Vanilla Mafia - [MELTED]

[JaggedJimmyJay]

ok im shouldnt make excuses but im still going to

your poll system is broken, very broken
thought it was majority lynch

uh
and thats it

I started playing without polls. I’ve played with automated counters. I’ve been all over the Internet for this silly game.

I think the poll is the best.

[reywaS]

fun fact i tried to switch my vote to epig when i saw he vote me and i knew that he was scum then...but it was at 8:06 and too late

[ColinIsCool]

Epignosis
1
9%
Voters: novaselinenever

Lunalee
1
9%
Voters: reywaS

MafiaMenace
0
No votes
Voters: None

novaselinenever
0
No votes
Voters: None

nutella
0
No votes
Voters: None

reywaS
4
36%
Voters: MafiaMenace, nutella, Epignosis, Lunalee

No Lynch
0
No votes
Voters: None

Eleanor Shellstrop (host/mod/non)
5
45%
Voters: Sloonei, sprityo, JaggedJimmyJay, ColinIsCool, G-Man

[MafiaMenace]

right now im townreading epi, but both epi and nutella created the whole "literally" debate

so i would like to say there can only be one scum in {nutella, epi}
if nutella flips civi then the next one from there would be epi

so you've already decided to lynch me tomorrow? I'd love to convince you otherwise :disappoint:

ive learned to stick with my guns
lots of shit happens when i dont

and many, many times ive let scum out of my grasps a minute too early

im not making excuses as to why the town lost tbh
its for my bad performance

[reywaS]

fun game regardless of outcome. Glad to be back, homies

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Good game bad freezer contents. Needless to say I would have done some things differently here, but that’s why you made me dead.

[ColinIsCool]

fun game regardless of outcome. Glad to be back, homies

Your commitment to the schtick was admirable.

[G-Man]

Looks like I was right about Nutella from Day 1. Epi had me fleeced though.

All my posts started with the letter L this game.

[Epignosis]

right now im townreading epi, but both epi and nutella created the whole "literally" debate

so i would like to say there can only be one scum in {nutella, epi}
if nutella flips civi then the next one from there would be epi

so you've already decided to lynch me tomorrow? I'd love to convince you otherwise

ive learned to stick with my guns
lots of shit happens when i dont

and many, many times ive let scum out of my grasps a minute too early

im not making excuses as to why the town lost tbh
its for my bad performance

I don't think you had a bad performance. I think you had a good performance. The things I said about you? All true. I think you have raw Mafia talent, and I think your biggest disadvantage was being unfamiliar with the personalities and M.O.s around here.

[Epignosis]

Looks like I was right about Nutella from Day 1. Epi had me fleeced though.

All my posts started with the letter L this game.

Loser.

[ColinIsCool]

right now im townreading epi, but both epi and nutella created the whole "literally" debate

so i would like to say there can only be one scum in {nutella, epi}
if nutella flips civi then the next one from there would be epi

so you've already decided to lynch me tomorrow? I'd love to convince you otherwise

ive learned to stick with my guns
lots of shit happens when i dont

and many, many times ive let scum out of my grasps a minute too early

im not making excuses as to why the town lost tbh
its for my bad performance

I think you did well! There's just a bit of an experience gap since you're relatively new-ish to the game and our scum tend to be especially devious, but you ought to keep playing here.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Go Chiefs

[MafiaMenace]

right now im townreading epi, but both epi and nutella created the whole "literally" debate

so i would like to say there can only be one scum in {nutella, epi}
if nutella flips civi then the next one from there would be epi

so you've already decided to lynch me tomorrow? I'd love to convince you otherwise :disappoint:

ive learned to stick with my guns
lots of shit happens when i dont

and many, many times ive let scum out of my grasps a minute too early

im not making excuses as to why the town lost tbh
its for my bad performance

I don't think you had a bad performance. I think you had a good performance. The things I said about you? All true. I think you have raw Mafia talent, and I think your biggest disadvantage was being unfamiliar with the personalities and M.O.s around here.

no thats an advantage
i probably wouldntve read nutella the way i did if so

but still

i was right
about shit going wrong when i dont listen to my gut
all the fucking time

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Menace and WaywardSon, it was a pleasure to have you both aboard. I hope you play with us again soon.

[ColinIsCool]

Go Chiefs

I promise the hold-up in the endgame post had nothing to do with that game, but I will also admit I am very nervous right now.

[nutella]

[mention]Sloonei[/mention] did that pocket feel nice and cold

[nutella]

Unfortunately I can usually depend on sloonei to stand up for me when I'm town, now he'll never trust me again

[Epignosis]

Go Chiefs

I'm all about some Chiefs. I hope Reid gets the big win.

[Epignosis]

Menace and WaywardSon, it was a pleasure to have you both aboard. I hope you play with us again soon.

Absolutely.

[nutella]

Looks like I was right about Nutella from Day 1. Epi had me fleeced though.

All my posts started with the letter L this game.

[nutella]

HOly fuck they really all do that is wild you absolute madman

[novaselinenever]

Looks like I was right about Nutella from Day 1. Epi had me fleeced though.

All my posts started with the letter L this game.

My bad for lynching you

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Biggest fingerwag goes to the general disinterest in a no lynch

[Epignosis]

Biggest fingerwag goes to the general disinterest in a no lynch

Precisely- I wanted someone lynched, even if it was one of us.

[nutella]

menace, you played a really strong town game. I think you absolutely could have won if sloonei hadn't been so confident about me hahah

[nutella]

but also yeah I think jay is right about the no lynch

[G-Man]

HOly fuck they really all do that is wild you absolute madman

It’s part of an ongoing series of posting gimmicks. I think I play too infrequently for it to have been noticed yet.

[Sloonei]

Unfortunately I can usually depend on sloonei to stand up for me when I'm town, now he'll never trust me again

[Sloonei]

I can also count on you to tinfoil me in every game. That and the sprit lynch were the reasons I trusted you.

[Sloonei]

Go Pats

[sprityo]

right now im townreading epi, but both epi and nutella created the whole "literally" debate

so i would like to say there can only be one scum in {nutella, epi}
if nutella flips civi then the next one from there would be epi

so you've already decided to lynch me tomorrow? I'd love to convince you otherwise

ive learned to stick with my guns
lots of shit happens when i dont

and many, many times ive let scum out of my grasps a minute too early

im not making excuses as to why the town lost tbh
its for my bad performance

you did well in the face of an adversary as monumental as Skeletor

[sprityo]

Biggest fingerwag goes to the general disinterest in a no lynch

oh yeah, they shouldve definitely gone for the no lynch

[sprityo]

I can also count on you to tinfoil me in every game. That and the sprit lynch were the reasons I trusted you.

i can always count on sloonei to over analyze me doing absolute nonsense

[Sloonei]

I can also count on you to tinfoil me in every game. That and the sprit lynch were the reasons I trusted you.

i can always count on sloonei to over analyze me doing absolute nonsense

Gotta start somewhere

[Sloonei]

I did start to doubt nutella when I died instead of her, but like I was dead so well played.

[Sloonei]

Also this was a fun little game, thank you Colin. Pure vanilla setups are a rare treat. [mention]MafiaMenace[/mention] I hope to see you around here some more. (that’s a non-alcoholic beer, of course), though this was probably my last game until the summer.

Most importantly, I’m glad we got an answer to my melting question.

[speedchuck]

Good game, guys! Easy to moderate, haha.

Hope [mention]MafiaMenace[/mention] sticks around, I want to play with him!

[G-Man]

Looks like I just need to go back to supporting an Epi lynch every game again. Thanks for a simple, back-to-basics game, Colin, even if it did reinforce the fact that I still suck as a civvie.

[Lunalee]

Good game guys, sorry I didn't do more to help us win. I'm surprised I got scum right in my GTH. I should have stuck with it. :P

Endgame

With the ice cream cartons culled, the Frozen Fiends were able to make their final strike ...

Spoiler: show

MafiaMenace was overpowered by the Frozen Fiends. He was Mint Chocolate Chip, a vanilla civilian.

Spoiler: show

Lunalee was overpowered by the Frozen Fiends. She was Elf Trash, a vanilla civilian.

Spoiler: show

novaselinenever was overpowered by the Frozen Fiends. He was Rocky Road, a vanilla civilian.

Congratulations to Epignosis (Bag of Frozen Vegetables), nutella (The Last Orange Popsicle), and sprityo, the mafia, for their victory.

luna:

Spoiler: show

[VOTE: G-Man] aubergine

...you got a reason to go with this?

towny post considering gman was town
i read the tone of this post as not knowing gmans alignment either, but still curious as to the reasons for the vote

I looked over the sprityo interactions. I don't feel like posting everything, but here's a road map:

Good looks: Sloonei, nutella, novaselinenever

Meh: Epignosis, MafiaMenace, reywaS, Spacedaisy

Icky: G-Man

^This is something to note. But Jay could have been killed for being wrong, so we would pursue the wrong people.

feels like an attempt on framing gman, follows this post up with a vote on him
experienced mafia players would know not to do that, it would lead nowhere

[VOTE: Nova] aubergine

Actually the way he and Menace are quick to vote G-man for his mis-vote yesterday makes them both look like opportunistic scum.

gives the feeling of town being out of the loop, since a few posts after this luna found slooneis spirit/gman interactions wall
counterwagonning me/nova for voting gman does nothing to help luna if she was mafia, especially since gman is town

@MafiaMenace What made you switch your vote from G-man to Sloonei? I don't see where you said anything about it.

even though i was a scumread luna bothered to ask me about my reads rather than sentencing me to death (sloonei too, my read on sloonei has changed as well but ill get into that later)

other points that i cant use a quote as evidence for:
- towny interactions, no indications of being mafia with anyone (if mafia)
- i like their tone in the majority of their posts, it gives across a sense of innocence
- theyre asking the right questions, wanting to acquire information that town needs to know to win

this ends with a townread

luna im curious on your entire readslist
can you share it?

Sloonei
MafiaMenace
reywaS
Nova
Nutella
Epignosis

Spoiler: show

Here's what I'm thinking right now.
Sloonei has looked town from the beginning. He's been doing all the heaving lifting for town with his sprityo interactions posts, and I don't see scum doing that really.
MafiaMenace is looking more town to me because of his efforts in the thread. He seems genuinely concerned about lylo, and nailing down the last scum.
I still don't have a good feeling on reywaS, since it's hard for me to get a good read on them, but Sloonei seems to think they are town despite the posting gimmick, and I'm inclined to trust him on that.
I'm torn on Nova. I've been gut reading them as scum, but then it seems like they are making an actual effort to help town. I really don't know where to put him.
Nutella has been agreeing with my opinions and hasn't suspected me. Town nutella usually tries to get me lynched.
Epi has swung from town to scum in my opinion because of the day 3 lynch. He refused to jump on the G-man wagon, (perhaps because he knew G-man was town and didn't want to be on it) but he then voted MM to just be off G-man. He didn't try to push anyone else. I would expect town Epi to have more of a fit close to EOD if he doesn't agree with the lynch options.

[Sloonei]

I didn’t even realize epi was the other scum. At least I can say I was 1 for 2.

[speedchuck]

Nutella has been agreeing with my opinions and hasn't suspected me. Town nutella usually tries to get me lynched.

This is also my tell for Nutella lately.

[nutella]

Nutella has been agreeing with my opinions and hasn't suspected me. Town nutella usually tries to get me lynched.

This is also my tell for Nutella lately.

What, that I always suspect you? Dude I tried to get you lynched when we were scum together.

[Epignosis]

I didn’t even realize epi was the other scum. At least I can say I was 1 for 2.

What? I was on your naughty list out of the gate.

[Sloonei]

I didn’t even realize epi was the other scum. At least I can say I was 1 for 2.

What? I was on your naughty list out of the gate.

Yes. You were the 1.

[Sloonei]

My one and only

[Epignosis]

Then I guess I don't understand what you mean by "I didn’t even realize epi was the other scum."

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Then I guess I don't understand what you mean by "I didn’t even realize epi was the other scum."

He was focused wholly on having been mistaken about nutella and overlooked that nutella's partner was you -- the player he'd been keen to eliminate. So he can accept that he was 1 for 2 among you.

I am Sloonei.

[Sloonei]

Verily

[sabie12]

Why am I always the first to die? I was only right about epi you could a let me live

[Epignosis]

Why am I always the first to die? I was only right about epi you could a let me live

What I said Night 1 in our chat:

sabie is a safe choice.
JJJ is a smart choice.
Spacedaisy is a saves-her-time choice.
sprityo is a shit-he's-on-our-team choice.