M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sun May 03, 2020 7:07 pm
Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Sun May 03, 2020 6:14 pm
Vompatti is what we'd call a dadaist mafia player.
There is no obvious meaning to his posts. No direction or inherent logic.
You don't understand Vompatti, you experience Vompatti.
Nanook is fucking JaggedJimmyJay compared to Vompatti.
And yeah, this is Vompatti.
@Russtifinko, I wouldn't say he plays like Vompatti, but he does have a... Chaotic Neutral type of D&D alignment in terms of mafia play.
Vompatti is more like Chaotic Evil.
Thanks, this is helpful. This response in itself would make me feel worse about the intense rhyming, but given NANOOK's tone change today, I'm feeling better about him anyway. He's up from on-the-fence to at least mild civ for me.
Please don't @ me anymore - it does this weird thing where if I quote the post, my computer wants to autofill Russtifinko and delete part of my post if I hit the enter key, and I can't make it go away.
sig wrote: ↑Mon May 04, 2020 12:45 pm
Claiming is such a lame way to play. Especially when nanook isnt even claiming. Double that with claiming anything this early isn't sound strategy and since I didn't target anyone last night there couldn't have even been watching/tracking confusion.
It's a fake peek which nanook always says he wants to/has done.
Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Mon May 04, 2020 8:11 am
sig wrote: ↑Sun May 03, 2020 9:48 pm
SO a combination of factors effected my mafia read of MP.
Last game, which just ended with a mafia victory, the team included MP who had flipped civ, but was actually mafia. He reacted the same way there when I poked him as he did here and said I just hound him for no reason. I'm seeing the same game-play here and have the same gut feel.
Which is the main reason why I'm sticking to my guns here with my MP read.
Mac, rip was wrong there, not the end of the world. I do plan to reread some things, but overall alot of people are still just leans.
You do realize MP replaced someone else in that game and the one you poked was town, right?
You never interacted with scum MP that game.
Maybe check back on that game? Since he was mafia.
I do get why people are saying sig going after MP the way he has seems beyond the bounds of what a mafia would do, but this defense post just seems scummy af to me. He says claiming is lame, which, of course mafia would think that, and literally the #1 rule is that roleclaiming and infodumping are legal. If you didn't like that, you wouldn't have signed up for this game, so to complain about it now seems not genuine.
Minor thing here, but "not the end of the world" isn't the best reaction to a civ lynch I've seen, even if it is D1.
Sig also claims that NANOOK always says he wants to/has done a fake peek, which, what? A civ would never do that, and it would be a ballsy move for a baddie considering we can't be anywhere near LYLO yet. Also, he's saying DDL and MP are both lying about this other game. So sig, correct me if I'm wrong here, but you're saying that 1) you're not bad and also 2) NANOOK, DDL, and MP are all bad, and are all basically revealing themselves by lying to set you up for a mislynch on D2??? If I'm misunderstanding you there, and you see a way that civ NANOOK, DDL, or MP do that, let me know, but I just don't buy it. No way a baddie team gives up 3 members for one civ lynch on D2, especially if, as you say, you have no power.
Finally, where the claim comes from does seem pretty straightforward given DDL's point about jiggies, and another Page 1 rule says we can't share how we get bonus jiggies. So sig seems to be intentionally failing to understand that.
Turnip Head wrote: ↑Mon May 04, 2020 9:51 am
Doesn't Sig's treatment of MP make anyone else think sig is town because of it? Like why, as a scum accusing someone he would have to KNOW is town, would sig go after a guy using false logic about a different game and also run the risk of making it so heated and emotional and personal for both parties? Sig believes what he's saying or else he just simply wouldn't have bothered (as scum).
Nanook's red peek on sig, therefore and for other nanook-seems-sketchy related reasons, looks fake to me. Especially how he chose to present it with such a soft push. Using terms like "pretty likely" to be a red check gives him some breathing room if it turns out he's wrong.
TL;DR Sig's push on MP looks genuine. Nanook's push on sig looks fake.
If sig is indeed bad, TH is my top pick for a teammate. BTW, dunya was right about this:
dunya wrote: ↑Mon May 04, 2020 11:26 am
alright cool, we'll all lynch sig end of day. now can we play mafia cos im sure sig has teammates.
, since today seems relatively open-and-shut.
I would also peg G-man as a potential teamie, based pretty much solely on his D1 vote. My gut gives me some hesitation on that one, though, as does the fact that Epi was NK'ed: anyone else think it was really weird choice, given that Epi could've been expected to take a lot of heat for his D1 vote? He also had been attracting some attention D1 (on purpose, as we now know).