This makes me think that if dunya is bad, sig likely is too and this was an attempt to save a teammate as sig was overtaking Mac. (At least I think that's how it worked, but apparently polls aren't being saved in this game. Can someone either point me to it or confirm?) However, it actually makes me feel slightly better about dunya. Calling this seems weird when there was a decent chance (at the time) she'd be proven wrong. I'd still lean scum on her, but less so, and now leaning scum on sig, particularly if I'm right on dunya.
The case on Epi as presented here doesn't look great. I also don't really love that dunya just says "i don't know why epi voted for mac, maybe he did and i didn't see why. i'll check. but his switch from sig to mac put them tied, which is ok in my books." It sounds to me like saying yes, there's a case on Epi, but then ignoring it because reasons.TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Sun May 03, 2020 12:01 pmEpi said he wouldn't vote for Mac, took a simple answer from Sig to get off Sig, voted for Mac (I think) without comment. It's not a complicated case, but I'm willing to run with it.dunya wrote: ↑Sun May 03, 2020 10:51 ami agree on sloonei now, and probably nutella. i don't know why epi voted for mac, maybe he did and i didn't see why. i'll check. but his switch from sig to mac put them tied, which is ok in my books. and it was gman who tipped the scale then sloonei came on board at some point.
There are one or two points in Epi's favor.
As far as Sloonei goes, I have no way to judge how he's playing. He's based his play on a strategic element I disagree with the philosophy on. I think he's presenting it as a preemptive defense, but it's unclear.
I had a strong town gut reading on Epi before, and I think it's too optimistic to think that everyone who voted Mac was saving sig - no baddie team would give themselves all away like that so early. Maybe that's WIFOM, but oh well. So I'd say coming out of the vote, G-Man actually looks the worst to me. His vote was the one that put Mac ahead. I'd follow that with dunya, then Epi. All of that is predicated on sig being bad, though, and other than the lynch results I haven't seen anything on him that felt particularly alignment-indicative.
Here's my GTH:
Dragon D. Luffy: town
dunya: scum
Epignosis: town
G-Man: scum
M Plus 7: town
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME: town
nutella: town
Russtifinko: town
sig: scum
Sloonei: town
speedchuck: town
TonyStarkPrime: town
Turnip Head: scum
NANOOK was the hardest one here for me. Can anyone tell me if he plays a Vompatti style? It seems like it so far. I get the same sort of....lack of concern? if that's the right term, from TH, but really didn't like TH's posts about sheeping, which is why he ended up on the scum side.
Linki: RIP Epi. That NK makes me feel better about TSP - it doesn't make a lot of sense for a baddie to start casebuilding on a guy they're planning to NK.