Banjo-Kazooie Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Tangrowth]

Wow, not quite sure how I came out with those. Fun.

[dunya]

DDL - cruising, no one seems to suspect him, but i don't remember a single opinion of his. seems like he's staying mia and liking the non-attention to me. no urgent game solving need. no inquisitive tones from him. dislike

g-man - his player reads were useful, but i value spontaneous engagement in the thread versus well thought out replies that were written and edited then posted. people who can't be the former are suspect, especially in this game.

nanook - i have no real reason to town read him, thus, he becomes a suspect.

nutella - stayed away from both sig and mac lynches. seems to agreeable with me. not as wishy washy as town nutella usually is. something seems off about her tone. i don't like it. i had more reasons, but no time atm. i have to go.

sloonei - i have discussed many times why i think sloonei is scum and the end of day fiasco doesn't sway me to change that.

tony - i dont have a reason to town read him, thus, he becomes a suspect.

[dunya]

i have to go. please talk more, we have 25 posts and it's almost end of night. burn through those with content! i'll be back before end of night

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Content

[Tangrowth]

Content

[nutella]

alright let's give this a go


Dragon D. Luffy town
dunya town
Epignosis scum
G-Man town
M Plus 7 town
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME scum
Russtifinko town
sig town
Sloonei town
speedchuck scum
TonyStarkPrime scum
Turnip Head scum

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Hey DDL, why do you not feel like you can town read nutella or Tony?

They were just null reads. And since I had just called about 4 players as civ reads, it was wierd to just sheep on a wagon by two people I didn't feel anything about.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Oh hey GTH

I'm still catching up so I guess I'll join later

[Sloonei]

Dunya scum reads me and nutella town reads me. Are we in crazy land?

[nutella]

Dunya scum reads me and nutella town reads me. Are we in crazy land?

I gth you town but I wouldn't say I town read you much north of null atm. I've wavered up and down on you quite a bit

[G-Man]

Dunya scum reads me and nutella town reads me. Are we in crazy land?

Perhaps.

[Tangrowth]

How are you guys getting like 5 scum reads? That's a bit strange.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

TonyStarkPrime:

Eh. Tiny thing in his favor. Won't mention what it is.

I would not lynch TSP today.

I'm assuming this tiny thing is related to the game that just ended. If so, would you like to mention it now?

[Sloonei]

Dunya scum reads me and nutella town reads me. Are we in crazy land?

I gth you town but I wouldn't say I town read you much north of null atm. I've wavered up and down on you quite a bit

That's more in line with what I'd expect.

[Tangrowth]

Dunya scum reads me and nutella town reads me. Are we in crazy land?

Are you really town? Because I'd love to work with you here. Say something only town!Sloonei would say.

[Sloonei]

I'm probably not gonna bother addressing suspicions. Day 1 was weird and I was more preoccupied with adjusting to the settings than playing the game. I'll catch a bad guy Day 2 and you'll all put me on your shoulders and parade me around banjo town, you'll see.

linki: "Hypocrisy is a staple of the civilian playbook."

[Tangrowth]

I'm probably not gonna bother addressing suspicions. Day 1 was weird and I was more preoccupied with adjusting to the settings than playing the game. I'll catch a bad guy Day 2 and you'll all put me on your shoulders and parade me around banjo town, you'll see.

linki: "Hypocrisy is a staple of the civilian playbook."

Okay, cool, let's work together then.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

G-Man:

He needs more time to post. He doesn't have much, but I will say this:

-Not a fan of his insistence on rhyming. Yes, it’s cheeky and fun but even I won’t encourage everyone to post solely in rhymes. Not a fan of his repetition of it. (-1)

...is strange coming from a guy who insists on practicing strange and quirky gimmicks all the time (his posts all start with a P, this time, by the way).

It's doubtful to me that someone of G-Man's quirky caliber would characterize posting in rhymes as something bad or inscrutable. We understand song lyrics just fine (well, most. We have Yes and Led Zeppelin...)

I would lynch G-Man today.

Peculiar? Yes. Hypocritical? Perhaps. In this game, there is a limit to how beneficial the rhymes are. You can fit them in here and there between prose as well. Once the benefit is over, sticking with the rhymes just impairs communication. I think it’s his apparent stubbornness to abstain from prose more so than the use of rhyme. My play experience with him is quite limited. If he’s quirky like me, then it might make sense. I lack that context. I’m voting for Nanook now so I have a vote on the board as I start ISOing the people I have little to no read on.

Damn G-Man don't make me defend nanook. I don't want to defend Nanook.

But yeah, you of all people being annoyed about imparting communication is well... ironic.

And yeah dude is quirky af. Though I'm yet to play with town him so I'm just assuming I don't know his meta.

[G-Man]

How are you guys getting like 5 scum reads? That's a bit strange.

Pfft, my vibe reads have seven in the bad section. It’s more of a “they don’t make me civ read them” thing than a “I suspect them thing.”

No one told them their GTH reads had to be capped at a certain figure. But I agree that not forcing yourself to narrow it down to a more sensible number given the size of this game isn’t helpful.

[nutella]

I'm probably not gonna bother addressing suspicions. Day 1 was weird and I was more preoccupied with adjusting to the settings than playing the game. I'll catch a bad guy Day 2 and you'll all put me on your shoulders and parade me around banjo town, you'll see.

linki: "Hypocrisy is a staple of the civilian playbook."

lol this is awkward but in a funny way

[Sloonei]

For instance, did you know that G-man is bad? Boom, got em

[TonyStarkPrime]

TonyStarkPrime:

Eh. Tiny thing in his favor. Won't mention what it is.

I would not lynch TSP today.

I'm assuming this tiny thing is related to the game that just ended. If so, would you like to mention it now?

For what’s it worth, Epi and Mac both (I feel) can get a sense on me early better than other players.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

If you’re tired of my rhymes
Kill me and sheep my reads
Even though it hasn’t been much time
I feel that pretend confident about my leads

If you want a straight answer
The next question I’ll drop the act
Now I’m lazy so the first rhyme is sir
And the second is fact

[TonyStarkPrime]

How are you guys getting like 5 scum reads? That's a bit strange.

I typed it up and then forgot to send it, and then, completely out of spirit with GTH, changed DDL to scum before sending. I was the first one, other people seem to have picked up on this? I don’t know, I think he’s just south of null.

More directly to your question, I’d place a player as scum roughly if I’d take 3:2 odds on the bet. So with that threshold, that leaves room for theoretically up to 10 players in a game with up to four mafia. How many players do we have?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

FUCK I messed up my rhyme

Welp I guess now I’m playing normally again cause I can’t handle the shame, I hope you’re all proud of yourselves you classless animals

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also I’ll defend you too DDL I actually think >rand chance you’re town.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

macdougall being saved. unimpressed, but will double down next phase.

linki: epi making it a tie! :o

Top 10 worst aging posts of 2020

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Also I’ll defend you too DDL I actually think >rand chance you’re town.

Thanks for the thought, but I am sure I'll vote for you the first time someone suggests that to me.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Yes I'm burning posts rn.

My cap is 30 the night closes in 2 hours.

Saying this now so I don't have to use the much more important day 2 cap to explain this.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also I’ll defend you too DDL I actually think >rand chance you’re town.

Thanks for the thought, but I am sure I'll vote for you the first time someone suggests that to me.

[Sloonei]

DDL is town

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Okay. Lynching Mac=bad. Anyone who voted for him=scum. Easy.

Was this sarcasm?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Okay. Lynching Mac=bad. Anyone who voted for him=scum. Easy.

Was this sarcasm?

No. I mean later I found out six people voted for him and odds are there aren't six mafia, but whatever.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Also, someone subtweeted me at some point and noted that it's highly unlikely that, assuming scum, the entire team was on Mac. It's hard for me right now to quite comprehend that idea, but I'm coming around. The lack of emergence of other trains is throwing me off.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Rats. I forgot that I wanted to ask Mac why he thought I don’t like playing mafia. That’s a false assessment. It’ll have to wait for post-game now.

I mean you literally hide from your wife to play mafia.

If that's not liking it I don't know what it is.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

DDL is town

Not sure how you concoluded that from a sequence of 3 filler posts, but thanks.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Ok, caught up. Let's do the GTH thingy

Dragon D. Luffy: town
dunya: town
Epignosis: town
G-Man: town
M Plus 7: town
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME: scum
nutella: scum
Russtifinko: town
sig: town
Sloonei: scum
speedchuck: town
TonyStarkPrime: scum
Turnip Head: scum

[Dragon D. Luffy]

The ranking from "I actually feel bad about this person" to "I wasn't allowed to vote neutral so I voted scum cuz I don't wanna have too little scum reads" was

TH > nutella > sloonei > nanook > TSP

[Dragon D. Luffy]

TH is still kind of weird in day 1 and I do agree on Mac's point about him that he was sheeping too much. Yeah maybe sheeping is fine but TH didn't really impress me otherwise.

nutella feels a little disconnected from the game, like she's saying a lot but not participating much. That said she probably ranks high in the list of people I've mislynched the most, so I'll tread carefully here.

Literally no idea how to read nanook. I don't know how to interpret he going against Sig. I don't know what to do with him. Send help.

TSP is also pretty meh. Dunno what to think of him yet.

Sloonei I do agree feels different but the argument that he is out of his element due to the post restriction is valid. Need more time to assess.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

dunya feels very honest and I can understand her thought proccesses just fine.

MP is a bit less obvious but so far he's easy enough to understand too. Maybe make this a light green.

Epi is actually mindmelding with me a lot which is rare. His big read post in D1 was very agreeable. He said some weird shit but coming from him it's okay.

G-Man's lists also make kind of sense and is giving me an okay feel. Light green.

Russ feels honest af.

Sig is being a jerk but that actually makes it less likely he is bad. I'm not sure if baddie Sig would do that kind of gratuitous bullying on MP for in-game reasons. Basically what speed said about him.

Speed is very hard to read but the stuff he said about Sig I really agree it so he earns a light green.

[G-Man]

Rats. I forgot that I wanted to ask Mac why he thought I don’t like playing mafia. That’s a false assessment. It’ll have to wait for post-game now.

I mean you literally hide from your wife to play mafia.

If that's not liking it I don't know what it is.

Pretty good these days at hiding the fact that I’m playing from her. I don’t hide from her in order to play. She understands that I consider this community to be part of my social life and that I consider several people here to be good friends. Thanks for making it sound like I go cower in a closet or something. If that’s something else to add to the list of things that people don’t like about me around here, then maybe I should just hang it up altogether. GoC sure made me consider it. Time changes people and forums.

[Tangrowth]

G-Man, you're one of my favorite people in general, and I for one am glad to be playing with you again. I'd be shocked if anyone else disagreed with that sentiment.

[Tangrowth]

Hey DDL, can you talk to me more about certain reads? I'm most interested in the dunya, Epi, and Russ ones. What specifically feels honest from dunya and Russ? And with Epi, what was the weird shit you're referring to there?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Rats. I forgot that I wanted to ask Mac why he thought I don’t like playing mafia. That’s a false assessment. It’ll have to wait for post-game now.

I mean you literally hide from your wife to play mafia.

If that's not liking it I don't know what it is.

Pretty good these days at hiding the fact that I’m playing from her. I don’t hide from her in order to play. She understands that I consider this community to be part of my social life and that I consider several people here to be good friends. Thanks for making it sound like I go cower in a closet or something. If that’s something else to add to the list of things that people don’t like about me around here, then maybe I should just hang it up altogether. GoC sure made me consider it. Time changes people and forums.

Wow I hope that didn't come accross as negative, it was just a joke. I love playing with you or playing your games and I definitely enjoy having you around.

Sorry, dude.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Hey DDL, can you talk to me more about certain reads? I'm most interested in the dunya, Epi, and Russ ones. What specifically feels honest from dunya and Russ? And with Epi, what was the weird shit you're referring to there?

dunya and russ are my biggest two reads so I guess it makes sense I didn't elaborate much, just feeling a lot of honesty and understanding their thought proccesses.

Epi had some moments where he called people bad for bizarre reasons, such as when he said you should enjoy counting since you are an accountant. Or that exchange when he calls Sig bad for having apparently contradicting thoughts but then backs down when Sig replies with the obvious explanation (like, Epi should have thought it himself to begin with).

That's the Epi thing, though, at this point I've learned not to read him bad every time he says something I heavily disagree with.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

TH is still kind of weird in day 1 and I do agree on Mac's point about him that he was sheeping too much. Yeah maybe sheeping is fine but TH didn't really impress me otherwise.

nutella feels a little disconnected from the game, like she's saying a lot but not participating much. That said she probably ranks high in the list of people I've mislynched the most, so I'll tread carefully here.

Literally no idea how to read nanook. I don't know how to interpret he going against Sig. I don't know what to do with him. Send help.

TSP is also pretty meh. Dunno what to think of him yet.

Sloonei I do agree feels different but the argument that he is out of his element due to the post restriction is valid. Need more time to assess.

Help

[Tangrowth]

Hey [mention]Russtifinko[/mention], what are all of your reads right now?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Rats. I forgot that I wanted to ask Mac why he thought I don’t like playing mafia. That’s a false assessment. It’ll have to wait for post-game now.

I mean you literally hide from your wife to play mafia.

If that's not liking it I don't know what it is.

Pretty good these days at hiding the fact that I’m playing from her. I don’t hide from her in order to play. She understands that I consider this community to be part of my social life and that I consider several people here to be good friends. Thanks for making it sound like I go cower in a closet or something. If that’s something else to add to the list of things that people don’t like about me around here, then maybe I should just hang it up altogether. GoC sure made me consider it. Time changes people and forums.

Wow I hope that didn't come accross as negative, it was just a joke. I love playing with you or playing your games and I definitely enjoy having you around.

Sorry, dude.

Also my sentence was not very clear maybe, but I saying I feel you do like playing mafia.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Night 1 has ended.

Something foul is in my tower
What ever is that smell
It's that turtle left to cower
Without a bath inside its shell!

Epignosis was killed. He was:

Spoiler: show

You are Tiptup.



You have no special abilities.

You gain one Jiggy after each day phase in which you received at least one vote at the final poll tally.

You are aligned with the civilians and win the game when all mafia members are eliminated.

Day 2 is underway. You have 48 hours to lynch someone. I will update post count ceilings shortly. You may resume writing 4-liners for Jiggies if you want to.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Post count ceilings through Day 2:

59 Dragon D. Luffy
57 dunya
46 G-Man
71 M Plus 7
68 NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
68 nutella
38 Russtifinko
45 sig
70 Sloonei
34 speedchuck
56 TonyStarkPrime
58 Turnip Head