It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia [END]

[thellama73]

Hey llama are you bad?

No, I am not bad, but thank you for asking a very sensible question.

[Mongoose]

Hello, I guess I am subbing in here. ANyone want to catch me up? I guess I have some reading to do.

There's some good HTG postings on this page, but this thread isn't so long that you can't catch up totally in about an hour or two, I reckon.

[MacDougall]

Hey what the heck juliets thinks I'm bad u guise

[Sloonei]

Mon Goose:

Spoiler: show

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

Do you blame me after the raucous first day I had in Gossip Girl? That was brutalizing.

so you are admitting you were in fact intentionally more stiff in your opening post here? exhibit a: the woman does not deny it, your honor.

I find it suspicious you don't value candor.

dunya is suspicious

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

Do you blame me after the raucous first day I had in Gossip Girl? That was brutalizing.

You got a read on dunya or nova?

Not yet, but I will amend when I do. I've played with them recently, so I could see a cabal thinking "Let's put a little pressure on Mongoose - she will get defensive and act weird and then we can vote her out early." I could also see them just desperate to grab onto any inkling of a ping on Day 0/Day 1 like we all are.

linki - Calibrating my playstyle to more suit this new world of mafia seems not only sensible but prudent. I'd expect anyone to do the same after playing one short game and literally one day period of another. My old style, which you would be unfamiliar with, seems a little antiquated for this new mafia landscape. It's more different than I could have ever realized.

No she's not.

Omg are you effing kidding me. Well I didn’t need to draft any documents this afternoon.

Overall thoughts:

Hope MP shows up
Thought Mac’s comment on Dunya’s FU play style was insightful and genuine
Liked The full rundowns folks did (that they did them, not saying I ratify the contents)
Seems like no one can read Luna, and I feel ya girl
Sorry to see speed go
No idea what the Paddy’s Pub mechanic is and didn’t see this in Hall of Fame

There's an unspecified list of people who get credit for posting rundowns, but I don't know who they are. I assume I'm one of them.

Speaking of risk, I have a question for the class: who here had the satest post history in the game? Is there anybody we think seems to be avoiding risks?

I have an answer, but I want to see if anyone agrees with me first.

Sloonei, you mean like historically over their career as compared with this game, right?

When MP is present he posts a lot from what I remember. I sometimes post a lot but am not always super chatty. Juliets seems par for the course. Yours seems normal. Not sure on the others.

juliets and sloonei seem normal

Speaking of risk, I have a question for the class: who here had the satest post history in the game? Is there anybody we think seems to be avoiding risks?

I have an answer, but I want to see if anyone agrees with me first.

Sloonei, you mean like historically over their career as compared with this game, right?

When MP is present he posts a lot from what I remember. I sometimes post a lot but am not always super chatty. Juliets seems par for the course. Yours seems normal. Not sure on the others.

Sorry. I mean the safest posts in this game particularly.

I don’t see any safeness for those that are present. I certainly empathize with Mac’s work woes and anyone with a frantic schedule, so I don’t hold that against people. I wanna see more out of Luna Lamb and that errant sock. I read everything over a couple of hours so I felt content was pretty good overall, particularly for Day1A.

MP and luna should post more.

Why all the cases on Colin? I needs someone to proffer items into evidence to substantiate this please. Okay seriously nail appt

Acknowledges Colin votes.

Juliets - you can add that I read Sloonei as civ.

Sloonei is town.

@Sloonei

In RE: The State v. Luna: Hung Jury. Yes, I do think I would lump myself in with folks that can't read her (this happened in another game recently), but the jury is still out. I'd like to see a little more.

In RE: The State v. Colin: 50/50 - I felt pretty good about him, so I asked for some more details once I saw two of you had voted him, and then you both had answers that were thoughtful and thought-out, so that's why I'm less sure now.

In RE: The State v. Juliets: Nah. While I understand the case folks were making on her, it seemed like a mountain of molehole. An allegation that she uncharacteristically wasn't here enough but when she did, she didn't draw out the right posts or ask the right questions. I'm not looking there yet.


linki - thank you for that dunya

Also, welcome to spirityo!

Neutral on Luna. Neutral on Colin.
Town on juliets.

I know you didn’t ask me, but this didn’t alarm me at all. Just seemed like someone thinking aloud. I don’t mind a point/counterpoint analysis.

Mac looks okay.

Guys, this reads like textbook Classic Frustrated Civ Syndrome. If she is faking this, I will laud her appropriately in post-game.

So let me tell you guys one more time. I was here early this morning. Nothing that I thought was substantive had happened yet. I got off work at 4:00 and got to the thread sometime between 4:30 and 5:00 and saw several things I wanted to comment on/question and so I did. Just because someone suspects me doesn't mean I am going to shut down my play style. You can try to make it into something it isn't which is what you guys are doing but it is not what you're trying to make it. I was the same in Asunder as I have been in every other game I play - asking questions. That's the last I'll say about yesterday/today unless I'm asked a specific question.

juliets is town

I think what has happened is I never bought the case on Juliets because she read super civ to me, and then even more so after the post I quoted earlier this morning. I also feel super civ about Mac and Sloonei, but ive not been alleged to be buddying up with them, which seems odd and inconsistent. Sloonei and I have had a lot of discourse and back and forth, especially in the time I’ve been acting.

As for being on the defense, sure I can defend myself but that doesn’t mean I’m defensive. I spent a LOT of time trying to thoroughly run through everyone’s questions for me and answering them fully. I didn’t want to brush anyone’s concerns off, and felt pretty confident I got to everything. In the end, I ran out of time. I was able to make some good thought out posts for day 1 and was actively hunting.

I feel slightly hamstrung by not having heard much or anything from a few folks, but I rarely have anything other than mild pings on day 1 (with some exceptions of course).

Linki

Mac and Sloonei are also town.

sloonei, maybe you missed my previous post. what about mongoose is town to you?

Sincerity. While I don’t think she’s given a ton of reads, she has been an open and willing participant in conversations whenever she’s been around. I don’t feel like she’s hiding.

But she hasn’t shared many reads.

I thought I had.

I feel Sloonei, Mac and Juliets are town.
Dunya and nova probably town
Colin is on border of town
Luna eep
MP and sprityo ??

Suddenly luna appears to be the top suspect. Interesting.

The person I feel the weakest about is Luna. But nothing brazen, ya know? I just find it hardest to read her. But I really empathize with that a lot since I’ve historically been hard to read, which I’ve been reticent to lead any charge (or follow anyone else’s) yet.

I’m off to another meeting, I should be able to check in one more time before the vote.

Dunya - I know I didn’t exactly answer your question the way you directed (pick two or three) but if what I replied to Sloonei with isn’t enough info, I’ll try to ameliorate that when I return

Elaborates that it's more an absence of a town read on luna than an explicit suspicion.

Oof, I am married to so few of these.

SUBECT TO CHANGE

ColinIsCool good
dunya good
juliets good
Lunalee bad?
MacDougall good
Mongoose goodgoose
novaselinenever good
Sloonei angelic

This is not going to work out well for me.

One bad read. Not a good look.

Outside of a small nod at the inactive players, luna is the only player Mongoose really expressed any suspicion of. There was a tiny blip against dunya that was dropped immediately. I can see why Mongoose is a suspect, but she's still too new to me to feel sure of anything. I'm gonna need more substantive reads moving forward or she'll become a viable suspect.

[MacDougall]

MP roleplayed as Margaret McPoyle quite well, so I'm skipping ahead to Mac.

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

Do you blame me after the raucous first day I had in Gossip Girl? That was brutalizing.

You got a read on dunya or nova?

What about yours?

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

Sloonei is a mafia.

I WILL FOLLOW DUNYA TO HECK

dunya is implied town

I don’t really have any suspects right now, but I do not think it’s Sloonei or juliets. Luna is probably good, I can buy that emulating Jay thing.

The man is town. Again.

Colin is town.

Colin is Mafia. Sorry I called him town before because I shouldn't have. Lynch with enthusiasm please.

Colin is mafia.

I do not know what Steve Carell means. The man is an enigma.

Now counterpoint, Colin as Mafia would be playing differently than this.

This Colin is not mafia Colin.

I wouldn't dispute a Colin lynch right now. I can see him as a callous civilian or a bumbling Mafia. The question is which is more likely to be Colin? The bumbling Mafia caught day 1 or the civilian suffering from a case of "oh shit I do look bad"?

This Colin is a lynch candidate, however.

Also what's with the speedchuck votes? The guy hasn't even been able to play, and is pending replacement.

Teammate with your hubby again!?

speedchuck and luna might be bad together.

I am willing to call it. Juliets and Sprityo are the Mafia team.

sprityo (speedchuck) and juliets are mafia.

Dumbass thinks I'm Mafia. News at 11.

Lynch spiritchuck or MP imo.

Implication that nova is town.
MP or sprityo should be lynched.

ColinIsCool - sus
dunya - good
juliets - good
Lunalee - good
M Plus 7 - undeserved of any opinion
Mongoose - sus
novaselinenever - dumb but good
Sloonei - good

Colin and Mongoose are his suspects after the lynch. MP/llama is null.

Oi Mac why are colin and mongoose your suspects now?

[Sloonei]

Hello, I guess I am subbing in here. ANyone want to catch me up? I guess I have some reading to do.

down with ketchup, 2019.

[thellama73]

Okay, I read day zero and I want to post some thoughts before I forget them, and then move on to reading Day 1:
ColinIsCool - Nothing of substance. I don't love the aloofness.
dunya - Seems supatown to me. Good, aggressive behavior trying to smoke out baddies. I like.
juliets - The exchange with Mac where he demands she throw out reads and she refuses is interesting. Could go a number of ways, but I'm inclined to read it civ on civ.
Lunalee - Sucking up a little to Dunya, but then again, I can see why.
MacDougall - See juliets.
Mongoose - Her tone seems a little different than what I'm used to. Bears watching.
novaselinenever - I was pinged by her post expressing frustration over not having won in a while. Could be the result of being given a baddie role and feeling outnumbered.
Sloonei - Active posting, good hunting. Leaning town.

[MacDougall]

Let's lynch Nova and Colin then. I hate them both as humans so this at the very least makes the experience of playing Mafia more enjoyable.

[Sloonei]

Spoiler: show

Third time's the charm?

Appeal to history? Appeal to emotions?

Not a good look madam

mongoose is a suspect

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

dunya is not.

hottake: juliets is bad

I love hot takes. Tell me more

she has made a total of 3 posts in between a lot of us already talking about other players as we always do. 3 of those posts had nothing to do with the game content. one was a typical juliets checkin, the second was comforting mongoose's playstyle in the same way i did (and a direct mention to how dunya/sloonei were making reads), and the last is to tell us about her schedule. she was online yesterday and today and that is all she managed to offer. i feel like this is in direct contrast with her usual day 0 conduct where she digs in and asks people for elaborations or some such. and her post to mongoose makes it clear she was up to speed with the game progress...and i know juliets, she reads every post in the game she's in.

at least i don't feel jules/mongoose would be w/w based on her second post directed towards mongoose.

with all that said, i'd sooner lynch myself day 1 than lynch juliets. so let's find her teammate!

I like this.

juliets is a suspect.

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

Do you blame me after the raucous first day I had in Gossip Girl? That was brutalizing.

You got a read on dunya or nova?

What about yours?

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

I don't like this

Mac is a jerk turkey.

I also don't like Sloonei's response but I'm giving him room. It was a nice piece of roleplay and I played along hoping he'd come back to it and answer seriously.

He didn't

Slanderous accusation against Sloonei.

I don't recall ever getting a town read from Luna. She's always uneasy or unsure about me when I'm town 'cause I mess around. Funny thing is she read me as scum when she was a baddie in our last game together and she ended up getting lynched. Trying a new approach?

Shade at luna

I'll have to agree with Dunya also about Luna's read on her. That "Town shines brightly" is funny looking, and it looks like something right out of Jay's eloquent gut reads.

Shade at luna

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Shade at juliets

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

Vote for juliets

Really liked her Mongoose stuff early on, and the later's response read to me like some appeal to emotions lol. I'm not sure I have the heart to go through with a lynch on her though, I'd feel really bad especially with her post about contemplating changing her play style.

I'm soft like that.

I think this support of dunya and waffling on Mongoose

Colin reads contrived in his latest exchange. A lot of backpedalling and sidestepping.

Colin looks bad.

Nada on MP and Speed

Nada on the nadas

Who's not impressed by Mac's exercise?

Shade at Mac

Haven't really seen much from Luna since the early hours of D1

Pokes luna with a pondering emoji

Also let's not even get to that point

I’ve got no desire to go there yet. How do you feel about everybody?

I have a reason to townread yourself, Dunya and Luna. I have nothing on MP, and I still await his promised arrival.

I have no reason to townread Colin, Sprit, Juliet, Mongoose and Mac. I feel the worse about the last 3 and would see myself lynching there.

Sloonei, dunya, and luna are town. MP is null. Colin, sprit, juliets, mongoose, and Mac are suspects.
That's a bigger pool than most.

Don't listen to Dunya, I'm good

Vote Mac, please. Thank you.

Calls for Mac to be lynched.

When in doubt, lynch Lunalee.

Is that how the saying goes?

Luna shade.
nova has been all over the place on luna. Why?

I hereby rescind Dunya's civilian card.

dunya shade. they'd been bickering for a while at this point.

I'm buying what Juliets is selling, undecided on Sprit's.

Feels good about juliets but undecided on sprit.

[VOTE: Sprityo] aubergine

votes sprityo.

Without re-reading, this is where I'm at currently. I think it might very change drastically so I'll go to the lab

ColinIsCool - good
dunya - good
juliets - good
Lunalee - good
M Plus 7 - good
MacDougall - bad
Mongoose - bad
novaselinenever - great
Sloonei - great

Mac and Mongoose are his suspects.

Nova's scum read on Mac has been one of a constant throughout, but other than that he's been a bit all over the place. He arrived at Mongoose as his suspect suspect in the GTH exercise. Why Mongoose, nova? And could you elaborate on the development of your luna read? please and thanks.

[Sloonei]

novaselinenever - I was pinged by her post expressing frustration over not having won in a while. Could be the result of being given a baddie role and feeling outnumbered.

ftr: nova's a dude, and he just won another game as scum like 15 minutes before this one started.

[Sloonei]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

[thellama73]

novaselinenever - I was pinged by her post expressing frustration over not having won in a while. Could be the result of being given a baddie role and feeling outnumbered.

ftr: nova's a dude, and he just won another game as scum like 15 minutes before this one started.

Don't tell me what to do.

Okay, I'm mostly caught up. I do think Colin looks terrible after Day 1. Wishy washy, not hunting, no reads, votes for no lynch (along with Mongoose) which is always a bad vote, in my view. HOWEVER there's this:

Ew, per Sloonei's post, Colin really doesn't look good.

I don't like this. I don't know why, but it immediately stuck out to me. It was her first post in a while, and it adds nothing of value, just piggybacks on Sloonei. Then, look what happens.

I got a lot more work rolled into my job today and I am going to be a wee bit occupied. (Also I’m not getting a raise if you were curious. )

But I will do my best to reassess the thread and get better reads before EOD. I see many of you now believe I’m just regular dumbass Colin so that’s a relief.

I would feel really bad mis-lynching Colin. Again.

Quite a turnaround in a short amount of time. Colin looks really bad, but oh no let's not lynch him. DO NOT WANT.

Also, I'm pretty sure Mac's gay.

[MacDougall]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

Why is Llama so high you shitbutt?

[MacDougall]

Also, I'm pretty sure Mac's gay.

I am deeply in the closet actually. I'm comfortable in here. Don't out me you insensitive dickhole.

[Sloonei]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

Why is Llama so high you shitbutt?

Pure gut read based on his entry

[MacDougall]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

Why is Llama so high you shitbutt?

Pure gut read based on his entry

Nova has been trolling me and Llama called me gay. You are town reading them because they are adversarial to me aren't you?

[Sloonei]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

Why is Llama so high you shitbutt?

Pure gut read based on his entry

Nova has been trolling me and Llama called me gay. You are town reading them because they are adversarial to me aren't you?

That's usually the first thing I look for.

[MacDougall]

That's pretty fucking great

[Sloonei]

That's pretty fucking great

is luna good?

[MacDougall]

I think so but I dunno ay. What do you think Sloonei? You've definitely paid more attention than I have?

[Tangrowth]

Sigh. I won't comment other than to express my deepest apologies to my fellow players and Jay for practically no-showing. Life right now just always gets busier than I anticipate. I really hope to actually play with you all again soon -- guess it'll unfortunately have to wait until summer or winter breaks for now. Hope you all have tons of fun!

[Sloonei]

I think so but I dunno ay. What do you think Sloonei? You've definitely paid more attention than I have?

Her Day 1 play seems pretty safe and measured, but I could attribute that to low availability and her expressed intent to hunt for town reads rather than scum. I want to see how she responds moving forward. I have her as a slight town read for now.

[novaselinenever]

Spoiler: show

Third time's the charm?

Appeal to history? Appeal to emotions?

Not a good look madam

mongoose is a suspect

no but seriously, i really did feel mongoose's entry was a little more stiff than her previous two.

dunya is not.

hottake: juliets is bad

I love hot takes. Tell me more

she has made a total of 3 posts in between a lot of us already talking about other players as we always do. 3 of those posts had nothing to do with the game content. one was a typical juliets checkin, the second was comforting mongoose's playstyle in the same way i did (and a direct mention to how dunya/sloonei were making reads), and the last is to tell us about her schedule. she was online yesterday and today and that is all she managed to offer. i feel like this is in direct contrast with her usual day 0 conduct where she digs in and asks people for elaborations or some such. and her post to mongoose makes it clear she was up to speed with the game progress...and i know juliets, she reads every post in the game she's in.

at least i don't feel jules/mongoose would be w/w based on her second post directed towards mongoose.

with all that said, i'd sooner lynch myself day 1 than lynch juliets. so let's find her teammate!

I like this.

juliets is a suspect.

Do you blame me after the raucous first day I had in Gossip Girl? That was brutalizing.

You got a read on dunya or nova?

What about yours?

I assume that if I give any reads you’ll all just tell me that I look like some sort of bird, or that I have nothing to contribute, and that I should just give up trying.

This is a mafia

I don't like this

Mac is a jerk turkey.

I also don't like Sloonei's response but I'm giving him room. It was a nice piece of roleplay and I played along hoping he'd come back to it and answer seriously.

He didn't

Slanderous accusation against Sloonei.

I don't recall ever getting a town read from Luna. She's always uneasy or unsure about me when I'm town 'cause I mess around. Funny thing is she read me as scum when she was a baddie in our last game together and she ended up getting lynched. Trying a new approach?

Shade at luna

I'll have to agree with Dunya also about Luna's read on her. That "Town shines brightly" is funny looking, and it looks like something right out of Jay's eloquent gut reads.

Shade at luna

Little surge of activity from Juliet, and a lot of inquiries in a very short amount of time. Exactly what Dunya said she would expect from civ juliets.

Omoshiroi

Shade at juliets

[VOTE: Juliets] aubergine

Vote for juliets

Really liked her Mongoose stuff early on, and the later's response read to me like some appeal to emotions lol. I'm not sure I have the heart to go through with a lynch on her though, I'd feel really bad especially with her post about contemplating changing her play style.

I'm soft like that.

I think this support of dunya and waffling on Mongoose

Colin reads contrived in his latest exchange. A lot of backpedalling and sidestepping.

Colin looks bad.

Nada on MP and Speed

Nada on the nadas

Who's not impressed by Mac's exercise?

Shade at Mac

Haven't really seen much from Luna since the early hours of D1

Pokes luna with a pondering emoji

Also let's not even get to that point

I’ve got no desire to go there yet. How do you feel about everybody?

I have a reason to townread yourself, Dunya and Luna. I have nothing on MP, and I still await his promised arrival.

I have no reason to townread Colin, Sprit, Juliet, Mongoose and Mac. I feel the worse about the last 3 and would see myself lynching there.

Sloonei, dunya, and luna are town. MP is null. Colin, sprit, juliets, mongoose, and Mac are suspects.
That's a bigger pool than most.

Don't listen to Dunya, I'm good

Vote Mac, please. Thank you.

Calls for Mac to be lynched.

When in doubt, lynch Lunalee.

Is that how the saying goes?

Luna shade.
nova has been all over the place on luna. Why?

I hereby rescind Dunya's civilian card.

dunya shade. they'd been bickering for a while at this point.

I'm buying what Juliets is selling, undecided on Sprit's.

Feels good about juliets but undecided on sprit.

[VOTE: Sprityo] aubergine

votes sprityo.

Without re-reading, this is where I'm at currently. I think it might very change drastically so I'll go to the lab

ColinIsCool - good
dunya - good
juliets - good
Lunalee - good
M Plus 7 - good
MacDougall - bad
Mongoose - bad
novaselinenever - great
Sloonei - great

Mac and Mongoose are his suspects.

Nova's scum read on Mac has been one of a constant throughout, but other than that he's been a bit all over the place. He arrived at Mongoose as his suspect suspect in the GTH exercise. Why Mongoose, nova? And could you elaborate on the development of your luna read? please and thanks.

What do you mean by "arrived"? The first post you quoted is me being pinged my Mongoose all the way back to D0.

I can't read Luna for shit. Several of early posts, as well as a dip in her presence have pinged me but she's hitting all the right tones and she seems consistent in her town hunting efforts. Our interaction over her Mongoose thoughts perfectly reflect this; her post about trusting Dunya's gut read pinged me and I asked her for original thoughts and they were perfect lol. Read genuine and echoed some of my conclusion thoughts I had over Mongoose and her lack of suspects.

[novaselinenever]

Quite an entrance from Llama dude. Not bad

[novaselinenever]

ANYWAY, keeping in mind my color-coding exercise here's an inaugural rainbow list:

dunya
nova
Llama
Mac
Luna
Colin
Mongoose
juliets

dunya's easily my most trusted for the time being, but she's never to be trusted fully ( ), and I like llama's immediate entrance so there's that. I mostly feel good about nova, but I'm uncertain about some of his read progressions, and his Mac suspicion is one that could be faked and dragged out by a mafioso to get through Day 1. I'd definitely lean town on him though.

I'd GTH all three of Mac, Luna, and Colin good right now, but in reviewing their posts I found that I can't actually give them a whole lot of actual town credit. Mac's been all over the place, which is a thing Macdougall is wont to do, but it's a very easy behavior to fake. Luna's offered far fewer reads than I thought, and Colin's No Lynch vote reads very much like a player who's not concerned with looking good or bad. Outside of that, I'm wary of him.

Mongoose produced no suspects except for an extremely vague not-town read on Luna. I don't like that.
My juliets suspicion is well-documented.

Switch Mac and Juliets, we gucci

[novaselinenever]

And put a lil' bit of yellow on Luna/Colin. Can't have that many green

[MacDougall]

I've decided I think nova is Mafia. His persistent wavering scum read isn't coming with any actual attempt to convince anyone else. He is lacking civ tinfoil, or doubt. It's a sham read and premeditated before the game began as a means for dealing with me.

[MacDougall]

Every time I envision Nova posting I imagine him sitting there sipping on a drink with a smirk on his face. Everything has a snarky tone to it. His tone reeks of mischief and mayhem. He's like the guy you catch staring at you from across the room while pretending to read the paper and then goes back to the paper and pretends you never made eye contact and he has a grey trenchcoat on and a tall hat.

[MacDougall]

I've decided I think nova is Mafia. His persistent wavering scum read isn't coming with any actual attempt to convince anyone else. He is lacking civ tinfoil, or doubt. It's a sham read and premeditated before the game began as a means for dealing with me.

*unwavering

[dunya]

Every time I envision Nova posting I imagine him sitting there sipping on a drink with a smirk on his face. Everything has a snarky tone to it. His tone reeks of mischief and mayhem. He's like the guy you catch staring at you from across the room while pretending to read the paper and then goes back to the paper and pretends you never made eye contact and he has a grey trenchcoat on and a tall hat.

I like llama he town.

[dunya]

I want nova dead. Maybe sloonei too.

[novaselinenever]

I've decided I think nova is Mafia. His persistent wavering scum read isn't coming with any actual attempt to convince anyone else. He is lacking civ tinfoil, or doubt. It's a sham read and premeditated before the game began as a means for dealing with me.

[novaselinenever]

If anyone missed it, I'm town

[novaselinenever]

Every time I envision Nova posting I imagine him sitting there sipping on a drink with a smirk on his face. Everything has a snarky tone to it. His tone reeks of mischief and mayhem. He's like the guy you catch staring at you from across the room while pretending to read the paper and then goes back to the paper and pretends you never made eye contact and he has a grey trenchcoat on and a tall hat.

You are good

[novaselinenever]

Prove me wrong Mac. Told you I'm very impressionable.

[novaselinenever]

Everyone looks civ except MP, and all those bland hot takes aren't going to cut it.

[MacDougall]

Yeah Nova is Mafia.

[MacDougall]

I want nova dead. Maybe sloonei too.

I could buy these two as Mafia together tbh. Sloonei dominating shit, Nova sitting on the sidelines lazily pushing his bullshit Mac suspicion and doing a whole lot of nothing else because he can.

[novaselinenever]

So I've done nothing except push Mac? All righty

[MacDougall]

Nothing that comes to mind for me, Mac.

[novaselinenever]

I don't know why but the first thing that came to my mind for reconsideration is my read on Luna.

Yes let’s discuss

Let's! I'm yet to hear what makes you feel uneasy about her outside of being unable to read her.

[novaselinenever]

Oh, all right thanks. I guess I haven't found Mac's scumbuddy. Back to work.

[MacDougall]

sham read

[novaselinenever]

What about that Colin read of yours, Mac? Saw him back to sus

That's a sham read, If ever I'd seen one

[novaselinenever]

Talk to me about Mongoose. We both have her as red. Bussing, mac?

[MacDougall]

Make up a read on mac you just recite like a mantra and refuse to ever admit the falsity of

vs.

Change your mind on a person you don't know the role card of because you're a civ

One of those things is a sham read and one is normal civilian play.

[MacDougall]

Talk to me about Mongoose. We both have her as red. Bussing, mac?

I looked into my soul and found very little reason to read her as town

[MacDougall]

Nova has backed himself into a corner where if he changes his mind on me he would be being hypocritical because he's accused me of being Mafia because of me doing that on my Colin read.

The thing is, a civilian wouldn't give a shit about that. Nova is not a civilian.

[novaselinenever]

The civilian play would require an incentive for the change. Mac hasn't given me such a thing.

Nice of you to also ignore that it is very civilian to not change one's mind and tunnel. There's nothing inherently scummy about believing your own reads, and I'd have thought a proud fellow such as yourself would know.

Do you have anything else beside "a civilian can change his mind" regarding your Colin read? I've asked you several times about the motives and reasonings, and you're just singing this gospel. It's also a baddie play to keep changing their reads, like of consistency, ya know.

[novaselinenever]

Nova has backed himself into a corner where if he changes his mind on me he would be being hypocritical because he's accused me of being Mafia because of me doing that on my Colin read.

The thing is, a civilian wouldn't give a shit about that. Nova is not a civilian.

I've changed my mind on Luna quite a few times, and I couldn't care less that Dunya saw that as hypocritical. I'm not changing my mind on you 'cause I have no reasons to.

Not the same thing.