2018 Socky Awards Mafia (FINAL PRESENTATIONS!)

[nutella]

Also I feel like recency bias is not all bad in mafia since people's metas change over time, so if you see behavior that's similar to a recent game in which someone was bad I think it holds more water than saying they look like how they were when bad in a game a year ago.

[Lunalee]

Assuming nutella is town, scum would be VERY LIKELY to see Mac's case, think "bingo! we can frame nutella," night kill Mac, then push for a nutella lynch because why not? It lines up perfectly. Since reywaS and DDL are now after nutella, I would feel very comfortable lynching one of them.

All the sources:

Spoiler: show

Guys how likely it is that a baddie nutella would off Mac to silence him?

WIFOM much?

do you guys seriously want to lynch me for "weasel words" what is it 2016???

I wonder if DDL really believes what he is saying because he has seen me play a lot in the last couple years and he must know that the "lols" etc are a hallmark of my civ style. He's harping a bit too much on this one thing and then going "well whatever her civ and bad metas are too similar so who knows" like he's soft-pushing an easy target but backing off/not taking responsibility

And what is a hallmark of your baddie style, then? Because last I checked you also do all those things when you are bad. Mac is right, you are not that obvious to read.

I'm not soft pushing, I'm putting all possibilities on the table. The way you are acting is perfectly reasonable for a baddie to act.

You say you are always on the fence, which is true, but then you use that as a shield to act the same way as bad and win games because no one wants to lynch "on the fence" nutella anymore.

[VOTE: nutella] aubergine

yeah im gonna vote [VOTE: nutella] aubergine

she gives me the "bad vibes" again this game. I started getting the heebeejeebees from her on day one when she said i was misinterpreting what she said but didnt even try to clarify what she was saying. I would have thought she would have gone ahead and tried to clear it up on the spot. Instead she just ignored me. I feel bad for voting for my long time friend/mafia nemesis SVS and not switching to nutella. And now its just post after post of "this is my civvie meta". OMG that is the worst defense possible....seriously.


BTW I'm totes civ guys. I only make these types of posts that end in "LY" when I'm a civ.


Seriously

[Lunalee]

[VOTE: DragonDLuffy] aubergine
His "how likely is it that nutella killed Mac for WIFOM" post just feels fishy to me. Almost like DDL is trying to push that as the narrative of what happened when it is just as likely that scum would kill Mac to frame nutella.

[nutella]

[VOTE: DragonDLuffy] aubergine
His "how likely is it that nutella killed Mac for WIFOM" post just feels fishy to me. Almost like DDL is trying to push that as the narrative of what happened when it is just as likely that scum would kill Mac to frame nutella.

Ehh I think that post makes him look less likely to be responsible. He wouldn't so overtly call it out as being wifom, right?....or would he lol

But on the whole I think Rey looks worse. He is going after me for very shallow reasons and every new post has a new fake-looking take.

[VOTE: reywas] aubergine

[nutella]

Aw man I thought sloo was voting for Rey too, when did he switch to sab?

[colonialbob]

i trust nutella. the way she responded to that post i made that one time, with the misunderstanding and all that, seemed like it was coming from a place of honest frustration rather than "it'll look good if i act like this"

?

[Lunalee]

[VOTE: DragonDLuffy] aubergine
His "how likely is it that nutella killed Mac for WIFOM" post just feels fishy to me. Almost like DDL is trying to push that as the narrative of what happened when it is just as likely that scum would kill Mac to frame nutella.

Ehh I think that post makes him look less likely to be responsible. He wouldn't so overtly call it out as being wifom, right?....or would he lol

But on the whole I think Rey looks worse. He is going after me for very shallow reasons and every new post has a new fake-looking take.

[VOTE: reywas] aubergine

Yeah, I don't know if DDL would be quite that obvious as scum. I'm switching to reywaS
[VOTE: reywas] aubergine

[sabie12]

Aw man I thought sloo was voting for Rey too, when did he switch to sab?

Awhile ago because I said welcome unless youre bad. I assume it was just to get me to talk more or something because that seems to be his style.

[nutella]

Aw man I thought sloo was voting for Rey too, when did he switch to sab?

Awhile ago because I said welcome unless youre bad. I assume it was just to get me to talk more or something because that seems to be his style.

Right, yeah.

What are your thoughts? On me, reywas, ddl, Luna, sprityo, anyone?

[reywaS]

lol im going after nutella for shallow reasons so nutella votes reyways.

My man typhoony would call this

NO U.

lol. Lynch me, ladies. DO IT

DO IT

[reywaS]

reyways is the only way

[reywaS]

and I said last night i started feeling uneasy about my suspicion of nutella and her recent explanation of the thing i asked her to clarify days ago makes sense. Then she goes ahead and No U's me anyway.

Oh well. Im switch to spirityo for self preservation purposes and also cuz I'm not getting fire ass banter from him like I am nutella.

vote: spirit of kenny rogers roasters

[reywaS]

and I said last night i started feeling uneasy about my suspicion of nutella and her recent explanation of the thing i asked her to clarify days ago makes sense. Then she goes ahead and No U's me anyway.

Oh well. Im switch to spirityo for self preservation purposes and also cuz I'm not getting fire ass banter from him like I am nutella.

vote: spirit of kenny rogers roasters

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Reywas is melting down like a volcano.

Not sure how to interpret that.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Like, is he usually emotional like this? I don't think I remember playing with him.

[speedchuck]

DO IT

You didn't say the magic word.

[G-Man]

Mafia is:

[mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention]
[mention]Kylemii[/mention]
[mention]S~V~S[/mention]

[Sloonei]

[VOTE: reywas] aubergine

I barely know why and i’m probably not gonna be here for the deadline. MVP performance right here.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Mafia is:

@Dragon D. Luffy
@Kylemii
@S~V~S

Elaborate.

[S~V~S]

Mafia is:

@ Dragon D. Luffy
@ Kylemii
@ S~V~S

Sorry, nope, I am not Mafia. That is about as clear as you can get. You might be right about the other two, but not me. I can't read DDL,I always think he's shady, and Kyle looks pretty civ to me.

I thought I would have more time today than I do, so gonna vote and run.

I think Mac made a good case, but I also think Mac dying when he did (or even Epi, as he also suspected Nutella) smacks of set up. Although both of them ... I dunno.

Why is Rey getting votes? This is civ Ray, he doesn't feel anywhere near slick enough to be bad.

I would rather vote for a no show than reywaS and I am conflicted on Nutella and hoped to sort that out, but a 60* gorgeous day and a dog with cabin fever got in the way.

[VOTE: sprityo] aubergine

[reywaS]

Like, is he usually emotional like this? I don't think I remember playing with him.

hhahahaha

You think this is a meltdown.

hahhahhaha


Tell 'em, S~V~S . Is this a meltdown or me just fuckin around?

[reywaS]

spoiler alert....its a meltdown

[reywaS]

Like, is he usually emotional like this? I don't think I remember playing with him.

I'm a Scorpio, so yes. I am always a white hot mess just like this.

[sabie12]

Mafia is:

@Dragon D. Luffy
@Kylemii
@S~V~S

And your reasoning is? The one thing that got me with svs was her saying bye epi and mac rather than RIP. Like who cares we just lost 2 more civs. That nonchalance over who cares we lost civs thing was also why I was suspecting gman.

I dont know on kyle and ddl. Nutella I could see as being bad. Very over zealous about the Enrique thing. She is very defensive and accusing epi who ended up being good.

Idk about spirit he's posted literally twice and once only to say epi was bad when he wasnt. It would suck if we lynch him and hes not bad but theres no way to know really because he has said nothing and never voted. If hes not going to be replaced then I guess I see why people want to get rid of him.

I don't like lunas comment on Enrique being good making her look good. And shes kinda following whatever nutella says. Idk if that's a teammate thing or an unsure what to do thing.

Gman says he is vanilla on the chart but we dont actuall have that confirmed. If he were bad it would be a great way to make civs look bad by saying he was good when he wasn't.

I'm really at a loss this game. Don't feel like I have any idea what to do. Those are some random thoughts. Idk

[S~V~S]

Mafia is:

@ Dragon D. Luffy
@ Kylemii
@ S~V~S

And your reasoning is? The one thing that got me with svs was her saying bye epi and mac rather than RIP. Like who cares we just lost 2 more civs. That nonchalance over who cares we lost civs thing was also why I was suspecting gman.

I dont know on kyle and ddl. Nutella I could see as being bad. Very over zealous about the Enrique thing. She is very defensive and accusing epi who ended up being good.

Idk about spirit he's posted literally twice and once only to say epi was bad when he wasnt. It would suck if we lynch him and hes not bad but theres no way to know really because he has said nothing and never voted. If hes not going to be replaced then I guess I see why people want to get rid of him.

I don't like lunas comment on Enrique being good making her look good. And shes kinda following whatever nutella says. Idk if that's a teammate thing or an unsure what to do thing.

Gman says he is vanilla on the chart but we dont actuall have that confirmed. If he were bad it would be a great way to make civs look bad by saying he was good when he wasn't.

I'm really at a loss this game. Don't feel like I have any idea what to do. Those are some random thoughts. Idk

I say "bye" to everyone, or I try to. I don't like "RIP" since it's opposite is "BIH", "Burn in Hell", and why would I want to say that to a friend? I said "Bye" to LC and Nova as well. For me, a big part of voting to lynch is realizing we are ending their game, and I want to take that seriously which is why I don't love joke votes. Like I said earlier in the game, everyone is cool, and I take every death seriously. "RIP" and bye are just words, and if what you read into that is that I don't care, I don't know what to say. I dislike ending anyones game flippantly. Sometimes I forget and say "RIP", but it isn't my favorite.

Like, is he usually emotional like this? I don't think I remember playing with him.

hhahahaha

You think this is a meltdown.

hahhahhaha


Tell 'em, S~V~S . Is this a meltdown or me just fuckin around?

He's just fucking around. I don't know if anyone here has ever seen me meltdown, but Rey and I play in the same league.

[S~V~S]

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, [mention]sabie12[/mention] .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

[sabie12]

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, @sabie12 .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

No not at all I was like saying that was the only thing I could possibly get from you which isn't much of anything. I was in no way planning on turning that small thing into voting for you. Gman was accusing you and I was saying that's literally the only thing I could think of. I am not accusing you more like just curious on the word choice.

[sabie12]

I don't want to upset people sighhhh I'm sorry!

[S~V~S]

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, @ sabie12 .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

No not at all I was like saying that was the only thing I could possibly get from you which isn't much of anything. I was in no way planning on turning that small thing into voting for you. Gman was accusing you and I was saying that's literally the only thing I could think of. I am not accusing you more like just curious on the word choice.[/quote}


I know some people who stopped making any reaction post at all becasue they got into issues just like this, and I was gonna say, if you think I am bad, find a real reason to vote for me ha ha. I know semantics arguments have become in again, but I always found them overrated.

Linki, no you did not personally upset me, Sweetie. It's all game face

[S~V~S]

Fixed.

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, @ sabie12 .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

No not at all I was like saying that was the only thing I could possibly get from you which isn't much of anything. I was in no way planning on turning that small thing into voting for you. Gman was accusing you and I was saying that's literally the only thing I could think of. I am not accusing you more like just curious on the word choice.

I know some people who stopped making any reaction post at all becasue they got into issues just like this, and I was gonna say, if you think I am bad, find a real reason to vote for me ha ha. I know semantics arguments have become in again, but I always found them overrated.

Linki, no you did not personally upset me, Sweetie. It's all game face

[sabie12]

Idk I'm just going to vote spirityo even though we have nothing to go on. I guess no one has stepped up to replace him and he hasn't done anything other than accuse a civ one time and then leave and not vote or anything.

[sabie12]

Fixed.

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, @ sabie12 .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

No not at all I was like saying that was the only thing I could possibly get from you which isn't much of anything. I was in no way planning on turning that small thing into voting for you. Gman was accusing you and I was saying that's literally the only thing I could think of. I am not accusing you more like just curious on the word choice.

I know some people who stopped making any reaction post at all becasue they got into issues just like this, and I was gonna say, if you think I am bad, find a real reason to vote for me ha ha. I know semantics arguments have become in again, but I always found them overrated.

Linki, no you did not personally upset me, Sweetie. It's all game face

I think ever since my brain thing I just get self conscious about the fact that I word things badly and people can take what I say the wrong way because of it sometimes.

[reywaS]

Fixed.

The more I think about this, the more it upsets me, actually, @ sabie12 .

Do you honestly think I am being flippant about civvies dying becasue I said "bye" not "RIP"? Do you really think that is a baddie tell?

No not at all I was like saying that was the only thing I could possibly get from you which isn't much of anything. I was in no way planning on turning that small thing into voting for you. Gman was accusing you and I was saying that's literally the only thing I could think of. I am not accusing you more like just curious on the word choice.

I know some people who stopped making any reaction post at all becasue they got into issues just like this, and I was gonna say, if you think I am bad, find a real reason to vote for me ha ha. I know semantics arguments have become in again, but I always found them overrated.

Linki, no you did not personally upset me, Sweetie. It's all game face

I dont ever acknowledge lynch deaths or nks for this reason way back in the day before this site existed.

[reywaS]

i stopped way back in the day that should say

[G-Man]

Man O’Day! Are you kidding me? We’re taking the non-participant option on Day 3 after two consecutive mislynches AND down four confirmed civs? He better flip mafia or else it’s game over for the civs.

[reywaS]

whats the better option, gman? I'm all eyes.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Man O’Day! Are you kidding me? We’re taking the non-participant option on Day 3 after two consecutive mislynches AND down four confirmed civs? He better flip mafia or else it’s game over for the civs.

I agree. This sounds like the easy path to baddie victory.

[VOTE: Reywas] aubergine

I'll take the non-lazy option. At least there is some precedent to mafia faking meltdowns.

[G-Man]

whats the better option, gman? I'm all eyes.

Mafia is:

@Dragon D. Luffy
@Kylemii
@S~V~S

[G-Man]

Mama Bear and Puff the Magic Dragon, splitting their votes up again? How convenient.

Sorry- no time for details before the deadline. I’ll elaborate in a little bit.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Gonna make this one quick. sprityo has been lynched. He was:

Spoiler: show

Vanilla civilian

Award!!!!


Night 3 begins now and will last 24 hours.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Spoiler: show

[G-Man]

Masterful job, guys. Back after bathtime.

[MacDougall]

Hooray!

[juliets]

Congratulations Assassination Classroom Mafia team! I remember how you humiliated the rest of us in that game. Also congrats to the nominees who will be named soon.

[nutella]

Well I'm disappointed it wasn't my FE team, but I didn't get to witness ass class and I assume it was well deserved.

[juliets]

Just fyi the Mafia Team in Assassination Classroom was Dragon D. Luffy, insertnamehere, MacDougall, and wolbre04.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Sorry DH, your show is now my show.

(Again, thanks for the votes!)

[sabie12]

Ugh i think I'm destined to lose every mafia game ever sigh.

[reywaS]

Man O’Day! Are you kidding me? We’re taking the non-participant option on Day 3 after two consecutive mislynches AND down four confirmed civs? He better flip mafia or else it’s game over for the civs.

I agree. This sounds like the easy path to baddie victory.

[VOTE: Reywas] aubergine

I'll take the non-lazy option. At least there is some precedent to mafia faking meltdowns.

lmao

please do tell where was i faking a meltdown?

[reywaS]

gman i think you hit the nail on the head with DDL being mafia as fug