days anyway was his self vote on D2 (or 1? I forget) and thinking that could be a signifier of his unlynchability. But that’s obviously not right.

So to go back, does a bad Quin vote for himself as the leading wagon that close to the EoD so nonchalantly?

[Scotty]

Did something happen at EoD with Quin’s vote? I saw Epi and JJJ having a curfuffle talking about ties when JJJ said “Jesus Christ Quin” but I can’t tell if that was just a response to the tinfoil? Quin said lap changed votes within 2 seconds of close, but I have no real indication if other people were jumping without writing in thread.

That remark came when I thought Quin had tied the lynch up at 4-4 with less than a minute remaining (and I wanted to be absolutely certain it didn't end in a tie). I was mistaken though, because it was lapluie who'd placed that vote.

k

[JaggedJimmyJay]

So to go back, does a bad Quin vote for himself as the leading wagon that close to the EoD so nonchalantly?

It's a valid question. The strategy one must attribute to Quin if he is a mafioso is to gamble -- he had the lead in the poll, and gave himself a larger lead with the hopes that it would bear the right appearance and that his voters would scurry off to elsewhere (as they mostly did).

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Quin has done no hunting since the lynch of Colin. Another sign of his likely alignment. Considering Quin was the only one who thought I was civilian before Day 4, and voiced his pleasure in his accuracy after the lynch, I'd hope for more from a civilian Quin.

Close to nothing from nutella as well.

[Scotty]

So to go back, does a bad Quin vote for himself as the leading wagon that close to the EoD so nonchalantly?

It's a valid question. The strategy one must attribute to Quin if he is a mafioso is to gamble -- he had the lead in the poll, and gave himself a larger lead with the hopes that it would bear the right appearance and that his voters would scurry off to elsewhere (as they mostly did).

I don’t know a precedent for that, and I just don’t know if it’s a worthwhile gamble, especially if you just lost your partner D1.

That was D2, then, right? When he did that?

[Marmot]

Oh, Quin changed to Colin.

Right... now I'm thinking we should vote for marmot

[mention]Scotty[/mention] This post here.

Although in reality, Quin might not have voted yet at this point.

[Marmot]

Quin has done no hunting since the lynch of Colin. Another sign of his likely alignment. Considering Quin was the only one who thought I was civilian before Day 4, and voiced his pleasure in his accuracy after the lynch, I'd hope for more from a civilian Quin.

Close to nothing from nutella as well.

Good point. She can stay right where she's at in my rainbow.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

That was D2, then, right? When he did that?

Yes.

[Scotty]

Oh, Quin changed to Colin.

Right... now I'm thinking we should vote for marmot

@Scotty This post here.

Although in reality, Quin might not have voted yet at this point.

Huh. Yeah, I just looked through Quin’s iso and nowhere does he ever say where he voted. Slightly annoying. He could have never voted until like 9p.

That’s slightly unsettling. He said he was going to vote within his PoE pool at beginning of day, and may have waited until when he saw the hammer was coming down on Colin to finish it off

[nutella]

Not hunting? Guys I've already concluded via poe that it's Quin. Ive done what I can and I'm busy irl

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Not hunting? Guys I've already concluded via poe that it's Quin. Ive done what I can and I'm busy irl

That's fine, but for the moment you're in my POE for reasons beyond just a quiet Night 4. If it isn't Quin, who's your first alternate?

[nutella]

Not hunting? Guys I've already concluded via poe that it's Quin. Ive done what I can and I'm busy irl

That's fine, but for the moment you're in my POE for reasons beyond just a quiet Night 4. If it isn't Quin, who's your first alternate?

I'm pretty dang sure it's Quin but if I absolutely had to pick a backup probably Dizzy

[Scotty]

I find Scotty's case pretty gross actually. I don't recognize myself in the narrative he paints at all. Maybe I'm OMGUSing. Would appreciate opinions on this. Also will go through a Scotty ISO at some point.

I read your response, and it reminds me of your responses to me earlier in the game. You don't care for cases against you if you don't feel they are well-conceived. Instead of stuffing myself into that two-way fountain of bias, how about you just review the interactive analysis I just posted and see how you feel about that (and/or compile your own)?

That question sounds snotty, but I don't mean for it to. I don't know how to make it sound friendly.

I get it. I DO feel super icky about the case. It felt constructed to point out bad things and take issue with things, finding a reason to call me scum with Colin.

And yeah, I will do that. But I'm going to wait for a bit so I have fresher eyes. I do get upset when players put poop on my posts and throws them on me.

lol well ya, I was looking at you they the lens that you’re bad and on a team with Colin. Sorry bout it!

I would expect you to do the same when you iso me

[Scotty]

Dys, I see you response to my posts and I’ll respond when I’m not at work and have patience to color respond. Phone posting with that shit sucks watermelon flavored donkey dick

[Scotty]

Ima look at nutella next. right now, I’m quite unsure in a battle with Quin and dys. I’m having trouble with quin’s self vote and would like other opinions on whether or not he would do that as bad. Is the gamble worth it?

[Quin]

Oh boy.

[lapluie]

[Marmot]

[wolbre04]

win for me pls town

[Dyslexicon]

I can't be around much before phase change, but I'm not going to be killed anyway. Most scummy thing I've seen is Jimmey not drinking coffee though. I'm offended. : p

[Dyslexicon]

I find Scotty's case pretty gross actually. I don't recognize myself in the narrative he paints at all. Maybe I'm OMGUSing. Would appreciate opinions on this. Also will go through a Scotty ISO at some point.

I read your response, and it reminds me of your responses to me earlier in the game. You don't care for cases against you if you don't feel they are well-conceived. Instead of stuffing myself into that two-way fountain of bias, how about you just review the interactive analysis I just posted and see how you feel about that (and/or compile your own)?

That question sounds snotty, but I don't mean for it to. I don't know how to make it sound friendly.

I get it. I DO feel super icky about the case. It felt constructed to point out bad things and take issue with things, finding a reason to call me scum with Colin.

And yeah, I will do that. But I'm going to wait for a bit so I have fresher eyes. I do get upset when players put poop on my posts and throws them on me.

lol well ya, I was looking at you they the lens that you’re bad and on a team with Colin. Sorry bout it!

I would expect you to do the same when you iso me

No? I will try to stay as neutral as possible and go through the experience of reading and see how it comes across to me. Which is exactly why I wanted to wait to a moment where I was not pursing my lips like Miranda Priestly. But ok, I hear you.

[ColinIsCool]

I don’t even drink coffee.

What is wrong with you?

I have a weird thing about feeling dependent on everyday substances (with the exception of alcohol lol) so I stay away from coffee, pre-workout supplements, etc. I’ll have some if I didn’t sleep a lot the night before but that’s it

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I have a weird thing about feeling dependent on everyday substances

Agreed. I hardly drink alcohol either.

I'm addicted to chocolate though.

[Marmot]

Does mafia count as an everyday substance?

[Scotty]

Does mafia count as an everyday substance?

The only prescription is to cold turkey it








And more cowbell

[Quin]

Colin is bad and 3J is his teammate.

After the lynch all went down, I disagree strongly with this possibility.

You mean like when 3J put you in the lead by trying a CFD on me at the last minute?

[Quin]

Sorry Q, bussing just didn't work out for you in the end. Your Choutas looks kept you safe for a while but it's over now.

Oh gee, I can't wait to prove you wrong.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Colin is bad and 3J is his teammate.

After the lynch all went down, I disagree strongly with this possibility.

You mean like when 3J put you in the lead by trying a CFD on me at the last minute?

What’s your point?

[Quin]

Colin is bad and 3J is his teammate.

After the lynch all went down, I disagree strongly with this possibility.

You mean like when 3J put you in the lead by trying a CFD on me at the last minute?

What’s your point?

You tried to save Colin.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

You tried to save Colin.

After I made him lynchable in the first place, and before I voted for him again?

No.

[Quin]

You tried to save Colin.

After I made him lynchable in the first place, and before I voted for him again?

No.

He's also unlynchable so you can easily risk the bussing. But you'd obviously prefer not to.

Revoting is irrelevant. Yours looks the worst to me.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

He's also unlynchable so you can easily risk the bussing. But you'd obviously prefer not to.

Revoting is irrelevant. Yours looks the worst to me.

Have you read anything that happened on Day 4 beyond people giving you shit?

[Quin]

He's also unlynchable so you can easily risk the bussing. But you'd obviously prefer not to.

Revoting is irrelevant. Yours looks the worst to me.

Have you read anything that happened on Day 4 beyond people giving you shit?

Yes.

Drop the "Quin is self-obsessed" shit.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

He's also unlynchable so you can easily risk the bussing. But you'd obviously prefer not to.

Revoting is irrelevant. Yours looks the worst to me.

Have you read anything that happened on Day 4 beyond people giving you shit?

Yes.

Drop the "Quin is self-obsessed" shit.

I'll drop it when you cease to exhibit it. Even now your gripe is centered upon a vote I placed for you.