Mafia: A World Asunder - GAME THREAD [Day 13]

[DharmaHelper]

Hmmmm

[sabie12]

nova has no posts according to the front page, but I know that's not true.

From what I remember nova had a couple posts saying he thought a couple people were bad and then one or two other things that didnt say much. He seems sketchy enough so far with his voting but lack of posting that I can definitely see why people are going in that direction. He was in the last game I played and didnt participate there either. Is that a thing he always does or?


I'm off to go try playing keyforge with some friends may be not around much for EOD stuff.

[colonialbob]

Ugh so office Christmas party and I find out apparently there's a nova wagon now? Did I miss something?

[G-Man]

Karaoke Karl says...

“Hello Darkness, my old friend.
I’ve come to talk with you again...”

[Jackofhearts2005]

Ugh so office Christmas party and I find out apparently there's a nova wagon now? Did I miss something?

Nova has posted like twice and only Mac has been darknessed that we know of so like maybe he’s the Darkness.

[Kylemii]

Oh and someone tried to kill me last night, they failed. Drunken Epi said he was trying to kill someone I assume it was me. The same person who I called out and said if he was alive to long should be lynched. Just gonna throw that out there.

If this is true why doesn't the Night Post mention a failed kill attempt on you?

if everything we've been told and everything we're assuming is true is true, and also DDL killed nutella, then DDL is one of the following, ranked from most civ to least civ:

savage pixie: i think this role is the most likely of these to be civ, since it can identify corpses.

Sakana Sashimi: i think this is probably an indie role since their kill count was increased for balance purposes, this possibility only applies if nutella died in the water

Dark Woshipper: DDL himself described this role as a probable hostile indie role, and it seems apt, since

a member of the mafia who just happened to carry out the kill on nutella, if Turnip Head was the one killed by the mafia then that makes this one obsolete.

i don't think i'd consider DDL an immediate priority for lynching specifically unless he's mafia, the Dark Worshipper does look dangerous and would be good to be rid of sooner or later for sure, but sakana sashimi can basically only kill people who decide to go swimming for some reason, and savage pixie has clear posititve utility.

Why would the Savage Pixie, if civ, use their one time kill on nutella Night 1?

i don't believe the savage pixie would do that.

nutella was far from a strong suspect of anyone

[Kylemii]

ok talk to me about sig,

I got bad news if this was directed at me lol. I don't have much to say RE: Sig

all of my questions are just cries for help directed at the universe in general

i've never understood anything in my entire life, and i never will

Did you get darknessed too?

this is who i am, dad. it's not a phase.

[timmer]

Just got home. Moved my vote over to sig. I have no reason not to trust Jack's info, but I'm going to cook dinner and think about thur case on him vs the darkness case on nova. Back in a bit.

[speedchuck]

Hmm

That wagon grew like, really quickly. I didn't think my reasoning was that good.

Tie meta anyone?

[timmer]

What's a tie meta?

[speedchuck]

What's a tie meta?

It's where we force the lynch to a tie for the lolz and then crazy things happen.

A joke, mostly.

[speedchuck]

I want both of these people lynched for completely different reasons. Sig is more likely actual scum. Nova is more likely darkness, though that might be angleshooting.

But...

I have my win con. Maybe I should vote Sig? :P

[LoRab]

On the topic of savage pixie: Why think that they are civ? I've seen corpse checker more often as a mafia role than a civ role. That just is my anecdotal evidence. But I don't see that as a necessarily civ role.

[Dana]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

[colonialbob]

ok talk to me about sig,

I got bad news if this was directed at me lol. I don't have much to say RE: Sig

all of my questions are just cries for help directed at the universe in general

i've never understood anything in my entire life, and i never will

Did you get darknessed too?

this is who i am, dad. it's not a phase.

You sure do have a lot of dads

[colonialbob]

Tie meta anyone?

Cfd speedchuck

[colonialbob]

Somebody lay out like a two sentence case for why sig please

[Kylemii]

[mention]Sloonei[/mention] may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

[Enrique]

@Sloonei may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

He's sig's teammate.

[Kylemii]

i see the case/reasoning for nova being the darkness/silencer or whatever, could someone summarize the case on sig for me, please

[colonialbob]

i see the case/reasoning for nova being the darkness/silencer or whatever, could someone summarize the case on sig for me, please

Jinx

[Kylemii]

On the topic of savage pixie: Why think that they are civ? I've seen corpse checker more often as a mafia role than a civ role. That just is my anecdotal evidence. But I don't see that as a necessarily civ role.

it's certainly possible that the savage pixie is mafia aligned or even indie, it just seems like the role that would fit most naturally into a civ role out of the 4 that i listed, but like whoever it was said, the intent/results of the kill in question is the more important thing

[Kylemii]

You sure do have a lot of dads

the more fathers i accumulate, the more powerful i become

[Sorsha]

I really don’t want to mess with a tie. I’ve nothing against a lynch of either of these two. I guess I like the speculation about nova more than the case on sig but I don’t know if I’ll vote to tip it that way....

[timmer]

I really don’t want to mess with a tie. I’ve nothing against a lynch of either of these two. I guess I like the speculation about nova more than the case on sig but I don’t know if I’ll vote to tip it that way....

Nothing against... I guess... I don't know...

I kind of think you do know that you won't mess with the tie, so why feign indecisiveness?

[timmer]

sig is actually confirmed town if you read the thread but ok

Just reading, maybe it'll come up, but does this get explained?

[timmer]

sig is actually confirmed town if you read the thread but ok

I read the thread...most of it. Which post are you talking about?

i forgot

Never mind.

[Epignosis]

sig is actually confirmed town if you read the thread but ok

Just reading, maybe it'll come up, but does this get explained?

Nothing gets explained ever. We're all...

...in the dark.

Or just Mac is.

[DharmaHelper]

Lol an 8-8 tie to protect an inactive yall are wild.

[speedchuck]

@Sloonei may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

He's sig's teammate.

[timmer]

So while I get the nova could be the darkness angle, couldn't nova also be the public silencing role, which I don't think ever happened?

And couldn't someone like sorsha with 14 posts in 11 days also be the darkness?

And what about Dana?

I would rather try for a baddie than a darkness when I can see several candidates for that.

[Epignosis]

So while I get the nova could be the darkness angle, couldn't nova also be the public silencing role, which I don't think ever happened?

And couldn't someone like sorsha with 14 posts in 11 days also be the darkness?

And what about Dana?

I would rather try for a baddie than a darkness when I can see several candidates for that.

Is nova precluded from being mafia in your mind?

[S~V~S]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

[DharmaHelper]

Uh oh uh oh

[timmer]

Not at all, but an absent player can be anything.

[S~V~S]

@Sloonei may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

He's sig's teammate.

No he's not.

[timmer]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

Good point, this has even more disclaimers and qualifiers than sorsha's...

[Epignosis]

@Sloonei may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

He's sig's teammate.

No he's not.

Who is "he?"

[Dana]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

Oooh boy I love sirens!

[timmer]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

Oooh boy I love sirens!

You, uhm.... get what she's saying here, right?

[Sorsha]

I really don’t want to mess with a tie. I’ve nothing against a lynch of either of these two. I guess I like the speculation about nova more than the case on sig but I don’t know if I’ll vote to tip it that way....

Nothing against... I guess... I don't know...

I kind of think you do know that you won't mess with the tie, so why feign indecisiveness?

Not feigning.

[Sorsha]

I really don’t want to mess with a tie. I’ve nothing against a lynch of either of these two. I guess I like the speculation about nova more than the case on sig but I don’t know if I’ll vote to tip it that way....

Nothing against... I guess... I don't know...

I kind of think you do know that you won't mess with the tie, so why feign indecisiveness?

Not feigning.

[Enrique]

Lol an 8-8 tie to protect an inactive yall are wild.

sig had 7 votes when nova had 0, who is being protected?

[Dana]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

Oooh boy I love sirens!

You, uhm.... get what she's saying here, right?

Yes I think, that it's alarming? But idk I'm not the best at this game and I hate having to vote on murdering people so I'm just trying my best here. I didn't like people voting for Nova host because they happened to show up around the same time as the darkness, I feel like there's so many other things that could be going on. I voted sig because I think it makes more sense than a last minute Nova lynch for something that could be entirely unrelated.

[DharmaHelper]

[Enrique]

@Sloonei may i have your updated thoughts on DDL, please? it's all i want for christmas

He's sig's teammate.

No he's not.

Who is "he?"

Dragon D. Luffy.

[Sorsha]

Voted nova. Heading to work so I don’t know if I’ll be able to check the thread before the day ends

[timmer]

Lol an 8-8 tie to protect an inactive yall are wild.

sig had 7 votes when nova had 0, who is being protected?

Is that true? Yeah that's pretty damning.

[timmer]

I'm not quite sure how I feel about lynching Nova, that seemed like it happened really fast and I don't entirely understand all this darkness stuff. I'm gonna [VOTE: sig] aubergine for now even though I don't really like that I'll be causing a tie but there is still some time left so I might change my mind once I catch up a little further.

Ding ding ding ding ding

Oooh boy I love sirens!

You, uhm.... get what she's saying here, right?

Yes I think, that it's alarming? But idk I'm not the best at this game and I hate having to vote on murdering people so I'm just trying my best here. I didn't like people voting for Nova host because they happened to show up around the same time as the darkness, I feel like there's so many other things that could be going on. I voted sig because I think it makes more sense than a last minute Nova lynch for something that could be entirely unrelated.

To be fair, "voting to murder people" despite the weird word choice, is literally how the game works, but I get you, coming in when there is a tie isn't fun.

[Enrique]

Lol an 8-8 tie to protect an inactive yall are wild.

sig had 7 votes when nova had 0, who is being protected?

Is that true? Yeah that's pretty damning.

It might have been 6 (I think you and Dana were the latest, I guess after the nova thing took off). Maybe nova had a vote, idk, but the point stands.